kicking was pretty even on the scoreboard but to me Barrett looked more confident kicking in those conditions. And IMO he clearly has more range, I think Cruden turned down at least one shot that Barrett would have taken because if range. Overall I thought barrett had slightly harder kicks at goal and Cruden I think missed one he definitely should have got.
obviously that intercept was a victory to cruden but it had a fair bit of luck involved and because Cruden did not commit to actually tackling anyone if he did not take that ball it would have been a clear line break for the canes may have seen the canes score at the other end. Savea with support would have been hard to stop.
Think maybe the area Barrett was strongest was his carrying and distribution in general play. While Cruden sits back and lets others do the hard graft, Barrett steps up and runs most of the Hurricanes plays. he just seemed involved in the game a lot more.
yes I am a barrett fan, but it's not without reason. As I said Compare Barrett this year to Cruden 2 years ago (when he was barretts age) there is no comparison IMO. Barrett is miles ahead of where Cruden was. And no cruden did not get much gametime is first year. mosty because a lot of that time he simply was not good enough and his goal kicking was 50/50 at best. I do think Barrett's potential is far above Cruden's. And I recon by the time Dan Carter is finally ready to make way for someone else Barrett most likely will have realized some of that potential and leap-frogged Cruden in the pecking order.
on messam, I didn't think his job in that game was to carry the ball close to the ruck he looked like he was running a lot wider than he has been and playing as a link-man/distributor rather than crash ball. Where he made his impact was on defense. Vito was good too but compared to Messam he went missing for periods. Though I hate making comments like that without seeing stats. Will have a look.
-
blah, I can't find good stats, though the coupe if sites I did fine had messam scoring More Virtual points than Vito, most of any loose forward so I guess I'm not totally bias ?
though Cruden Did get a few more Virtual points than Barrett so maybe I am? That intercept try would be the one thing that nudged him ahead, though that involved a fair bit of luck and huge risk if it does not pay off so I don't weigh it too much.