• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

[2014 EOYT] Week 1 XV

iINDOMINUSxx

First XV
TRF Legend
Joined
Jul 28, 2012
Messages
3,802
Country Flag
Scotland
Club or Nation
Edinburgh
i think we should start doing this per week, so pretty much from this weeks Autumn test matches who would you have in your XV, it be hard for me as i didn't watch the games so i'll wait and let you decide.
 
I still need to watch IRE SA full, and then SCO ARG I haven't touched yet. Will get back here and make a real XV based on matches I've actually seen. Just so you know...your efforts have only been half-useless ;)
 
I would say Laidlaw at 9 for sure. McCaw probably at 7, Sexton at 10,
 
I havn't watched all the games either and probably won't. I would imagine only Sexton to have a look in from the Ire-SA match. While Ireland certainly had a good match as a team I don't think many individuals really stood out. I mean I'd be surprised if there weren't better performances from 15s in other matches though kearney had a good game for instance. Then again I didn't manage any other games as I had a full weekend so can't say.

EDIT; what a useless post this was... apologies to anyone taking the time to read.
 
^ :D yes...quite useless. Just about right
hand_gesture_outstanding_excellent_dartboard-r0b22ca4e0212488d9d54f07bfcfa723e_fomuk_8byvr_50.jpg



PLANET RUGBY INTERNATIONAL XV OF THE WEEK


15 Rob Kearney (Ireland) - So tough to leave out Scott Spedding, who has a statistically rich debut against Fiji with two assists and close to 200 metres, but we've gone with Kearney. Immense under the high ball against the Boks and a constant running threat with four defenders beaten, the Leinster full-back was excellent. Israel Folau also racked up the stats on a good day for 15s.


14 Sean Maitland (Scotland) - Ben Smith was his usual reliable self on the wing for New Zealand on his return to action, but Maitland flourished in an impressive Scottish performance. The half-backs set the tone which led to the Glasgow finisher picking up on all that was created, scoring one try and setting up another, as Scotland go into the week leading up to facing the All Blacks full of confidence.

13 Tevita Kuridrani (Australia) - Best number thirteen in Test rugby right now? We think so, as the devastating outside centre had Wales in pieces at times, notably for his try when he burst through Alex Cuthbert and Alun Wyn Jones. He made sixteen carries and ten tackles.

12 Sonny Bill Williams (New Zealand) - One poor decision aside, when he opted for an offload after breaking into England's defence, Williams was back at his destructive best. In fact he looks better than ever, beating five defenders with a pair of offloads and clean breaks among 16 carries at Twickenham. Rock solid in defence too. Jamie Roberts went well for Wales, with 17 tackles against the Wallabies, while Kyle Eastmond caught the eye.

11 Teddy Thomas (France) - It doesn't get much better than a hat-trick on your Test debut, but we hope Thomas shared a fair bit of his champagne with Spedding who set up two of his scores. Make no mistake though, the Racing Métro wing is one hell of a finisher. Jonny May gets a mention for his amazing solo try.

10 Jonathan Sexton (Ireland) - Man of the Match against South Africa, Sexton's control from fly-half was outstanding. Deadly off the tee, it was the Racing Métro fly-half's tactical kicking to the corners that won him the slot as he persistently pinned the Boks back. A mention for Aaron Cruden who struggled going for the posts but again, like Sexton, was brilliant in controlling territory.

9 Conor Murray (Ireland) - Maybe it was accentuated by England's poor kicking against New Zealand, but the Irish half-backs were clinical with the boot in their win over the Boks, with Murray's smart kick creating Tommy Bowe's try to wrap up the win. Tough on Greig Laidlaw who finished with three assists over Argentina, while Aaron Smith also kicked well.

8 Kieran Read (New Zealand) - Another fine all-round display from the current IRB Player of the Year. Read stood out with ball in hand, winning 45 metres in the process, put his body on the line on defence with nine tackles, and impressed with his aerial skills winning a handful of line-outs. Mentions for Sergio Parisse of Italy and young Adam Ashe of Scotland.

7 Richie McCaw (New Zealand) - He just keeps on getting it done. A moment of breakdown brilliance upset the Twickenham crowd and he was in the right place at the right time to put the All Blacks ahead with their second try, bringing in Cruden's bobbling pass. 14 tackles and nine carries, his engine keeps going. Credit to Rhys Ruddock, who took his matchday call up in his stride and scored Ireland's first try.

6 Sam Warburton (Wales) - Shifts over to the other side of the scrum due to McCaw's superb showing against England. Warburton though was so impressive at ruck time and alongside team-mate Dan Lydiate tackled well throughout. A mention also for Jerome Kaino.

5 Paul O'Connell (Ireland) - A colossus. No wonder Victor Matfield talked him up so highly before Saturday's Test. O'Connell played a major role in the maul that ended with Ruddock's try, while adding in 17 tackles. So physical, at 35 he's defying his age - a real captain's performance. Mentions for Sam Whitelock, excellent as ever as he nearly stole a try from under Danny Care's nose, along with try-scoring Alun Wyn Jones.

4 Jonny Gray (Scotland) - Scored Scotland's second try against Argentina and went on to make thirteen tackles alongside his big brother Richie. Both were excellent at Murrayfield as Scotland played a new, exciting brand of rugby that their supporters will hope is a sign of things to come under Vern Cotter. Mention for Ireland giant Devin Toner, who alongside O'Connell was outstanding at the Aviva Stadium.

3 Owen Franks (New Zealand) - Played a big role in the build-up to McCaw's try against England at Twickenham. He made a telling break which had England's defence at sixes and sevens before the ball was recycled and spun wide to his captain. Franks also held his own in the scrums and did his bit on defence with 11 tackles. Samson Lee went well for Wales.

2 Dylan Hartley (England) - Stood up well to the All Blacks' physicality and impressed with his core duties, especially at the lineout where his throw-ins were deadly accurate. Hartley delivered a 100 percent record in that department like the man he edges out, Wales' Richard Hibbard, but the England man gets the nod after a superb defensive effort with 18 hits.

1 Jack McGrath (Ireland) - 17 tackles for the Leinsterman ensured that Ireland didn't miss Cian Healy's presence too much in the loose, even if the scrum came under real pressure from the Springbok eight at times. Worked tirelessly in a great defensive team effort.
 
Telegraph Team of the Week
15.Israel Folau (Australia) - By his own remarkable standards Folau had endured a try-scoring drought lasting four whole games before striking twice in victory against Wales.
14.Ben Smith (New Zealand) - Wonderful take to help set up the Cruden try and possesses such game understanding and intelligence.
13.Tevita Kuridrani (Australia) - Wales had a pair of blockbusting centres of their own in Jamie Roberts and George North, but it was Kuridrani who created the most carnage at the Millennium Stadium.
12.Robbie Henshaw (Ireland) - Only played 40 minutes of professional rugby at inside centre before being selected by Joe Schmidt there against South Africa. Barely put a foot wrong and it was his kick set up Rhys Ruddock's crucial try.
11.Tommy Seymour (Scotland) - Rounded off an impressive individual performance with a late try against Argentina.
10.Jonathan Sexton (Ireland) - Player of the weekend. A masterclass of control, accuracy and game management. Immaculate with the boot.
9.Greig Laidlaw (Scotland) - Justified Vern Cotter's decision to appoint him captain by orchestrating Scotland's moral-boosting victory against Argentina. Arguably his best international performance.

1.Jack McGrath (Ireland) - Given that Mike Ross was severely lacking match fitness, McGrath had to shoulder a large part of the burden against a dominant Springbok scrum and joint top of Ireland's tackle count.
2.Richard Hibbard (Wales) – There were faults elsewhere in Wales' performance but the set-piece was not one of them where they won all their own throws at the lineout and dominated the scrum.
3.Samson Lee (Wales) – Demonstrated why Warren Gatland was prepared to jettison Adam Jones by serving up the Wallaby scrum on toast.
4.Sam Whitelock (New Zealand) - Denied an opportunistic try by referee Nigel Owens but there can be no doubting his overall influence on the game. Put in a monumental shift.
5.Paul O'Connell (Ireland) - Ireland's coach Joe Schmidt paid him the highest compliment a Kiwi can use by saying that O'Connell represents Ireland's "Mana" - their spirit and culture.
6.Jerome Kaino (New Zealand) - Justified his reputation as the "hit man" of New Zealand. Put in a couple of huge hits and surged past Dylan Hartley to set up Cruden's try.
7.Richie McCaw (New Zealand) - Topped the New Zealand tackle count and won several crucial turnovers, by fair means or foul, to frustrate England.
8.Jamie Heaslip (Ireland) - A typically industrious display at the base of a scrum that was often in retreat, tying together Ireland's grunt work with his finesse.
 
Telegraph Team of the Week
15.Israel Folau (Australia) - By his own remarkable standards Folau had endured a try-scoring drought lasting four whole games before striking twice in victory against Wales.
14.Ben Smith (New Zealand) - Wonderful take to help set up the Cruden try and possesses such game understanding and intelligence.
13.Tevita Kuridrani (Australia) - Wales had a pair of blockbusting centres of their own in Jamie Roberts and George North, but it was Kuridrani who created the most carnage at the Millennium Stadium.
12.Robbie Henshaw (Ireland) - Only played 40 minutes of professional rugby at inside centre before being selected by Joe Schmidt there against South Africa. Barely put a foot wrong and it was his kick set up Rhys Ruddock's crucial try.
11.Tommy Seymour (Scotland) - Rounded off an impressive individual performance with a late try against Argentina.
10.Jonathan Sexton (Ireland) - Player of the weekend. A masterclass of control, accuracy and game management. Immaculate with the boot.
9.Greig Laidlaw (Scotland) - Justified Vern Cotter's decision to appoint him captain by orchestrating Scotland's moral-boosting victory against Argentina. Arguably his best international performance.

1.Jack McGrath (Ireland) - Given that Mike Ross was severely lacking match fitness, McGrath had to shoulder a large part of the burden against a dominant Springbok scrum and joint top of Ireland's tackle count.
2.Richard Hibbard (Wales) – There were faults elsewhere in Wales' performance but the set-piece was not one of them where they won all their own throws at the lineout and dominated the scrum.
3.Samson Lee (Wales) – Demonstrated why Warren Gatland was prepared to jettison Adam Jones by serving up the Wallaby scrum on toast.
4.Sam Whitelock (New Zealand) - Denied an opportunistic try by referee Nigel Owens but there can be no doubting his overall influence on the game. Put in a monumental shift.
5.Paul O'Connell (Ireland) - Ireland's coach Joe Schmidt paid him the highest compliment a Kiwi can use by saying that O'Connell represents Ireland's "Mana" - their spirit and culture.
6.Jerome Kaino (New Zealand) - Justified his reputation as the "hit man" of New Zealand. Put in a couple of huge hits and surged past Dylan Hartley to set up Cruden's try.
7.Richie McCaw (New Zealand) - Topped the New Zealand tackle count and won several crucial turnovers, by fair means or foul, to frustrate England.
8.Jamie Heaslip (Ireland) - A typically industrious display at the base of a scrum that was often in retreat, tying together Ireland's grunt work with his finesse.

Would say thats a bit NH biased given the weekends reults, but having only seen the Ireland game can't really comment.
 
Is it acceptable to 'weight' player performances based on the strength of the opposition? :p If so, I wouldn't have Johnny Gray. Dave Attwood was strong for England, probably the only Engish bloke I'd have.

Warburton and Mccaw were both pretty immense so I'd agree about taking both.
 
eh these days I usually can't be fkd and only look at the way teams play rather than individual players, but I do watch for that too.
My xv would be something like (loosely based on the PR one):

15 Kearney or Folau. Noticed both, maybe a hint towards Folau.

14 Ben Smith for me. Special, makes special things happen all the time, simply.

13 Tevita Kuridrani

12 I don't know. SBW did make breaks and looked like his special self creating out of nothing, but then he botched two major opportunities incl. 1 that was simply 7points. He can't get my vote. Fofana was good, Eastmond...nobody for me.

11 Teddy Thomas hattrick on debut, good positioning every time.

10 Jonathan Sexton: it's gonna have to be Sexton for his pro effort in the game and then kicking in everything. Special mention out to the Scottish 10.

9 Laidlaw: Murray was good for sure insuring good continuity in a non-stop effort, but Laidlaw kicked almost everything in, got 3 assists, breaks, quick legs...

8 Kieran Read

7 Richie McCaw

6 Kaino/Warburton/Coetzee ?

5 Paul O'Connell definitely good.

4 Jonny Gray yeah I agree, good game for the youngster, even got a try.

3 I just don't know. Nobody clearly stood out, so no point being stubborn picking someone for the heck of it.

2 Dylan Hartley yup, he was good.

1 Jack McGrath made 17 tackles, damn...Ireland's pack was fantastic, and getting smashed at the scrum had little to no effect on the outcome.
 
^ :D yes...quite useless. Just about right
hand_gesture_outstanding_excellent_dartboard-r0b22ca4e0212488d9d54f07bfcfa723e_fomuk_8byvr_50.jpg



PLANET RUGBY INTERNATIONAL XV OF THE WEEK


15 Rob Kearney (Ireland) - So tough to leave out Scott Spedding, who has a statistically rich debut against Fiji with two assists and close to 200 metres, but we've gone with Kearney. Immense under the high ball against the Boks and a constant running threat with four defenders beaten, the Leinster full-back was excellent. Israel Folau also racked up the stats on a good day for 15s.


14 Sean Maitland (Scotland) - Ben Smith was his usual reliable self on the wing for New Zealand on his return to action, but Maitland flourished in an impressive Scottish performance. The half-backs set the tone which led to the Glasgow finisher picking up on all that was created, scoring one try and setting up another, as Scotland go into the week leading up to facing the All Blacks full of confidence.

13 Tevita Kuridrani (Australia) - Best number thirteen in Test rugby right now? We think so, as the devastating outside centre had Wales in pieces at times, notably for his try when he burst through Alex Cuthbert and Alun Wyn Jones. He made sixteen carries and ten tackles.

12 Sonny Bill Williams (New Zealand) - One poor decision aside, when he opted for an offload after breaking into England's defence, Williams was back at his destructive best. In fact he looks better than ever, beating five defenders with a pair of offloads and clean breaks among 16 carries at Twickenham. Rock solid in defence too. Jamie Roberts went well for Wales, with 17 tackles against the Wallabies, while Kyle Eastmond caught the eye.

11 Teddy Thomas (France) - It doesn't get much better than a hat-trick on your Test debut, but we hope Thomas shared a fair bit of his champagne with Spedding who set up two of his scores. Make no mistake though, the Racing Métro wing is one hell of a finisher. Jonny May gets a mention for his amazing solo try.

10 Jonathan Sexton (Ireland) - Man of the Match against South Africa, Sexton's control from fly-half was outstanding. Deadly off the tee, it was the Racing Métro fly-half's tactical kicking to the corners that won him the slot as he persistently pinned the Boks back. A mention for Aaron Cruden who struggled going for the posts but again, like Sexton, was brilliant in controlling territory.

9 Conor Murray (Ireland) - Maybe it was accentuated by England's poor kicking against New Zealand, but the Irish half-backs were clinical with the boot in their win over the Boks, with Murray's smart kick creating Tommy Bowe's try to wrap up the win. Tough on Greig Laidlaw who finished with three assists over Argentina, while Aaron Smith also kicked well.

8 Kieran Read (New Zealand) - Another fine all-round display from the current IRB Player of the Year. Read stood out with ball in hand, winning 45 metres in the process, put his body on the line on defence with nine tackles, and impressed with his aerial skills winning a handful of line-outs. Mentions for Sergio Parisse of Italy and young Adam Ashe of Scotland.

7 Richie McCaw (New Zealand) - He just keeps on getting it done. A moment of breakdown brilliance upset the Twickenham crowd and he was in the right place at the right time to put the All Blacks ahead with their second try, bringing in Cruden's bobbling pass. 14 tackles and nine carries, his engine keeps going. Credit to Rhys Ruddock, who took his matchday call up in his stride and scored Ireland's first try.

6 Sam Warburton (Wales) - Shifts over to the other side of the scrum due to McCaw's superb showing against England. Warburton though was so impressive at ruck time and alongside team-mate Dan Lydiate tackled well throughout. A mention also for Jerome Kaino.

5 Paul O'Connell (Ireland) - A colossus. No wonder Victor Matfield talked him up so highly before Saturday's Test. O'Connell played a major role in the maul that ended with Ruddock's try, while adding in 17 tackles. So physical, at 35 he's defying his age - a real captain's performance. Mentions for Sam Whitelock, excellent as ever as he nearly stole a try from under Danny Care's nose, along with try-scoring Alun Wyn Jones.

4 Jonny Gray (Scotland) - Scored Scotland's second try against Argentina and went on to make thirteen tackles alongside his big brother Richie. Both were excellent at Murrayfield as Scotland played a new, exciting brand of rugby that their supporters will hope is a sign of things to come under Vern Cotter. Mention for Ireland giant Devin Toner, who alongside O'Connell was outstanding at the Aviva Stadium.

3 Owen Franks (New Zealand) - Played a big role in the build-up to McCaw's try against England at Twickenham. He made a telling break which had England's defence at sixes and sevens before the ball was recycled and spun wide to his captain. Franks also held his own in the scrums and did his bit on defence with 11 tackles. Samson Lee went well for Wales.

2 Dylan Hartley (England) - Stood up well to the All Blacks' physicality and impressed with his core duties, especially at the lineout where his throw-ins were deadly accurate. Hartley delivered a 100 percent record in that department like the man he edges out, Wales' Richard Hibbard, but the England man gets the nod after a superb defensive effort with 18 hits.

1 Jack McGrath (Ireland) - 17 tackles for the Leinsterman ensured that Ireland didn't miss Cian Healy's presence too much in the loose, even if the scrum came under real pressure from the Springbok eight at times. Worked tirelessly in a great defensive team effort.
i disagree on a few things Sean Maitland played well but put in there over ben smith ? mm and Conor Murray did play a good game but i felt he didn't play aswell as Laidlaw
 
Top