• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

Scrum.com's team of the Championship

Jockstap

First XV
TRF Legend
Joined
Apr 18, 2009
Messages
1,590
15. Chris Paterson (Scotland)
The veteran fullback rolled back the years with two superb tackles to deny England's Ben Foden and Italy's Luke McLean and was also as reliable as ever with the boot. Injury opened the door for his return to the Six Nations stage and he grabbed the opportunity with both hands.
14. Chris Ashton (England)
The Championship's leading try-scorer exploded into life with brace against Wales and a four-try haul against Italy. In the process he equalled the Six Nations record held by England's Will Greenwood and Wales' Shane Williams. He was unable to add to his tally and break the record but there can be no doubt about his reputation as a world-class finisher.
13. Brian O'Driscoll (Ireland)
BOD was destined for legendary status long before this year's Six Nations but he offered a reminder of what a special talent he is by becoming the Championship's all-time leading try-scorer - his three tries carrying him past the mark of Scotland's Ian Smith. How lucky we are to witness one of the all-time greats in his pomp. Age cannot wither him.
12. Jonathan Davies (Wales)
Injuries allowed Davies the chance to nail down a spot in the Welsh back division and he did not waste the opportunity. A hamstring strain denied him a full-house of appearances and he may have escaped a potential citing for a trip against England but his game definitely benefited from the exposure.
11. Mirco Bergamasco (Italy)
The Azzurri winger may not have been a dazzling threat out wide but his you cannot underestimate his contribution to Italy's campaign having kicked his side to an historic victory over France in Rome. A little bit more refinement and Italy will be beating the best more often.
10. Toby Flood (England)
His rivals may have made more impressive cameos but Flood's consistency propelled England to the ***le and the brink of a Grand Slam. He dictated much of his side's creativity and bagged 50 points in the process to top the scoring charts. Just could not get the job done in Dublin.
9. Morgan Parra (France)
The multi-skilled scrum-half may have suffered at the hands of coach Marc Lievremont's selection policy but still gave Flood a run for his money in the scoring charts. His try against Italy could not prevent an upset in Rome but he endeavoured to keep his off-colour side from self-destructing.
1. Thomas Domingo (France)
The French loose-head dished out a scrummaging lesson against the Scots and his power-packed brand of rugby was at the heart of what Les Bleus managed to get right in this year's Championship. And having been rested in Rome he can wash his hands of the that game.
2. Dylan Hartley (England)
Wales tried to unsettle the England hooker on the eve of the Six Nations opener but to his credit he shrugged off those verbal barbs and did his talking on the pitch with a controlled and measured display - two common themes throughout his Championship showing.
3. Martin Castrogiovanni (Italy)
A hat-trick of appearances in our Team of the Week illustrate how the Italian tight-head took on all-comers and won. A cornerstone of an Italy side that shocked France and worried Ireland and Wales, he is a powerful ball carrier who racked up the metres with ball in hand when he wasn't doing his best impression of a rock at scrum time.
4. Richie Gray (Scotland)
The young Scot would surely be in the mix for the Player of the Championship if it were not for some dodgy criteria. His impressive industry in defence and attack gave the Scots another dimension and his emergence as a top class talent is a huge positive from a largely disappointing campaign.
5. Tom Palmer (England)
An assured presence throughout the Championship, England sorely missed his influence in Dublin. He was rewarded with the Man of the Match honour for his display against France but his lung-busting efforts were not limited to that game. A tower of strength.
6. Sean O'Brien (Ireland)
A rising star of the international game, the 24-year-old continues to attract plaudits and rightly so. Deployed first at No.8 in the opener against Italy before being switched to the flank following the return of team-mate Jamie Heaslip, he has torn into defences with ball in hand while shackling his rivals.
7. Sam Warburton (Wales)
Another young talent who appears destined for big things. Some may have been concerned about Martyn Williams' absence from the Wales squad at the start of the Championship but not anymore with the athletic and influential Warburton now finding the No.7 shirt to be a perfect fit.
8. Sergio Parisse (Italy)
Italy's captain cemented his status as one of the world's best players with a series of outstanding displays. He is an awesome presence with ball in hand and tenacious in defence but those attributes are arguably over-shadowed by his inspirational leadership.
 
Pretty much agree with that but could easily include Foden and Masi in that squad.

Although don't agree with Jonathan Davies being there or for their reasons.
 
Rees > Hartley, Lamont > Davies, Foden, Medard, Masi > Paterson...
 
agree with it mostly, i would say that no no.12 stood out, but feel as a biased englishman Corbesiero and Haskell deserve a mention!
 
Six Nations: PR's Championship XV

XV of the Championship

15 Ben Foden (England) - The votes tell the story. Andrea Masi did push for a late inclusion but Foden takes our opening slot after being a regular threat alongside Mark Cueto and...

14 Chris Ashton (England)
- He finished at the try-scoring summit with six scores and rightly deserves his number fourteen jersey. England hopes his form continues in New Zealand.

13 Brian O'Driscoll (Ireland) - A clear winner in our centre poll as BOD claims the majority of your votes. Three tries with his most recent performance arguably being his strongest.

12 Sean Lamont (Scotland)
- Our readers made the call on this one too and we can't argue with their choice. Andy Robinson may stick with the Lamont-Ansbro axis at the World Cup.

11 Max Evans (Scotland) - Glasgow will sorely miss their centre-cum-wing next season but Scotland will continue to enjoy his dynamism. Belying his size, Evans has been immense.

10 Toby Flood (England) - It may be argued that since the Achilles injury he suffered against France, Flood didn't quite get back up to his top form. But overall he was the best pivot.

9 Morgan Parra (France) - We are still not yet convinced about Francois Trinh-Duc as an international playmaker which is what makes Parra's performances that more impressive.

8 Sergio Parisse (Italy) - What can you say about this man? Parisse leads by example and is fully deserving of his place in our XV. Pretty much a mainstay in our earlier selections.

7 Sam Warburton (Wales)
- This guy has a massive future for Wales. Athletic yet powerful while having a rugby brain, Warburton should win many more caps in for his country.

6 Sean O'Brien (Ireland) - A consistent carrier for the Emerald Isle and still at such a tender age, O'Brien has made our number six jersey his own this campaign. Not one bad game.

5 Tom Palmer (England) - No good can come of moving to play in the Top 14? Palmer has proved that is definitely not the case and was a real foot soldier for Martin Johnson at lock.

4 Richie Gray (Scotland) - How the young lock was not included in the shortlist for player of the championship is a real puzzler. Gray was an outstanding performer from the outset.

3 Martin Castrogiovanni (Italy) - A tough call to leave out the likes of Nicolas Mas and Dan Cole but Castro cracks the nod after being a key cog in that victory over France.

2 Matthew Rees (Wales) - It was a voting tie between Scarlets hooker Rees and William Servat but we have felt that the former merits the jersey as he was without his starting props.

1 Thomas Domingo (France) - His absence against Italy slipped under the radar somewhat but not here as his impact was sorely missed in Rome. He has been dynamic throughout.

http://www.planetrugby.com/story/0,25883,16024_6828313,00.html
 
For a backline of the tournament to include two Scots and to nearly include an Italian is either a damning indictment on the sanity of the voters, a damning indictment on the coaching abilities of Robinson and Mallet, or a damning indictment on the standard of backplay in this tournament.

I will be going with the latter.
 
Can't fault Planet Rugby's team - that'd be my team too (though SOB and Castro are marginal)
 
Can't fault Planet Rugby's team - that'd be my team too (though SOB and Castro are marginal)


No they aren't. The only person that got the better of SOB all tournament was Parisse and I'm putting that down to inexperience. Still got man of the match that game though :p
 
4 penalties against Wales including two kickable = Bad game.
 
Lydiate and Wood were much more impressive for me


Then you must be watching different games than everybody else because he's been picked for every team of the championship I've seen.

Scrum.com
Skysports
Planetrugby
SportingLife
rugbyfix

Damn it Olyy agree with me and I'll stop.
 
Then you must be watching different games than everybody else because he's been picked for every team of the championship I've seen.

Scrum.com
Skysports
Planetrugby
SportingLife
rugbyfix

Damn it Olyy agree with me and I'll stop.
Or just the Irish ;)
Seriously, everyone knows that O'Brien has played well, is it that hard to believe that a lot of people don't think he's the best 6 in the world?
 
5934_full.jpg


Adonis
 
Planet Rugby team of round 5:

15) Lee Byrne
14) Tommy Bowe
13) Brian O'Driscoll
12) Sean Lamont
11) Vincent Clerc
10) Jonathan Sexton
9) Morgan Parra
8) Sergio Parisse
7) David Wallace
6) Sean O'Brien
5) Lionel Nallet
4) Richie Gray
3) Mike Ross
2) Ross Ford
1) Thomas Domingo
 
Top