I think it's more some people just don't like to say their club made a mistake (I do it knowingly others it's just built into them)
Yeah, the single-club pages seem to be split fairly evenly between fans who don't want to admit their club did a bad thing; fans who don't want to admit that their club did a good thing, and those who think there's a mix and good and bad.
In theory, it should be about 80% in the latter group, with the first 2 chipping in occasionally; but in reality it seems that those groups have a fairly even split, and most of the conversations are the first 2 groups shouting at each other, whilst the last group get tired of fighting and stick to the occasional intervention.
COVID messed up a lot of talented youngsters.
Also quoted for truth. the last 2 years have seen no action for the A-league, and minimal time available out on loan to the championship. So the 19-22 year olds haven't had the game time they usually would to develop their game out of the public eye.
And now we're back with a reduced salary cap, and reduced squads, and those same kids are 2nd or 3rd choice, and too close to the match day 23 to risk going out on loan. For example at Bath, with 1 injury at each of 9, 10 and 12; and our 9-10-12 axis are all under 22, and have less than a dozen appearances between them