I don't think Tindall is that bad
He's never been a creative player - him and Hape are very similar except Tindall is better than him
Him and Hape together is a bloody terrible combination though - as you said, no creativity!
Need someone like Flutey (or an on form Olly Barkley....) inside him, and then someone who can actually put a ball down over a line in the 14 shirt
He is a whole bloody foot taller than Shane, probably weighs three times as much, yet he didn't get the try - the mind boggles
Wonder what the scoreline would be with Ashton playing and/or Flutey/Tuilagi involved