Burger really is overrated stormer, he was awesome in 07, "meh" in 08 and sucky in 09, now he is "meh" again. He only performed in the Super 14, occasionally.
Beast have always been overrated in my eyes. Nobody really rates Smit as a player these days... Spies is another Super14 Hero, he was really good before the World Cup though.
I saw someone put Francois Louw as overrated? I don't think he is really overrated and he might turn out to be a legend in the future.
The biggest overrated player (mostly rated by the bulls on here) is Olivier, he sucks. The end.
For fun though: Underrated players:
Wian Du Preez
WP Nel
Juan Smith
Puke Twatson (He is a *******, but he can play
)
Sarel Pretorius
Harinordoquy
Haymans (Spelling? He scored great tries against the All Blacks last year)
Phillips (He had a great lions tour, don't know about his current form)
Weepu (From what I saw i the tri-nations, he is a good scrum-half)
Riaan Viljoen (Can't believe this guy isn't atleast on the bench to be tested in international matches)
Francois Steyn as a 12 (Everybody thinks he is this legendary fullback, I think he is a mediocre fullback, but an awesome inside centre)
