B
BLR
Guest
gingergenius: The ELV's aren't neccessarily 'fixing' anything are you seem to think, so the tired mantra you are using doesn't work. The ELV's attempt to 'evolve' the game, making it a little more refined, and if you are too attempt to say that the game is perfect as it is...well that shows how clueless you really are, the laws are messy at the moment and the ELV's act to clean them up. I mean, apes were pretty good at foraging for food and managing to survive, that doesn't mean that they weren't better to evolve into humans...change is good if it is bringing around a more refined game while still maintaining the basics that people liked about the old one, which is what the ELV's do
Putting aside all your preconceptions of ELV's being out to turn all rugby into running rugby the simple fact is that the laws take some of the subjectivity out of reffereeing, (although some sections will be ironed out before being implemented) the scrums have been once again made the main centrepiece of the game and the various styles of play have been given more options and avenues to be successful.
Now, this is to feicarsinn as well, the idea that all props will be skinny fit blokes in the future, I am not too positive. Sure in the Super 14 there has been a large amount of attackign rugby but that has always been our way, who is to say if it gets a trial in the NH teams will get a hold of it and use the free kicks to its advantage, packing scrum after scrum, slowing the game down to thier pace where attacks are launched off scrum after scrum into the opposition...if anything this will mean that the team with the most powerful scrums will win the day and the props places in the scrum will be preserved....
The rules are not a HUGE change, it's simply refining and evolving the game that stands today, the simple fact the NH seems to be against it without even trialling it under thier competitions shows how narrow minded you all seem to be, running rugby is enhanced sure, yet so is slower forward play and if you cannot see that, well maybe union is a little too complex for you to understand?
Putting aside all your preconceptions of ELV's being out to turn all rugby into running rugby the simple fact is that the laws take some of the subjectivity out of reffereeing, (although some sections will be ironed out before being implemented) the scrums have been once again made the main centrepiece of the game and the various styles of play have been given more options and avenues to be successful.
Now, this is to feicarsinn as well, the idea that all props will be skinny fit blokes in the future, I am not too positive. Sure in the Super 14 there has been a large amount of attackign rugby but that has always been our way, who is to say if it gets a trial in the NH teams will get a hold of it and use the free kicks to its advantage, packing scrum after scrum, slowing the game down to thier pace where attacks are launched off scrum after scrum into the opposition...if anything this will mean that the team with the most powerful scrums will win the day and the props places in the scrum will be preserved....
The rules are not a HUGE change, it's simply refining and evolving the game that stands today, the simple fact the NH seems to be against it without even trialling it under thier competitions shows how narrow minded you all seem to be, running rugby is enhanced sure, yet so is slower forward play and if you cannot see that, well maybe union is a little too complex for you to understand?