• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

[2014 Mid-Year Tests] France

dunno much about Moore, but apparently he's 1m80/123kg lol. I mean give me an example that goes clearly against what I'm saying here, to the point where I have no choice but to reconsider my position.

And dude, in 2012 and 2013 (as far as I know, maybe 2011, 2010...etc...also) France had the best scrum in the world statistically. We collected the most penalties there, and gave away the fewest of any nation. Since the rule change, and very, very notably in the last 6N, France have given away a bunch of penalties, including against Wales, Italy, Ireland AND SCOTLAND. Had you told me this a year ago, and that we'd be packpedaling against Scotland, that Scotland would choose the scrum against us after penalty, or that we'd lose our own-fed scrums to teams, I'd think either Mas and Domingo both lost a leg or that they had some kind of quickly degenerative condition.
Nope...just rule changes.

Mas said himself: "you're taught how to do something and do it for over a decade, and then they change it in a day......"
Domingo spoke about it too in an interview, it's a topic that came up, everybody knows it in France, the scrum is our pride and there was even an entire article about it, the ***le of which went smt like: "the French scrum: from a strength to a flaw".
Dude, have you watched France scrummage in recent years: 2011, 2012, 2013; VS France in the 2014 6N ?? I'm "exaggerating" ?? I wish...
 
In fairness a lot of the Irish props seem to be loving the new scrum laws. Domingo was a genuine world class technician and Mas was also up there, Mas could be down to old age but Domingo is a weird one. I don't think that it's just big guys, Marler, Ayerza, Mtawarria, Healy are all 6 foot 1 and under. I think it is all to do with upper body strength now and the legs don't seem to be as much a driving force more a stability platform.
 
Cian Healy (when you're using the term "sort" like I am), Jack McGrath, BJ Botha, Rodney Ah You In Ireland alone. If you think I'm pushing it with 6'2

Well OK, will have to investigate about that.

If the guy comes from Lille or Strasbourg, i dont mind. It's the same thing : he has french blood :)
Maybe Xavier Chiocci. I dont know if he's a losehead or a tighthead ...

Otherwhise, why not picking foreign players ?? We did it with good players (Claassen, Nakaitaci or Le Roux), but not where we needed it. I mean on the 3rd row, we have Picamoles, Chouly, Lauret, Dusautoir, Ouedraogo, Burban, ... and for the center we already spoke about this.

But you will say me that Chouly comes from Neo Caledonia, Lauret from the Reunion, Dusautoir Ivory Coast and Ouedraogo Burkina Faso :)

Chouly is from New Caledonia ?? Wtf...he was born in Limoges dude....Dusautoir is mixed, and so is Lauret.
Just so it's clear, I wasn't making the comment that we need guys with French blood, at all. We could have 3 more guys who are originally from Algeria, it's fine. I'm just saying regarding the prop position, it's crazy to think we don't have anymore of those typical French Southwestern props like we used to, like that whole list I made up there.
I'm just saying: where are all those rugged Southwestern props ??!! Don't they like to play anymore ? Where are they ?? I don't see any in the Top 14.
And THAT...is a problem. Yes indeed.
 
Chouly is from New Caledonia ?? Wtf...he was born in Limoges dude....Dusautoir is mixed, and so is Lauret.
Yes he was born in Limoges, but one of his parents is from Neo Caledonia (or Wallis and Futuna, i dont remember)
 
Yes he was born in Limoges, but one of his parents is from Neo Caledonia (or Wallis and Futuna, i dont remember)

surprising...he looks all-white to me...can't find anything about that. Where did you find out, do you remember ?
 
Le XV de départ : Thomas Domingo (Clermont), Guilhem Guirado (Perpignan), Nicolas Mas (Montpellier), Sebastien Vahaamahina (Perpignan), Yoann Maestri (Toulouse), Fulgence Ouedraogo (Montpellier), Bernard Le Roux (Racing Metro), Damien Chouly (Clermont), Maxime Machenaud (Racing) (m), 10. Frédéric Michalak (Toulon) (o), Félix Le Bourhis (Bordeaux-Bègles), Wesley Fofana (Clermont), Gaël Fickou (Toulouse), Yoann Huget (Toulouse), Hugo Bonneval (Stade Français).

Remplaçants : Christopher Tolofua (Toulouse), VincentDebaty (Clermont), Rabah Slimina (Stade Français), Alexandre Flanquart (Stade Français), Antoine Burban (Stade Français), Morgan Parra (Clermont), Rémi Lamerat (Castres), Brice Dulin (Castres).

Hate to be pessimistic but this french team doesn't inspire any confidence in me.... and I don't want to sound like a broken record but where the f**ck is FTD??! It's been so long since Michelak has played a game he's probably forgotten how?!!

I've never seen this new winger Felix... is he any good? And is Sofiane still injured?
 
Le Bourhis had a good season for Bordeaux this year. At center. He played just once on the wing...

Guitoune is still out injured, very unfortunately. He'll have missed his first 6N, and this Aus tour where we really could've used his crazy skills and he would've brought lots of spectacle to the series.
 
Come on France I need a win!! One of those beautiful out of nowhere wins that we used to do so well!! Just one more win so I can keep the faith!
 
Come on France I need a win!! One of those beautiful out of nowhere wins that we used to do so well!! Just one more win so I can keep the faith!

while everybody, and I do mean EVERYBODY in France is saying Aussie sweep, and not even close for France, I do predict the one victory. France always has the right players to beat good teams, there isn't a point in modern Rugby history where France just don't have good players, we always do, so it's a matter of them coming together and producing a good, consistent performance. Which they obviously can, they're human beings.

Technically, I think France has shown they consistently play very good defense. If you analyze PSA's entire campaign since 2012, we've lost many games and that's terrible but we haven't taken any poundings:
Untitled.png

* Test 2 in NZ wasn't a horrible pounding, we just scored on none of our numerous chances, and the AB's took the little we gave them and made converted it into points. They scored 3 tries that night.
* As for Cardiff 2014, pathetic effort from France but Wales still only scored 2 tries, and with lots of difficulty/luck.

We haven't conceded a ton of tries ever since PSA. The highest total we've conceded for a match is 3.

So PSA has definitely brought a huge defensive culture to France, but it's obviously on attack we've never, ever, ever been even CLOSE to this bad. For France, it's an outright aberration. Ppl used to call our style "Flair" just some time ago goddamn it. But the defense is there, and if the attack finally clicks (because it eventually will, given our talent) we can get the one in the bag. Considering the defense we played against the mighty AB's on all 4 occasions in 2013, I'm hoping for a solid hold-up and no leaks against the Wallabies.
 
Last edited:
**urgent**

Guys I desperately need a site to stream sky sports! My friend I normally watch it with who has sky sports if off holidaying in Canada! ( I know selfies right!? )

If anyone can message me a streaming site I would be be very grateful!
 
This is embarrassing!! What will it take to get PSA fired?! I wona know! They have know idea what they're doing out there it's plain for all to see! No game plan what so ever absolute disaster
 
Wow we're really lost for words aren't we!? Not a single french fan has commented on here in a week! I suppose talk doesn't mean a thing at this point... we need results!!
 
Top