• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

RWC Semi Final: France - Wales (15-08-2011, 21:00)

That was a red card. People want consistency from the refs yet they'll say the ref should have thought about how this being a semi-final? What bullshit is that? The law is very clear about these kinds of tackles and the decision was in line with them.
This is actually the exact type of tackle that happened to me and my T9 vertebrae suffered a compression fracture. It dangerous and must be rooted out, if that happens to be in a WC semi then so be it.
Clerc was deliberately picked up, twisted his and thrown to the ground with his hips way above his head. Red card.

Partly because the simple fact is we don't see that consistency. Never really do, for example in the pool stages apparently there was a spear tackle by a Frenchman on a Tongan (didnt see the game myself so someone may have to rustle up a video to confirm) but no red was given there? It's one of the things that frustrates me with rugby, I feel that interpretations of the law change far too easily from game to game.
 
If people noticed Rolland was in charge of that game also and well he is showing that he is consistent in that area and wheather people think it was a red or not he is doing his job and implementing the laws consistently.
 
If people noticed Rolland was in charge of that game also and well he is showing that he is consistent in that area and wheather people think it was a red or not he is doing his job and implementing the laws consistently.

I guess you missed the last penalty he gave against France then.. They had every right for that ball, even if Mas came from the side, there was no ruck, Harinordoquy went straight through, the ball was pulled back in by Charteris[I think] and there was no ruck form there, then Mas went for the ball, no ruck was formed so he didn't come from the side.
 
Wow, full credit to Wales, they played for an hour without arguably their most effective forward, their captain and lets face it, to keep a team on the back burner when you're a man down for an hour shows how deserving they were of a win. Sadly, it wasn't to be.

On the red card, IT WASN'T A RED CARD OFFENSE!!!!... Sure the rules clearly state that, but f*** me!, the rules also state that if a player drops the ball forward it's a knock on and how many times have we seen the ball get dislodged by opposition and it always gets called a knock on. For all those who are going on about, "It's the rules, Warburton was wrong", get over yourselves. There is clearly a BIG problem in terms of refereeing and the laws and as I've been saying all tournament. Controversial calls cost matches and Welsh are very unlucky, it was a damn yellow card offense and that's that. If they're going to be strict and truly enforce the laws BY THE BOOK, then do it with ALL the calls, make sure you've covered every f***ing law to the book, otherwise it's an injustice.

In saying that, Wales still could have won this match, Stephen Jones was terrible when he came on, and why he turned onto his left foot when he tried to droppy is beyond me. He wasn't forced onto it at all, he just looked really unco-ordinated, the way he took the ball, ran with the ball, passed, I think it was wrong to take Hook off.

The true match happens tomorrow and I can now say that whoever wins tomorrow should be awarded the cup right there and then

mate the final will be played next week against france, wether you like it or not. The winner will be decided then and if nz or aus win it then fair enough. However it isnt over.
France won tonight because of defense, a bit of luck and kicking goals correctly.
 
I guess you missed the last penalty he gave against France then.. They had every right for that ball, even if Mas came from the side, there was no ruck, Harinordoquy went straight through, the ball was pulled back in by Charteris[I think] and there was no ruck form there, then Mas went for the ball, no ruck was formed so he didn't come from the side.
Quite right. My father was screaming for a penalty to us but there was no way that that was the case.
 
**** Roland, **** France, **** all the pompous posters trying to justify that cheating French/Irish incompetent and **** the World cup ( only th ABs deserve to win now!)

Im off to the football...cmon the mighty Bloooooooobiiiiiiiirds!!!!!!
 
mate the final will be played next week against france, wether you like it or not. The winner will be decided then and if nz or aus win it then fair enough. However it isnt over.
France won tonight because of defense, a bit of luck and kicking goals correctly.
Yep good on you. I hope you get smashed next week. Bon chance.
 
I guess you missed the last penalty he gave against France then.. They had every right for that ball, even if Mas came from the side, there was no ruck, Harinordoquy went straight through, the ball was pulled back in by Charteris[I think] and there was no ruck form there, then Mas went for the ball, no ruck was formed so he didn't come from the side.

Agreed.
 
I guess you missed the last penalty he gave against France then.. They had every right for that ball, even if Mas came from the side, there was no ruck, Harinordoquy went straight through, the ball was pulled back in by Charteris[I think] and there was no ruck form there, then Mas went for the ball, no ruck was formed so he didn't come from the side.

Was that the one that Halfers missed by inches half way?

If so then we could have been looking at roles being reversed had Leigh got that. I had my head in my hands when the whistle went until I realised it was our pen.
 
I guess you missed the last penalty he gave against France then.. They had every right for that ball, even if Mas came from the side, there was no ruck, Harinordoquy went straight through, the ball was pulled back in by Charteris[I think] and there was no ruck form there, then Mas went for the ball, no ruck was formed so he didn't come from the side.

That was hilariously bad.

Only clanger dropped though.
 
Yep good on you. I hope you get smashed next week. Bon chance.
I just hope I see a good game of rugby next week bro.... and it will be better if australia is in it, cause I will surely win :p french aussie here
 
I guess you missed the last penalty he gave against France then.. They had every right for that ball, even if Mas came from the side, there was no ruck, Harinordoquy went straight through, the ball was pulled back in by Charteris[I think] and there was no ruck form there, then Mas went for the ball, no ruck was formed so he didn't come from the side.
Well first up Dangerous tackling and offside are 2 totally different areas. But if you are going to be smart I suggest you re-watch that passage. There was a ruck and French drove through but it was called brrn a ruck and Mas would've been fine if he stepped over and picked but he walked around the side and well it was a very lazy penalty to concede but there was a ruck correctly called as the original ruck had not broke up completely so still deemed a ruck. So the correct call was made and well Mas, by law, came in from the side so I didn't miss the penalty ha I think you missed the law ;)
 
**** Roland, **** France, **** all the pompous posters trying to justify that cheating French/Irish incompetent and **** the World cup ( only th ABs deserve to win now!)

Im off to the football...cmon the mighty Bloooooooobiiiiiiiirds!!!!!!

Whaaaaaa! Whaaaaa! Someone call the Whaaaaambulance!! Wahmbulance.jpg
 
Well for all the Welsh supporters, I'll repeat what was said to us AB supporters last world for complaining about the ref, "you can't blame the ref, you still had chances to win it"
 
**** Roland, **** France, **** all the pompous posters trying to justify that cheating French/Irish incompetent and **** the World cup ( only th ABs deserve to win now!)

Im off to the football...cmon the mighty Bloooooooobiiiiiiiirds!!!!!!
Hahaha hardcore rugby fan right here ...
 
The true match happens tomorrow and I can now say that whoever wins tomorrow should be awarded the cup right there and then

These comment's really **** me.

Hey they didn't do it pretty, they haven't play well this competition but seriously I'm sure every single other team who has been knocked out would have loved to play poorly and make the final.

This is a French team who finished second in the six nations this year, won the Grandslam the previous year and also beat New Zealand in New Zealand last year.
 
Well for all the Welsh supporters, I'll repeat what was said to us AB supporters last world for complaining about the ref, "you can't blame the ref, you still had chances to win it"

Do you want to know something? ....

We already knew that. No need to point that out.
 
Well for all the Welsh supporters, I'll repeat what was said to us AB supporters last world for complaining about the ref, "you can't blame the ref, you still had chances to win it"

that is so true. france won because the welsh didnt score enough points. And they had THREE clear chances of doing so. bad luck, good game
 
Well for all the Welsh supporters, I'll repeat what was said to us AB supporters last world for complaining about the ref, "you can't blame the ref, you still had chances to win it"
Agreed (and I'm not sticking up for Rolland) people will blame the red card but my point is if Welsh did analysis they'd know Rolland is strict in that area and well should never have even risked it. But fact they left so many points behind them is a factor that is been overlooked.
 

Latest posts

Top