Only if you believe that there's no talent involved in being a defensive organiser, solid scrummager, lineout jumper, reader of a game, thumping tackler etc... I'll leave you to your own thoughts.
As an aside, that's a blatant insult? Do we really live in a world full of left wing pussys now?
There are a few things wrong with your post.
* First, I'm not left wing...at all. Being
respectful has nothing to do with that, even though I see where you're coming from. And again, what if I were left wing ? You'd just insult me yet again for a second straight uncalled for time, there's something very wrong about that. You just don't go on insulting ppl friend, wtf is that ?? Calling my entire post "bullshyt" or wtvr term is the biggest insult you can give someone on a forum, you're insulting the one output I'm giving here, you don't know anything about me but what I post, that's all you have on me, and you take that and insult it...there are other ways you know: e.g.: "say dude, you're wrong here..." not "bullshyt".
Like, I come here on the forum and I see shyt like that I'm like, "where'd that come from ?!!" a guy calling my posts bullshyt like that !! It really is strange in hindsight if you think about it...
anyways.
* someone started a post by saying "screw the semantics". I agree. "Talent" turns out to be a bit of an ambiguous term. And I'm NOT saying England doesn't have talent, I'm not saying you suck, I'm not saying you're in the "wrong" anywhere; but you're soooo defensive you're not seeing my very clear point.
England's the best team in the tournament atm. Clear ?
...and now I repeat eeeevvverything I've said before...no. It's useless. I've given theory, examples, everything...I think you're disagreeing with something I'm not even saying. But it's clear, clear, clear...
I'm going to repeat one last example, and then that's it for my part: Ben Morgan is a good example. He's BIG, he's actually overweight a little. But that's something that works for no.8. He's big, fat and strong; takes at least 2 guys to take down, he can break through tackles etc...good use at no.8, job well done in certain matches. But he's certainly not talented. BUT he's still a GOOD no.8, despite the lack of talent.
Okay, this is as clear as it's going to get, ever: YOU CAN BE
GOOD AT YOUR POSITION DESPITE NOT BEING
TALENTED.
Not all positions require talent, some require hustle/energy/physical strength etc...
It's not a talent to play rugby team defense, it's cerebral, you set your mind to it, that's not a fkng talent ! :lol: It's not a talent ! You concentrate really hard, and utilize your skills and experience. Unless you have crazy timing, like off the charts, see things 10 moves before they happen etc...you've got this special defensive talent. But the regular bloke tackling is just playing standard team defense, it's concentration (with a tad bit of skill at times) and a lot of energy. A guy super high on energy, a strong body but with zero talent can tackle.
Let's see here: if talent is simply being big and fat and strong, then alright let's massage the truth, play the rhetorical semantics and shape word definitions into what we want; Ben Morgan is talented.
I don't think you're being fully honest, and I think you're too biased w/o even noticing I'm not bragging about other sides, bashing England or anything like that. AGAIN: just a mere remark that needs to be said that it's remarkable, isn't it,...that England are the best team in the tournament while other sides have such athleticism, creativity potential on attack etc...and it isn't the first time, but it's still a funny thing.
If we were comparing with France they would have more but the original point was that England lack the quality of Wales and Ireland, which if I may steal a phrase, is a load of ********.
You realize you're making this even more confusing with a new word like "quality", surely ?
Nobody on this thread has said that.
My point certainly isn't England don't have the QUALITY of other sides.