• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

Italy v Ireland

My main alteration would be O'leary. He takes the fizz out of the attack and makes it very hard for our backs. I thought DOC was good and put in alot of tackles. POC was ok he seems to have helped our restart problems and improved our lineout. Leamy was weak as was Wallace. O'brien did his well but no one supported him and that didn't help his offload game. To be honest I think Ireland deserved to win as we had control for much of the match but then again the best thing about Ireland was Tommy Bowes suit.
 
Lads I don't understand gow people argue POC or DOC should be dropped. DOC had fine game yesterday and Paulie did his job too and lead the pack well. The problem was a backrow that didn't seem to connect as a unit SOB got man of the match and did ok bur not MOTM. Wallace and Leamy seemed out of it and well we need a natural 6 at this level.
I don't think Reddan will make difference either and a Stringer/Sexton combo is what is needed.
D'Arcy was shocking yesterday so I'd also suggest Wallace gets a go. ROG shows all people that doubt him again that he has a big role still to play.
Players I think deserve chop are Wallace Leamy O'Leary Best and D'Arcy.
Will that happen probably not but Ireland are in trouble next week against a French team that looked classy and even Scotland impressed me.
A player who impresses me alot this year is Richie Gray
 
Of course most the review is on the Ireland performance but from an Italy point of view a good (for our standards) performance, and distraught not to win. We really roughed up Ireland well, did good on the set plays and defended awesome. Bergamasco missed kick may have cost us as did the drop after the restart. It's not Mirco fault but we are a great kicker short of winning some matches. We miss too many to really keep the points ticking over.

On to some players. Really impressed with Sgarbi at 12. Especially defensively he was a tackling machine. All the forwards played a huge game as ever. Was sad that Gori got injured so early.
 
DItaly - You are spot on that Italy were excellent and well Italy were missing a few through injury too. Mirco had a fine game on the wing though and well Parrisse is a class act through and through. I really hope Italy can play like that on a continuous basis because if they do then they will start beating big nations. If they won yesterday Ireland couldn't argue.
 
Having had time to sit through the full match again, my view has changed a little bit. Italy got close to winning but it would have been a very fortunate victory for them had they done so. It's all ifs, buts and maybes but Ireland wasted three glorious try scoring opportunities. D'arcy spilling the ball a yard out was one, Sexton getting within inches of the line was another and O'Driscoll delivering a Tindallesque pass towards McFadden was a third.

Ireland carved Italy open on a fair few occasions and it wasn't the coaching that was at fault, it was the players. Declan Kidney didn't drop any scrums nor did he fumble the ball once. If Ireland are more clinical they'll give France a good game.
 
I don't think Parisee is the player people make him out to be .. he is a good ball carrier and a good leader but nothing really to say he is best in the world.
 
I don't think Parisee is the player people make him out to be .. he is a good ball carrier and a good leader but nothing really to say he is best in the world.

BLASPHEMY... May Sergio strike you down with his thunderbolts...
 
http://www.planetrugby.com/story/0,25883,16024_6733357,00.html

O'Gara says he was the reason Ireland won.

<!--/pr-art-subcol/-->
Ronan O'Gara may no longer be first choice fly-half but he insists his expertise was needed to guide Ireland when Six Nations disaster beckoned in Rome.

The Irish scraped home 13-11 at the Stadio Flaminio on Saturday with O'Gara landing the winning drop goal two minutes from time, denying Italy a first tournament victory in the fixture.
It is the type of cameo from the bench O'Gara is making his speciality since seeing rival Jonathan Sexton claim the number 10 jersey for himself.
While acknowledging Sexton enjoyed an accomplished afternoon, O'Gara believes his own nous was key in preventing the Six Nations' greatest upset since Italy joined the championship in 2000.
"At that stage in the game you go at it and don't think too much, you just do your job," said the Munster fly-half.
"The ability to do that comes with experience. As a youngster you don't understand that.
"I was told that once but it's when you get in my position - and I've been lucky to steer the Ireland and Munster ship for 10 years - that you understand it.
"Then someone like Jonny comes in and he's really good but to continue the analogy, when the ship hits choppy waters you bring someone in.
"Jonny played well, but I got backed to come on and try to win the game.
"It's important to have two fellas fighting it out because we can offer a lot going forward."
Italy allowed opponents rated 1/8 favourites to wriggle off the hook having done the hard work in fashioning a superb 76th-minute try for full-back Luke McLean.
Leading 11-10, and with Ireland flanker Denis Leamy in the sin-bin, they just needed to collect the restart and run down the clock.
Instead they immediately surrendered possession, enabling O'Gara to strike, before making a hash with their own drop goal attempt at the death.
For O'Gara the nail-biting conclusion evoked memories of the 2007 World Cup pool clash with Georgia, which Ireland won 14-10 after surviving a desperate late assault by the heavy underdogs.
"We were leading when Jonny went off and then Italy scored...it was looking like Georgia again and I was thinking 'no, don't do this'," he said.
"It was experience that was the difference between the sides at the end. It was important that when the gun was put to our heads we found another gear.
"Had Mirco Bergamasco kicked the conversion I like to think there was a try in us.
"It would have been an almighty kick in the balls for us if we'd lost and it was important we got out of the hole.
"I was very fresh when I came onto the pitch. We had plenty of time and I felt relaxed. It sums up my mood at the moment.
"I've been really excited and confident in camp during the last two weeks, which is unlike me!"
The coming week's inquest into what went wrong should be brief given Ireland were clearly placed in such a precarious position by their abysmal finishing.
Dominating territory and possession, especially in the third quarter, they butchered chance after chance with Brian O'Driscoll, Gordon D'Arcy and Keith Earls among the culprits.
When O'Driscoll crossed in the 44th minute, Ireland looked ready to begin the demolition process.
Instead they repeatedly floundered at the crucial moment and Italy, inspired by their magnificent captain Sergio Parisse, clung on courageously.
By the time O'Gara appeared with 15 minutes to go, the realisation that Italy could yet prevail gripped the Azzurri - and the Stadio Flaminio.
"We made a lot of handling errors in ideal conditions for rugby and they seemed to add up," said O'Gara.
"Add them all up and they probably equate to 20 minutes less pressure on them.
"At times it was very intense and there were nearly some cracking tries scored, but at this level nearly isn't good enough.
"Experience tells you that playing Italy fourth or fifth in the competition is the time to build a score.
"They're probably disappointed they didn't get the win."
Adding a conspiratorial element to the afternoon was the revelation by Italy coach Nick Mallett that referee Romain Poite had written to the Italian Rugby Federation apologising for the way he refereed prop Martin Castrogiovanni at the scrum in the fixture last year.
Poite was in charge again yesterday and Ireland were hammered 13-5 on the penalty count, with many of them occurring at the set-piece.
The Irish camp will review the video before deciding whether to pursue the matter further via official channels.
Head coach Declan Kidney reported a clean bill of health following the encounter and could be lifted by the return of Jamie Heaslip from an ankle injury in time for France on Sunday.


******; if Sexton was on the field he would have went for the drop-goal as well.
 
I think if any flyhalf was on the pitch they'd've gone for the dropgoal,
As would most centres, fullbacks, wings and Matt Dunning
 
O'Gara is a twat of the highest order. I'm no surprised one bit by this indulgent piece of self flattery. what a child.

*Awaits letter from ROG*
 
That'd be the same experience that decided an Up'n'Under was the best idea was the perfect idea against the Boks?


Arrogant prick.
 
Most positive thing this week was it was 4/4 for the Irish teams with the Wolfhounds, Seniors, Women and U-20s all winning.
 
Most positive thing this week was it was 4/4 for the Irish teams with the Wolfhounds, Seniors, Women and U-20s all winning.


It must be said that that's a pretty big positive.


Also, undefeated in 2011 *****ezz!!!!
 
And Drico has scored a try in every game! What a ledgebag!
 
actually sexton went a few months last year with a 100 % kicking ratio internationally I think.
 
Last edited:
Don't know if it's been mentioned already, but I thought the scrums were reffed poorly ... I welcomed the news that the refs were going to be more strict on the binding and the not straight feeds by the half backs, but this ref was pretty lax on both
 
Was I the only one two though the ref made some pretty **** calls, not only in the scrum like shaggy said.
 
The refereeing will never get sorted until there's a uniformed training seminar to make them all tow the same line. There are too many big personalities with the refs who all want to leave their own mark on the matches now which detracts from the calls. Removing the personalities and forcing them to call the games as the laws intend would mean they do their jobs properly.

They also need to scrap all the pointless laws, because as things stand there's so much over-officiating that things are bound to get missed.
 
Interesting fact about O'Gara winning that match:
Ireland actually lost the part of the match he was on the pitch 5 - 3
 
Top