I was 100% behind Hartley last year for the starting spot but last 6 months or so i wouldn't have him near the team until he starts playing better and giving away less penatlys. I think whoever has the best form in the 6 nations will swing it!
-
Help Support The Rugby Forum :
2013 British and Irish Lions
- Thread starter samhall
- Start date
- Joined
- Dec 3, 2010
- Messages
- 22,774
- Reaction score
- 11,020
1. Healy
2. Best
3. Cole
4. Gray
5. Ryan
6. Ferris
7. Wood
8. Heaslip
9. Care
10. Sexton
11. Gilroy
12. Roberts
13. O'Driscoll
14. North
15. Kearney
I just fixed a ****ing laptop. I think I can pick a Lions team. Everyone else = Wrong.
Disclaimer: Don't take this post seriously I just feel very manly right now and think everyone should know how awesome I am.
2. Best
3. Cole
4. Gray
5. Ryan
6. Ferris
7. Wood
8. Heaslip
9. Care
10. Sexton
11. Gilroy
12. Roberts
13. O'Driscoll
14. North
15. Kearney
I just fixed a ****ing laptop. I think I can pick a Lions team. Everyone else = Wrong.
Disclaimer: Don't take this post seriously I just feel very manly right now and think everyone should know how awesome I am.
North? The man you constantly insult for being a simpleton who runs around with a tree in his arms?
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2007
- Messages
- 8,310
- Reaction score
- 4
I'd have Cuthebert, Halfpenny, Ashton and possibly a few others over North unless he shows he's capable of more than running in a straight line.
:mellow:
psychic duck
International
North has shown he's capable, just he's on couple months bad form recently. Ironic you put forward Cuthbert and Halfpenny ahead of North despite neither of them having done anything other than run straight their entire careers.
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2007
- Messages
- 8,310
- Reaction score
- 4
North has shown he's capable, just he's on couple months bad form recently. Ironic you put forward Cuthbert and Halfpenny ahead of North despite neither of them having done anything other than run straight their entire careers.
Cuthbert has shown himself to be a much better player than North over the past few months. Halfpenny similarly.
Bowe? Does no one else love the jammy *******?
- Joined
- Dec 3, 2010
- Messages
- 22,774
- Reaction score
- 11,020
I don't think he can get back from his injury on time tbh.
Forgot about that. Real pity.
irelandfan123
Bench Player
psychic duck
International
No Cuthbert hasn't, certainly not "much better" even if he on better form. And the logic that he's better because North can only run straight is odd considering that's all Cuthbert does. Cuthbert was equally as ineffective as North was in November anyway.
Also Cuthbert is a donkey, he has no ball skills whatsoever and is uncoordinated and unskillful, unlike North who you saw give an offload above, you would never see Cuthbert do that. What you do see him do though is comedy errors like the below ...
True, but North has shown over the rest of his (admitedly short) career that he's better than Cuthberts top (for him) form over the past couple of months.
An on form North vs an on form Cuthbert is no contest.
An off form North isn't markedly worse than an on Cuthbert.
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2007
- Messages
- 8,310
- Reaction score
- 4
No Cuthbert hasn't, certainly not "much better" even if he on better form. And the logic that he's better because North can only run straight is odd considering that's all Cuthbert does. Cuthbert was equally as ineffective as North was in November anyway.
Also Cuthbert is a donkey, he has no ball skills whatsoever and is uncoordinated and unskillful, unlike North who you saw give an offload above, you would never see Cuthbert do that. What you do see him do though is comedy errors like the below ...
A fine example of inductive reason this. Here's a clip of a player doing something good. Here's another clip of a player doing badly. Therefore the first one must be better.
Cuthbert has been the form Welsh back since the 6 nations. North has been largely ineffective since about the World Cup. Cuthbert was been one of the few players at the Blues who seemed to give a sod when they played us earlier in the season. I considered him a bit of a donkey at the beginning of the year tbh, but I've been very much won over by him.
Personally I don't think we've seen enough of North to say what his top form is. It may simply be a case of teams having figured him out.
Lads, is this going to be a thing every couple of months until the squad is actually announced?
Can we just agree that they're both too unjinky, too big and too Welsh and therefore resolve to pick wingers who are none of these things? Craig Gilroy and Christian Wade for the Lions it is then. Can we then fill up this thread with vids of them being jinky and awesome before I get back from work next morning? Cheers.
Can we just agree that they're both too unjinky, too big and too Welsh and therefore resolve to pick wingers who are none of these things? Craig Gilroy and Christian Wade for the Lions it is then. Can we then fill up this thread with vids of them being jinky and awesome before I get back from work next morning? Cheers.
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2007
- Messages
- 8,310
- Reaction score
- 4
Luke Fitzgerald is fit again....
- Joined
- May 28, 2010
- Messages
- 10,373
- Reaction score
- 4
North's issue is that his club is dire and don't know how to use him.
Look at Cuthbert v Sale. Some excellent lines covered. Pace to burn as well.
I can post clips of Bowe, Halfpenny, etc all messing up. I remember Bowe completely blowing **** against us and gifting Brew a try last year, but I don't think anybody would say he is a donkey.
I really don't get the North hype. Big young player=Good? Steve Hanley and Barrie Jon Mather must agree... (Oh god, I await Olyy...) North at the Ospreys would have been good, with Dirksen out.
Look at Cuthbert v Sale. Some excellent lines covered. Pace to burn as well.
I can post clips of Bowe, Halfpenny, etc all messing up. I remember Bowe completely blowing **** against us and gifting Brew a try last year, but I don't think anybody would say he is a donkey.
I really don't get the North hype. Big young player=Good? Steve Hanley and Barrie Jon Mather must agree... (Oh god, I await Olyy...) North at the Ospreys would have been good, with Dirksen out.
psychic duck
International
A fine example of inductive reason this. Here's a clip of a player doing something good. Here's another clip of a player doing badly. Therefore the first one must be better.
Your reasoning: One player hasn't shown "he's capable of more than running in a straight line" so another player who just runs in a straight line should be ahead of him.
No he hasn't. That has been Halfpenny by far.
Also sure North was ineffective in November, but he wasn't awful, and Cuthbert wasn't much better. All I remember Cuthbert doing of note was having one run down the touchline and then getting pushed into touch (as he couldn't step inside as he doesn't do anything other than run straight), and also getting embarrassingly (for a man of his 6 foot 6 inch size) smashed backwards by Luke Romano when Romano scored.
The entire Wales backline has been exposed as a bunch of lumps who just run straight, not just North, Cuthbert was largely shut down in November as well.
Also you saying North has been ineffective ever since the World Cup is wrong, he has been ineffective for the last couple of months or so. Ireland for one didn't work him out ... (also note another offload here that Cuthbert rarely ever does). Also he has scored 7 tries this season (third most in the league), which is as many as Cuthbert and not bad for an off form player.
As Olly says, an on form Cuthbert and an off form North are around the same level, and on form North and there is no contest.
Difference. Cuthbert makes a load of errors like were mentioned above, were all in the space of a few weeks. That was probably the only time Bowe has done that in several seasons.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2007
- Messages
- 8,310
- Reaction score
- 4
Your reasoning: One player hasn't shown "he's capable of more than running in a straight line" so another player who just runs in a straight line should be ahead of him.
No he hasn't. That has been Halfpenny by far.
Also sure North was ineffective in November, but he wasn't awful, and Cuthbert wasn't much better. All I remember Cuthbert doing of note was having one run down the touchline and then getting pushed into touch (as he couldn't step inside as he doesn't do anything other than run straight), and also getting embarrassingly (for a man of his 6 foot 6 inch size) smashed backwards by Luke Romano when Romano scored.
The entire Wales backline has been exposed as a bunch of lumps who just run straight, not just North, Cuthbert was largely shut down in November as well.
Also you saying North has been ineffective ever since the World Cup is wrong, he has been ineffective for the last couple of months or so. Ireland for one didn't work him out ... (also note another offload here that Cuthbert rarely ever does). Also he has scored 7 tries this season (third most in the league), which is as many as Cuthbert and not bad for an off form player.
As Olly says, an on form Cuthbert and an off form North are around the same level, and on form North and there is no contest.
Difference. Cuthbert makes a load of errors like were mentioned above, were all in just one season. That was probably the only time Bowe has done that in several seasons.
Anymore incompatible clips? Here's Cuthbert missing a tackle and North making an offload, therefore North is better. What an apt and applicable comparison. Also, I take issue with Halfpenny being the form back in Wales. Personally I think his kicking game is factored into his general play far too much, which, when evaluating back three players, probably isn't a worthwhile issue when comparing.
If you want to move North's form forward a game be my guest. He's been dire for a long while now. Overhyped, as Draggs said.
I don't get it?
Tell me whether I'm supposed to be angry or happy and I'll go from there...
Similar threads
