The French need to change a lot more than the 6Nations, it's true but the only major international tournament you attend on an annual basis is poor preparation for a tournament as long and as attritional as the RWC.
This is true, as said, from a french perspective, re formatting the 6 Nations is not a priority. our domestic championship, number of matches played, the relation union-Clubs are much more of priorities for us if we want to become competitive.
I can understand that these factors are much less of an issue for Ireland or Wales for example. As the result, some changes for the 6 Nations would be more of a priority for them. And this is also an issue for the NH rugby, not all the nations are at the same level and have the same issues. Therefore, difficult to find a common resolution.
Argentina were not competitive and they still struggle away from home, if there was a relegation from the RC then it would focus the minds and heighten the tension, not lessen it.
Relegation and pressure out of it could go both ways. It can level up the rugby but also, it can create a championship where the only goal is to win, whatever the way you win. What I'm seeing from my point of view is that four nations and Super rugby have no relegation systems and they are producing a superior rugby. Therefore, my conclusion is that non-relegation system in 6 Nations is not the cause of the poorer rugby in NH. But I could be wrong.
That would certainly help matters but if they still only have the current 6nations format to rehearse within for a RWC then they will still come out underprepared.
The RC has gone up a gear and left the 6Nations in it's wake.
It's a distilling procedure.
The cream rise up through their clubs, to provincial representative level, then up again to Super Rugby level, then again to the white hot cauldron of home and away matches against the top sides in the world.
Take away the RC and its format and we would still produce great players like the Northern hemisphere does, but they wouldn't have the experience that comes from a long and gruelling annual international tournament at the very highest level. They would be a blunt instrument comparatively.
The RC allows the countries competing to sharpen their sword.
That sharpening of mind, fashioning tensile mental strength under pressure, has been borne out clearly by looking at the 4 semi finalists of this Northern Hemisphere Rugby World Cup.
If the format doesn't change to help the northern hemisphere players advance their growth through International experience then we will see the gap maintained and correspondingly the same result in Japan in 2019.
Two southern hemisphere teams in the Final.
I fully agree with all your points and I wish strongly I would have a say in the future of French and European rugby. I fear that it will be worse and worse for the french rugby as our clubs have no interest to change anything as long as they have the revenues to continue as they wish.
I think the british and Irish are much more organized and pragmatic than the french, they will adapt. Even England will come out stronger from this RWC.
Sometimes I wish for the french rugby that the Top14 starts to not attract players anymore, that it goes down the hill, that sponsors going away, for clubs to be forced to negotiate with the union and to find a new formula. I also wish some men of action at the union level ready to fight hard for agreements with clubs. I know sounds an awful thinking but I do not see any other way out if we want one day to reform the french domestic rugby and being able to compete with SH rugby.