• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

The comparison thread

RWC 11 or Sidhe Rugby Challenge ?

  • RWC 2011 HB

    Votes: 80 10.3%
  • Sidhe Rugby Challenge

    Votes: 418 53.8%
  • Both

    Votes: 279 35.9%

  • Total voters
    777
What I mean by that is that nobody knows, only speculating clever-dicks are [strike]making the claim[/strike] trolling based on a couple of screen shots. As empty cans rattle the loudest, a few others who've recently shown interest have seen these comments by these so called "experts" and taken their opinions (trollings) as gospel. The Chinese whispers effect takes effect from there.

I'm sorry, but that bit about the empty cans will from now on be one of my all time favourites lines.

Now I remember why I don't visit the gaming section that often
 
SA and the SA super 15 teams are all in there, just different names that you can tweak yourself
 
Quicker, yes
Easier, no
Cheaper, not always (It's cheaper for me to buy games online from the UK than to buy them in-store in the Netherlands)

I can't remember what the question was, but one yes counts as a hit. :p
 
i think gameplay is what is going to separate the two rugby games.
I would agree BUT if they are both good, for example FIFA vs pes then longevity will come next and rwc2011 is going to really struggle there in approx mid October. Pretty much straight after the actual world cup finishes!!
 
RWC 11 or Sidhe RugbyChallenge?

Hi i just want to know what game you are buying and if you have enough time post why you chose your answer:)
 
both, will get RWC on xbox, RC on pc,and if that is good maybe a chance of getting that on xbox too.
 
Both on the xbox, I've been waiting too long. Plus I can play international rugby on RWC and club rugby on RC. Can't wait, I'm like a 5 year old at christmas :)
 
I will probably get Rugby Challenge first either for the 360 or PS3 might wait a few days see what most people are getting it on but eventually I will get both. Maybe for both systems as well..
 
going to buy both for 360 and take the player names positions and stats from the all blacks and wallabies on rugby challenge and edit the players on new zealand and australia on RWC 2011. Do the same but backwards with South Africa from RWC2011 to Rugby Challenge.
 
Top