- Joined
- Oct 12, 2006
- Messages
- 4,662
- Club or Nation
I don't want to sidetrack the New Zealand demolition of Ireland thread so will reply here @Reiser99
Loosehead prop will become an area of concerns the provinces have nobody in their ranks in their 20s putting their hands up at the moment as international class. A wildcard could be shifting either Furlong or Porter to 1.
Hooker appears to be Niall Scannell's position to lose with Rónan Kelleher taking the Sean Cronin change of pace role.
Second row will see James Ryan captain the team. There'll be plenty of options beside him.
Backrow will see quite a bit of change. Dan Leavy will be back in the reckoning. If Ireland want to play a wide game, Max Deegan is the most likely 6/8 to hemp them do so.
Scrumhalf is a crapshoot.
At flyhalf, a lot depends on how Harry Byrne develops. If he develops quickly, expect Joey Carbery to move to 15.
Who knows what'll happen in the outside backs and midfield.
.............................
There's a lot to be said for picking in the moment and to hell with the next world cup. Nobody can legislate for the injury and suspension woes Ireland suffered in 2015 and we've just seen where a grand plan building 2019 got Ireland. Pick on form.
Looking at 2023:Looking at the current Ireland Squad and these seem to be the current players who will be there in four years. I'd say anyone at 33-34 is unlikely personally, though possible, so I won't include them. Dunno if there are any obvious injuries off the top of my head. Think maybe somewhere in the back row possibly...
As for younger players who might come through I'm sure our Irish contributors are in a much better position to comment.
Props: Furlong, Porter (Though both a tightheads)
Hooker: Scannell (Haven't seen enough to say he's the permanent solution, but others might disagree.)
Locks: Ryan, Beirne, Henderson, Kleyn (bit of depth here and Beirne can also slot in the back row)
Back Row: Conan, Stander, Van der Flier, Murphy and Ruddock. (All of them will be past 30 here and back row hasn't been hugely consistent for Ireland, so possibility to develop some younger players maybe?)
SH: McGrath (Marmion as well in the wings. However neither have really put their hand up to claim the shirt, potential for someone younger to upset the ranks?)
FH: Carbery, Carty (Again neither has stood up to claim the shirt post-Sexton and Ross Byrne also played in the warm ups. Hopefully competition might be healthy for them.)
Centres: Henshaw, Ringrose, Farrell (If Ireland can have Henshaw and Ringrose fit at the same time and on form they have an excellent centre pairing. This year didn't work out for them)
Backs: Stockdale, Larmour, Conway (Stockdale needs to learn when not to rush up, but attacking wise he's great. Larmour also looks like he'll be very composed at the back.)
So personally out of the current squad you have about 9 key players to develop around. I think SH and FH are a bit up in the air still and maybe have an issue with loosehead props, but as I said it's based purely on current squad.
Loosehead prop will become an area of concerns the provinces have nobody in their ranks in their 20s putting their hands up at the moment as international class. A wildcard could be shifting either Furlong or Porter to 1.
Hooker appears to be Niall Scannell's position to lose with Rónan Kelleher taking the Sean Cronin change of pace role.
Second row will see James Ryan captain the team. There'll be plenty of options beside him.
Backrow will see quite a bit of change. Dan Leavy will be back in the reckoning. If Ireland want to play a wide game, Max Deegan is the most likely 6/8 to hemp them do so.
Scrumhalf is a crapshoot.
At flyhalf, a lot depends on how Harry Byrne develops. If he develops quickly, expect Joey Carbery to move to 15.
Who knows what'll happen in the outside backs and midfield.
.............................
There's a lot to be said for picking in the moment and to hell with the next world cup. Nobody can legislate for the injury and suspension woes Ireland suffered in 2015 and we've just seen where a grand plan building 2019 got Ireland. Pick on form.