Rugby 2012 player ratings? Players with 99

[NEEPS]

If thy are still going to do a star system thing nd if thy r gonna give scotland one i think tht it has to be Jonnhy Beattie cos if he keeps up th form he's in he's on his way to being th best 8 in th uk nd posibly in th northern hemisphere thts only if he keeps improving like he has been

 

[Conal]

he is quality but not better than immanal harnodqy(cant spell his name the french one!) or heaslip when they are on form

 

[NEEPS]

Yeh thats true but if he keeps improving like he is atm I think he will be better than them in a few seasons

 

[Iron Mike]

Pierre Spies

Strength 80
Speed 90
Acceleration 90
Rugby Skills 0

 

[dan the man]

I agree that no one should have a 99 rating, but Dan Carter should be right up there!!!
Piri Weepu should be close also (probably the 2nd best halfback on the planet... and he's a great goal kicker)
Pierre Spies is amazing also! he could probably play anywhere from no. 8 to 2nd five! A true athlete
Matt Giteu could also be up there although his form has slipped recently ;(
Brad Thorn and conrad Smith must also be right up there!

I know i'm slightly one eyed but i am a proud New Zealander!!!
can't wait to get my hand on rugby 2012!!!

 

[SelimNiai]

If thy are still going to do a star system thing nd if thy r gonna give scotland one i think tht it has to be Jonnhy Beattie cos if he keeps up th form he's in he's on his way to being th best 8 in th uk nd posibly in th northern hemisphere thts only if he keeps improving like he has been

Woah lets not get carried away. Beattie had a good 6N including that try against Ireland which I, as a former 8, loved to see. I don't think he is even close to best 8 in the North however. Each 6N team has a better 8 than him, albeit not by much.

 

[durbutter]

except england i'd say.

 

[SavageLez]

I agree that no one should have a 99 rating, but Dan Carter should be right up there!!!
I know i'm slightly one eyed but i am a proud New Zealander!!!
can't wait to get my hand on rugby 2012!!!

Carter is a great rugby player but what has happened to his kicking for posts?

 

[cyRil]

except england i'd say.

...and Wales.
We easily have the worst back-row in the 6 Nations.

 

[ranger]

Carter is a great rugby player but what has happened to his kicking for posts?

Give it up lez..

 

[gmoe]

All Blacks ratings
Mils.88
Jane.85
Joe Rokocoko.88
Conrad Smith.90
Ma'a Nonu.87
Dan Carter.93
Piri Weepu.85
Kerian Read.84
Richie McCaw.94
Jerome Kaino.84
Brad Thorn.89
Tom Donnelly.92
Tony Woodcock.90
Keven Mealamu.89
Ben Franks.82
I just added all these ratings together and divided by 15 and got a rating of 88 New Zealand Rating =88 but thats just on my own opinion

Tom Donnelly is not better than Thorn!

 

[alex]

i'd say haha.

 

[rugbyman9]

i no donnelly is poo were is ali williams yeah boy!!!!!

 

[raymondm2a]

dont for get to rate sonny bill.sonny bill will playing for the all blacks next year for the all blacks,sonny bill should be 99.he would play number 12.thats to make up for micheal jones not playing in the world cup back in 1994,all blacks would of won if micheal jones played.soth africa cheated and put the final on a sunday,coz they knew micheal jones wouldnt play.BRING BACK THE THE OLD SCHOOL LEGENDS,SO I CAN CHANGE HISTORY,AND PLAY MICHEAL JONES IN THE FINAL AND BEAT SOUTH AFRICA BACK IN 1994 WORLD CUP PLZ .

 

[SelimNiai]

dont for get to rate sonny bill.sonny bill will playing for the all blacks next year for the all blacks,sonny bill should be 99.he would play number 12.thats to make up for micheal jones not playing in the world cup back in 1994,all blacks would of won if micheal jones played.soth africa cheated and put the final on a sunday,coz they knew micheal jones wouldnt play.BRING BACK THE THE OLD SCHOOL LEGENDS,SO I CAN CHANGE HISTORY,AND PLAY MICHEAL JONES IN THE FINAL AND BEAT SOUTH AFRICA BACK IN 1994 WORLD CUP PLZ .

What a ridiculous post in every sense of the word

 

[raymondm2a]

Conrad smith 99

 

[raymondm2a]

bristol you not a new zealander,you would never understand.you got wales on your mind

 

[SelimNiai]

I understand that there was no such thing as a World Cup in 94.

 

[raymondm2a]

bistol go and save your wales,coz the japan a killing all the whales in the sea

 

[SelimNiai]

oh how very witty