Yeh, wouldn't mind those two starting. Jonathan Davies might miss out due to his injury, but if he's back this weekend and plays well, I'd still go with him. Bishop hasn't been all that spectacular the past month (solid, but nothing more) which is a bit dissapointing really considering this was his chance to nail down a centre berth with Davies and Roberts out.
I'm sure Gatland will go with Phillips, and that'll be fine, but it does mean that Wales will play a slower game than if Rees was there. Martin Roberts demonstrated for the Scarlets how important a scrum half is at introducing pace to a game. Peel used to do it for Wales, and Rees is probably the best option at the moment to do that (unless Peel's back playing well). I haven't seen Phillips introduce pace to a game for a long time now, whilst is insistance of box kicking constantly hasn't been working. Rees can come off the bench to add impact to the game aswell though.
Not fussed about the replacement hooker. Granted T Rhys Thomas had a disapointing game on the weekend, but so did the majority of Blues players (Halfpenny, Laulala and Bradley Davies not so). Can't see Owens getting a chance now, after not getting one when he deserved it and playing consistently for the Scarlets. Pitty, as I think he's got the potential to be better than all the rest, including Rees.
Ian Evans didn't really set the world alight in his brief period in between injuries, so I don't think he'll be involved this Autumn. He needs to get fit and stay fit for a period of time without being thrown into international games. I think it would be a mistake to go into a game against Aus, SA or NZ without a specialist 7 on the bench. JT makes a dire openside imo, can do the job in an emergency, but I wouldn't like to see him play an entire match there against Pocock if Williams/Warberton went off injured in the first minute.
Edit:
Dull thats the side Id go with although Ryan will be captain and how much id like to see Rees start at 9, hes best use off the bench as he is able to take advantage off tired legs. I do think Phillips is the better 9 at starting with Rees being able to change the tempo off the bench.
Have read that Jaime Roberts will miss the AI ... (don't quote me on this, I swear I have read this) ... but Bishop deserves a shot.
Ryan probably will be captain you're right. You're probably right about Phillips starting too, but I don't think it always has to happen like that. I think Phillips could be a great impact sub, maybe not at adding pace, but certainly at adding power and aggression. He can also come on to slow the game down too, to protect a lead if needs be. I also think dropping certain players to the bench for a game can show then that they're not automatic starters, and that there is competiton for their place if they don't perform. Phillips hasn't performed for Wales since his comeback game against Italy, so it could do him good.
Pitty Roberts will miss out, but it gives a chance to Davies and Bishop to show what they're capable of. Maybe for Shanklin to show that he's not passed it too after thinking about it. Competition for places is always a good thing, whilst we can never have too much strength in depth.