• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

RWC: France - Japan (10-09-2011, 18:00)

I'm usually the first to defend refs. But Steve Walsh stuffed that big time. He took his eyes off the ball.
 
Yea, the ref will usually find out what colours the teams are wearing before he chooses his.
 
Is Steve Walsh not watching this game? Missing blatant knock ons. Also, I can't stand how here are penalties at scrum time. If your lineout sucks then you lose the ball, if your scrum sucks then you give up 3 points.. I don't get it. Should be free kicks so the better scrumming team gets possession rather than a shot at goal. Especially as half the time it's guess work.
 
Last edited:
The only mistake i've seen him make was the "not releasing" which lead to the first try. On everything else he is being strict while giving a lot of advantage.

The scrum penalties are fine, the Japan #3 is being dominated. You can't give a free-kick for anything that happens after the ball is fed in. The only free-kickable offences are things like "early engagement", "foot up" or "not straight".
 
Even tho the French side is stronger than the Japan side, the Japanese are playing some great rugby, very enjoyable match to watch...

Come on Japan!

The French are absolutely dominating the scrums and get another penalty...
 
Sponsored
UnlistMe
Back
Top