- Joined
- Sep 7, 2009
- Messages
- 9,423
- Country Flag
- Club or Nation
Jannie is crap, I've never rated him. Maybe Malherbe is solid, maybe. SA has is struggling at LH and TH and I don't really rate anyone at present but van der Merwe does seem to be improving.
I hear wherre you're coming from. My feeling is that we, ITO our props, are now where we were 1/2 years ago with our fly halves; Steyn was Steyn and we knew what we had in him but needed more if we were going to push for no.1, Lambie and Goosen both had asterisks next to their names and we knew Pollard was coming but he was 2 years off.
Now, Beast and Jannie are getting a bit long in the tooth (Jannie in particular), Oosthuizen is a failed experiment at TH so there is some time lost there unfortunately. Malherbe has had 4 solid outings for the Bokke but like Goosen at 10 doesn't seem able to string 3 games together without injury (too young and unconditioned for the top level still). The rest have potential but need the opportunity to either prove or disprove themselves (Nyakane and MvdM with the inside tracks even if I rate the Lions' starting props, at least ITO the scrum). Du Toit is just way too young at this stage. Give him 2/3 years and he'll still be young for a prop and we'll have seen if he can build on the potential he's shown. Post 2015 those spots will be open and I am sure we'll get to the bottom of who can make it and who not sooner rather than later.