Who Are The Dirtiest Players In Rugby?

[samoa77]

richie mccaw and mauro bercamasco..

 

[Kyle Broflowsky]

I'd say Singapore's whole national team...they're so **** they only knoe how to play dirty
[/b]

Aah aah!!! :lol: Huge post!

 

[Kyle Broflowsky]

Schalk Burger is today's roughest player.

All-time winner are of course Brian Moore and most of the players of english pack from the early nineties.

On the French side, we had some legends like Vincent Moscato and Alain Carminati (nicknamed Carminator). Let's not forget Springbok's Garry Pagel who cleaned his boots on Jeff Tordo face. Tordo was bleeding like hell when leaving the field.

But for 10 years, players are not that dirty and there's definitely more discipline than before.

 

[australopitek]

burger is pretty dirty and also vickery

 

[Vambo]

. Duncan McRae?? Anyone remember the mess he made of Ronan O'Gara?
[/b]

To be fair... O'Gara has one of those faces that you just want to slap

Unsavoury incident which bizarrely didn't do McRae much harm cos he still ended up in the Premiership with Gloucester.

 

[danny]

Schalk Burger is today's roughest player.

All-time winner are of course Brian Moore and most of the players of english pack from the early nineties.

On the French side, we had some legends like Vincent Moscato and Alain Carminati (nicknamed Carminator). Let's not forget Springbok's Garry Pagel who cleaned his boots on Jeff Tordo face. Tordo was bleeding like hell when leaving the field.

But for 10 years, players are not that dirty and there's definitely more discipline than before.
[/b]

What about Serge Simon, he came to Gloucester at the end of his career and he was brutal. I think he played in the same pack as Moscato at Beziers- am I right?

 

[Matpel]

Serge Betsen, he needed a psycholgist to calm down, but the psychoologist hasn't succeded

 

[erwanseb]

Claude Dourthe
Vincent Moscato
Olivier Merle, managed a breaking leg headbutt
Danny Grewcock

 

[DiscoBear]

Maybe it's not a good exemple, but I think that sometimes Elissalde is playing dirty.
But I would say Mauro Bergamasco

 

[Bullitt]

Duncan McRae?? Anyone remember the mess he made of Ronan O'Gara?
[/b]

Because of which, I want to give him some money.

 

[hat]

burger and matfield from south africa

 

[terra06]

id say the whole SA forward pack

 

[Steve-o]

LMAO more Bok bashers

I love you guys, keep me well entertained

...Now I just have to buy you train conductor hats and teach you how to do that in front of a crowd, and collect the money afterwards, while I turn the handle of the music box

 

[peppers07]

I cant beleive no ones said Nathan Hines yet

 

[Kel_Sumo]

in terms of pure ill discipline either moody or grewcock in the english camp... but i always considered michalak a dirty player... not necessarily breaking the rules... just not very sporting in his play.

 

[Mr.blobby]

That Duncan McRae incident against O'Gara was absolutely disgusting - The moron looked happy about what he'd done. In terms of consistent dirty play, Vickery is right up their. But Andrew Henderson always makes me think he's gonna punch someone in the face though.

 

[paridjanian]

it's not so much the individual but the more undisciplined teams around that spawn the dirtiest, whether it's lack of experience or frustation that their team isn't very good, but its always teams like Italy and Fiji that produce the dirtiest players

 

[Juggernaut]

it's not so much the individual but the more undisciplined teams around that spawn the dirtiest, whether it's lack of experience or frustation that their team isn't very good, but its always teams like Italy and Fiji that produce the dirtiest players [/b]

Fiji...get the f**k outta here.

Yes, we play hard, we play rough but we dont play dirty....well sometimes but not all the f**king time.

and could you please name one player, just one, to prove your point.

Otherwise shut the f**k up.

 

[Steve-o]

<div class='quotemain'> it's not so much the individual but the more undisciplined teams around that spawn the dirtiest, whether it's lack of experience or frustation that their team isn't very good, but its always teams like Italy and Fiji that produce the dirtiest players [/b]

Fiji...get the f**k outta here.

Yes, we play hard, we play rough but we dont play dirty....well sometimes but not all the f**king time.

and could you please name one player, just one, to prove your point.

Otherwise shut the f**k up.
[/b][/quote]
I take it you didn't watch their quarter final match against the Boks.

Most high tackles I've ever seen from an international team. (I'm a poet and I don't even know it )

And not even one got cited.

 

[Dmx#1]

Everyone in the South African team except for S.Burger