- Joined
- Dec 17, 2015
- Messages
- 7,047
tolouse playing Dupont at flyhallf last week is quite the revelation
Totally agree. The offside wasn't even marginal. I think the hind foot was the try line, he was pretty much in the centre of the breakdown.How the hell have Scotland got away with both a high tackle and blatant offside right on the try line?
Scotland sealing off nearly every ruck.
Then borderline high, borderline offside
Not like France didn't tell Berry either.Dummy throw there, also let that go.
For me, I think the tackle offside line was there in the absence of a ruck as at least one player was over the ball. No way VDM went back behind it. Very lucky.Was it a ruck? Also does the tackler have to get back onside? It feels wrong, but I reckon he's got away in a grey area.
I think the first clearout arrived so the offside line was created.Was it a ruck? Also does the tackler have to get back onside? It feels wrong, but I reckon he's got away in a grey area.