psychic duck
International
- Joined
- Mar 7, 2011
- Messages
- 5,094
He can be a "great" player but is too inconsistent for me to really be called one but we do have differences of opinion do we not!!
Incidentally, I do rate James much higher than ROG but he has had some bad moments too...
McAlister was more consistent as a 12. I think he would have got many more caps there for virtually every nation but dimly gifted his place to Nonu.
Yes, James has had his nightmares but they have stuck on him more. The only one that stuck on ROG was the Lions and even that was seen as a one off worst day, James has been stuck with his worst day as defining his whole career. If people had cherry picked James' career and labelled him as the king under pressure (like they do ROG), then I would note that too, but they have done the opposite. I saw a Dean Ryan article the other day lambasting him whilst claiming Skrela and Michalak were top fly halves. Laughable.
Ah yes, the old 'lying' tactic. Most people's first thought of Rog around here is the second Lions test in 09'. Get a real grievance to moan about.
Unfortunately the only "lying tactic" here is in this statement. Not very aware of your countrymen's delusions are you? I've seen exactly what the majority of Irishmen think, they aren't as objective as yourself.