B
Bull
Guest
Steve-o, you've said it twice already, last year!!! If I were a selector or coach I wouldn't and I don't pick players on previous form of achievement, that's why Joe van Niekerk always failed so miserably. If we have to pick on form then Wynand Olivier has to get the nod.
I have to disagree with you both and we can argue about this all day. I won't change my opinion on Jacobs, he has always been made to look good by the players around him. He is not an inside centre that's why he played outside centre for the Valke on his inside he had the legend Ettienne Botha, outside centre for the Bulls and Sharks. Jamie Roberts and BOD really showed he can't defend in the Lions tour and he is slow, couldn't even catch Devon Raubenhaimer in the Sharks vs Griquas match.
There are a lot of political pawns in this team eg. Earl Rose, Maku, Ralepelle etc. But in saying that there are also other/white guys that do not deserve to be there Heinke, Ruan, Jannie etc. At the end of the it's down to personal opinion, I guess.
I have to disagree with you both and we can argue about this all day. I won't change my opinion on Jacobs, he has always been made to look good by the players around him. He is not an inside centre that's why he played outside centre for the Valke on his inside he had the legend Ettienne Botha, outside centre for the Bulls and Sharks. Jamie Roberts and BOD really showed he can't defend in the Lions tour and he is slow, couldn't even catch Devon Raubenhaimer in the Sharks vs Griquas match.
There are a lot of political pawns in this team eg. Earl Rose, Maku, Ralepelle etc. But in saying that there are also other/white guys that do not deserve to be there Heinke, Ruan, Jannie etc. At the end of the it's down to personal opinion, I guess.