No he's as good as gone he originally picked a 28 man squad arrogant or what you finished 5th 5th I mean 5th lucky Italy were in itEddie Jones is not going to get sacked. OK, performances have been poor since the RWC, but it would be grossly unfair to sack a coach with his record, not to mention massively expensive. Given the RFU coffers have been decimated by COVID-19, that is a big factor.
Yes, I'd like to see us winning and playing more attractive rugby, but there seems to be a strange expectation that Eddie is underperforming unless we win every game. That's just not realistic.
IF it does happen, my choice would be Pat Lam every day of the week. Yes, Bristol have given him a fair bit of money to build their side, but he's done just as well with the unheralded signings like Randall or Thacker as he has with the star names and his achievements at Connacht show he's very good at getting the maximum out of his players which is key as an international coach IMO. He also has his teams playing attractive rugby and knows English rugby well. What's not to like?
Baxter has done a great job with Exeter and seems like a top bloke who is able to build a great playing culture. BUT, we see very little variation from the tried and tested gameplan and that worries me. We also haven't seen him outside of the Exeter environment. I'm sure he'd be able to replicate that success again, but we haven't seen him do it.
He picked a 28 man squad full of out of form players who hadn't played, the word is foolish or stupid.He picked a 28 man squad because he had to under the COVID agreements with the clubs I believe ... nothing to do with arrogance.
I've said before. I can accept he took a gamble at the start, but once he saw the form he easily could have not brought in Mako, but he still did knowing he'd just come back from injury and was likely to be as out of form as the rest of the Sarries players.Weird that you name drop Itoje, when he's the only Saracens player no one had/has an issue with playing
Naming the Saracens players was always a risk, especially as they all (bar Itoje) had middling-at-best autumn internationals and then no chance to play themselves into form with their clubs.
I understand Eddie's hands were somewhat tied by the 28man squad limit, once they showed early doors not to be up to standard this series, but he's had opportunity to bring in players to replace them when we've had injuries
"Let us not be down-hearted. One total catastrophe like this is just the beginning!""One of the things I learnt about that, I stayed too long. It was my fifth year. The thing I've learnt about international coaching, you do a good job for four years, you build the team up and then you give it to someone else to do".
Eddie Jones - 2016
Thing is, I really don't think he would.That may be true to an extent, but I think it was a no-win situation. Had he not picked the Saracens players and gone for inexperienced alternatives, he would have been criticised for that too.
Yeah, I don't think anyone would've batted an eyelid (too hard, anyway) if EJ had said he was resting the Sarries lot for this 6N - especially as he was intending on resting a lot of his RWC starters in the Autumn anyway, but didn'tI admire the Sarries contingent's loyalty to their club. But Jones could also have made it clear beforehand that he would only pick players playing regularly so giving them the chance to find loan deals etc. He didn't, actively choosing to pick on reputation.
The treatment of Dunn more than any other player makes me fume. It clearly means a lot to him and he has put in some fine shifts in an underperforming Bath. No caps at all would be better than the pitiful amount of times Jones threw his way. Plus he comes across as just a genuinely nice guy too.As far as Odogwu is concerned though, they may simply have decided he wasn't ready after having had a good look in training. He'd hardly be the first player (not just for England) to have not made the 23 on his first call in to the squad. If he's outraged by that, then he doesn't really belong there IMO.
As good as his form was, it's not as though he has been at that level for a sustained period and TBH, I wouldn't have called him up. If I had though, I would have given him a run against Italy, but I don't think it's the massive snub it's being made out to be.
Other players like Tom Dunn have had way worse treatment.
No, but none of them will have had to hold tackle bags for 10 weeks solid either. After the initial thrill and learning you can't tell me that any professional sportsman worth his salt wouldn't have been dispirited by that.As far as Odogwu is concerned though, they may simply have decided he wasn't ready after having had a good look in training. He'd hardly be the first player (not just for England) to have not made the 23 on his first call in to the squad. If he's outraged by that, then he doesn't really belong there IMO.
As good as his form was, it's not as though he has been at that level for a sustained period and TBH, I wouldn't have called him up. If I had though, I would have given him a run against Italy, but I don't think it's the massive snub it's being made out to be.
Other players like Tom Dunn have had way worse treatment.