S
stormmaster1
Guest
Trying not to sit on the fence with choices like Phillips/Reddan/Blair/Wigglesworth/Peel/anyother or Jones/Parrise. One player must get the nod.
1 Sheridan,
2 Szarzewski
3 Castrogiovanni
4 Hines, despite his temperament he had a strong tournament.
5 Gough
6 Dussotoir (probably spelt wrong, but he looked good imo)
7 Martyn Williams
8 Sergio Parisse, one player only. jones was good but there's only 1 no8 position
9 Mike Blair, pack was going backwards, and he still continues to perform at least as well as his welsh counterparts.
10 James Hook, more talented than Jones imo and his control of the game is improving. At present the choice between Hook, O'Gara and jones would depend on a game plan and the opposition played.
11 Shane Williams, tough one this but Williams might just sneak in the team
12 Gavin Henson, showed a good all round game, but no fireworks at the moment.
13 Tom Shanklin,
14 Vincent Clerc
15 Lee Bryne, I think Heymans is a more destructive player, but Byrne had a great tournament
1 Sheridan,
2 Szarzewski
3 Castrogiovanni
4 Hines, despite his temperament he had a strong tournament.
5 Gough
6 Dussotoir (probably spelt wrong, but he looked good imo)
7 Martyn Williams
8 Sergio Parisse, one player only. jones was good but there's only 1 no8 position
9 Mike Blair, pack was going backwards, and he still continues to perform at least as well as his welsh counterparts.
10 James Hook, more talented than Jones imo and his control of the game is improving. At present the choice between Hook, O'Gara and jones would depend on a game plan and the opposition played.
11 Shane Williams, tough one this but Williams might just sneak in the team
12 Gavin Henson, showed a good all round game, but no fireworks at the moment.
13 Tom Shanklin,
14 Vincent Clerc
15 Lee Bryne, I think Heymans is a more destructive player, but Byrne had a great tournament