Touchyyyy
He's talented, but as I said, jack of many trades, but not really a master of any. Could probably play any position from 7 (not 8) to 15, and thats a talent rarely seen in todays specialist game. Plus we all may have trained with that guy who's amazing on a practise pitch, does cool things you dont expect from players their position, and that gets the wows.
Anyway if your argument is "you're missing some things" without identifying what they are (and i followed his little blue scrum cap as best I could) , I'd say its a little shaky. Show me some evidence and I'll pay attention
From his position beside the ruck, he probably leads the blitz up in defense, so I could give you that, and he does make good defensive reads. But he's a centre playing flanker for me (and more of a 13 than a 12 at that)