D
darwin_23
Guest
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (dullonien @ Nov 7 2009, 01:10 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div>
Carters injury is a badly bruised calf muscle. I don't have any medical background, but I'd suggest that its the sort of injury that won't become serious if it gets knocked during the game (it might just get bruised again, and he can be rested against Italy the next week to recover) - as such I would definitely play him. I think he has just been on light training during the week to let the swelling go down, rather than to prevent the risk of causing a more serious injury. I could be completely wrong about the nature of bruising injuries though...
Roberts is probably being talked up a little too much on this thread. He's a great player, as the Lions test proved, and he will get better in his second season at inside centre. But I doubt we'll see him break a tackle every time he touches the ball again like in SA.
I personally don't think we've seen half of what Roberts is capable of, we've only seen his brute strength at centre so far. But seeing his length of the field break playing at full back for the Blues, showes me he's got a great step and some good pace aswell. I personally hope that we start seeing a bit more or Roberts' skills in this AI. If we can put him into space, he'll cause more havoc than being the one creating the space imo.
Gatland has just said that he doesn't expect Carter to be fit. Might be more mind games, but considering the fact he hasn't trained yet this week is worriying for NZ. Can they really risk chucking him into an international (especially one where he'll have Roberts and Shanklin running at him all day), if he isn't fit? I don't see NZ risking it, would be a pitty if he picked up a serious injury if he plays.
What do you NZ guys think. Worth risking it, or better to let him recover fully?[/b]
Carters injury is a badly bruised calf muscle. I don't have any medical background, but I'd suggest that its the sort of injury that won't become serious if it gets knocked during the game (it might just get bruised again, and he can be rested against Italy the next week to recover) - as such I would definitely play him. I think he has just been on light training during the week to let the swelling go down, rather than to prevent the risk of causing a more serious injury. I could be completely wrong about the nature of bruising injuries though...