- Joined
- Apr 9, 2010
- Messages
- 11,758
- Country Flag
- Club or Nation
It will be interesting to see what sort of team South Africa puts out. You would have to think that with the series won you wouldn't want to risk anyone who was carrying even a slight injury, so we could see a number of changes as you suggest. Flip van der Merwe is obviously the next best lock, but given both he and Etzebeth are genuine tighthead locks I suppose we could see a debut for Franco van der Merwe (I'd prefer to see Flip though). Potgieter has the size and power to play a similar role to Alberts, but if they have an eye to the Rugby Championship I do wonder whether they will consider bringing in Daniels at 6 (and shifting Coetzee to 7). Daniels certainly isn't as pure 'fetcher' in the mold of Brussow or Pocock, but he is certainly better adapted to the 'traditional openside role' (which I believe will be required against NZ and Australia) than any of other squad options at the moment.
I can't see Morne Steyn being replaced (though I think it would be a good idea), and would be interested to see how Aplon goes if he plays at fullback. I'm not yet convinced about Aplon at fullback - he is a quality player no doubt, I'm just not sure whether he is a test fullback (he'd still be a better option than Kirchner though IMO....). I agree Frans Steyn would be the biggest loss to the team - not only because he is a quality player, but because their is no obvious replacement. Olivier could partner de Villiers, but he's only really been average at international level (I would have preferred de Jongh in the squad). I don't favour playing Pietersen at centre - he looks to be getting back to top form on the wing so I would leave him there (and playing wings at centre is seldom a good idea). I wonder whether we may see a test debut for JJ Engelbrecht (maybe from the bench)?
As much as it sounds like a better idea to play Daniel as fetcher, i thought the English pack showed on saturday that when Alberts and Kruger went off, our scrum became a bit light... Franco van Der Merwe and Keegan Daniel will certainly add mobility to the pack, but we'll lose strength and power...