S
snoopy snoopy dog dog
Guest
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE </div>
-
Help Support The Rugby Forum :
G
Gavin
Guest
Not really a shock. Let's hope he can leave after winning the Heineken Cup.
M
munross
Guest
Will be super having him back in SA and playing for WP and the Stormers alongside Fourie and Habana ^_^
S
snoopy snoopy dog dog
Guest
Will Munster look to sign anyone or will they replenish from within their ranks? I assume there was a lot of truth to Munster courting James Downey when they learned De Villiers was on his way home.
Mafi and Earls seem to be the first choice centre partnership next season at this point in time.
Mafi and Earls seem to be the first choice centre partnership next season at this point in time.
G
gingergenius
Guest
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Intercept King JdV @ Feb 15 2010, 07:17 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div>
sure he's going back to the stormers?
sure he's going back to the stormers?
M
munross
Guest
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (gingergenius @ Feb 15 2010, 10:26 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div>
sure he's going back to the stormers?
[/b][/quote]
Well I can't really see him signing for another club in SA...
*Bulls->Already have a star no.12 in Wynand Olivier
*Lions->Would like to have him but they already spent enough on getting Spencer and la Grange isn't that bad...
*Sharks->Would probably like to see him play alongside Jacobs so maybe...
*Cheetahs->Highly unlikely!
*Stormers->He began his career with them, captained the side, gets to play with class players such as Burger, Habana and Fourie.
So at most the Sharks might throw him a deal, but I'm 99,99999999999999999% sure that when he returns to SA he will go straight back to the Cape
sure he's going back to the stormers?
[/b][/quote]
Well I can't really see him signing for another club in SA...
*Bulls->Already have a star no.12 in Wynand Olivier
*Lions->Would like to have him but they already spent enough on getting Spencer and la Grange isn't that bad...
*Sharks->Would probably like to see him play alongside Jacobs so maybe...
*Cheetahs->Highly unlikely!
*Stormers->He began his career with them, captained the side, gets to play with class players such as Burger, Habana and Fourie.
So at most the Sharks might throw him a deal, but I'm 99,99999999999999999% sure that when he returns to SA he will go straight back to the Cape
M
munstermuffin
Guest
JDV has left massive hint though he will return to Munster at some point.
Still I'm sure he will give us a massive effort for next few months and glad he came to play for us!
JDV :bravo:
Still I'm sure he will give us a massive effort for next few months and glad he came to play for us!
JDV :bravo:
N
Nickdnz
Guest
To me it sounds like any franchise getting him is a bit of a waste. He's essentially said, I want to play for the world cup, but then I'll **** off again. At least NZ is making Carl Hayman make a commitment to NZ rugby, before he rejoins.
S
stormer2010
Guest
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Intercept King JdV @ Feb 15 2010, 10:48 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div>
sure he's going back to the stormers?
[/b][/quote]
Well I can't really see him signing for another club in SA...
*Bulls->Already have a star no.12 in Wynand Olivier
*Lions->Would like to have him but they already spent enough on getting Spencer and la Grange isn't that bad...
*Sharks->Would probably like to see him play alongside Jacobs so maybe...
*Cheetahs->Highly unlikely!
*Stormers->He began his career with them, captained the side, gets to play with class players such as Burger, Habana and Fourie.
So at most the Sharks might throw him a deal, but I'm 99,99999999999999999% sure that when he returns to SA he will go straight back to the Cape
[/b][/quote]
Not sure WP fork out to have him with Fourie, de Jongh, Des Fountain, Grant & Newman all quality centers; the first 2 better than JdV IMO. Sharks might want him but they've lost 2 class 12's allready in Frans Steyn and Barritt to Europe; not sure if that means anything, maybe one of them or both might return to the Sharks, especially Steyn if he wants a spot in the Bok squad for 2011. Where he should go is the Cheetahs; he will be invaluable there; imagine JdV at 12 with a fit-again Ebersohn or Mapoe at 13; centers and halfbacks have always been the downfall of the Freestate and with the former two, plus Olivier and Pretorius from the Griquas playing for the Cheetahs, they would finally have a squad without glaring weaknesses midfield. Especially if the Cheetahs can get some results this year after managing to keep some players during the off season for a change. Also, the experience he can bring to the Cheetahs midfield.. he is not really needed at the Lions who have good options for midfield if not game-breaking.
Question is, can the Cheetahs afford him and would he fancy a move to Bloemfontein?
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Nickdnz @ Feb 16 2010, 03:35 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div>
Not sure he would be wanted/needed for 2012 onwards. Hasn't yet returned to the form he showed in 2008 and he's no spring-chicken at 30/31 (post world cup).
sure he's going back to the stormers?
[/b][/quote]
Well I can't really see him signing for another club in SA...
*Bulls->Already have a star no.12 in Wynand Olivier
*Lions->Would like to have him but they already spent enough on getting Spencer and la Grange isn't that bad...
*Sharks->Would probably like to see him play alongside Jacobs so maybe...
*Cheetahs->Highly unlikely!
*Stormers->He began his career with them, captained the side, gets to play with class players such as Burger, Habana and Fourie.
So at most the Sharks might throw him a deal, but I'm 99,99999999999999999% sure that when he returns to SA he will go straight back to the Cape
[/b][/quote]
Not sure WP fork out to have him with Fourie, de Jongh, Des Fountain, Grant & Newman all quality centers; the first 2 better than JdV IMO. Sharks might want him but they've lost 2 class 12's allready in Frans Steyn and Barritt to Europe; not sure if that means anything, maybe one of them or both might return to the Sharks, especially Steyn if he wants a spot in the Bok squad for 2011. Where he should go is the Cheetahs; he will be invaluable there; imagine JdV at 12 with a fit-again Ebersohn or Mapoe at 13; centers and halfbacks have always been the downfall of the Freestate and with the former two, plus Olivier and Pretorius from the Griquas playing for the Cheetahs, they would finally have a squad without glaring weaknesses midfield. Especially if the Cheetahs can get some results this year after managing to keep some players during the off season for a change. Also, the experience he can bring to the Cheetahs midfield.. he is not really needed at the Lions who have good options for midfield if not game-breaking.
Question is, can the Cheetahs afford him and would he fancy a move to Bloemfontein?
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Nickdnz @ Feb 16 2010, 03:35 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div>
Not sure he would be wanted/needed for 2012 onwards. Hasn't yet returned to the form he showed in 2008 and he's no spring-chicken at 30/31 (post world cup).
B
Bullitt
Guest
Hardy a surprise 12 months before the World Cup.
S
stormer2010
Guest
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Bullitt @ Feb 16 2010, 02:27 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div>
I would rather have heard that Frans Steyn is leaving Racing. Having both van Heerden and Botha back from Europe is already good news for SA although they might struggle to make the team.
I would rather have heard that Frans Steyn is leaving Racing. Having both van Heerden and Botha back from Europe is already good news for SA although they might struggle to make the team.
C
coonor
Guest
It's ashame as he was just fitting in. hope he comes back
M
mulldog
Guest
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (snoopy snoopy dog dog @ Feb 15 2010, 08:07 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div>
Word is Munster have Riki Flutey on their radar - http://www.planetrugby.com/story/0,25883,3...5961924,00.html
I think that Mafi and Earls is the way forward too even with De Villiers in the fold at the minute. I was at the Ulster V Munster game at Ravenhill a while back which Ulster won. Mafi and De Villiers were in the centre together and didn't like the look of them to be honest. I do still think Munster have two top class natural 12's there and if I was McGahan I would bite the bullet and pick one to partner Earls who is more suited to playing 13, and in my opinion Mafi would be the ideal choice. Also if Munster were to sign Flutey next year this would also create a similar dilemma to the one now so I do think he would be a bad signing. In my eyes I would also see Earls as a candidate to replace O'Driscoll at 13 in the future so playing him there would certainly have benefits for the national team. With Doug Howlett on the go next season too signing a top class winger should be at the top of Munster's to do list!
Word is Munster have Riki Flutey on their radar - http://www.planetrugby.com/story/0,25883,3...5961924,00.html
I think that Mafi and Earls is the way forward too even with De Villiers in the fold at the minute. I was at the Ulster V Munster game at Ravenhill a while back which Ulster won. Mafi and De Villiers were in the centre together and didn't like the look of them to be honest. I do still think Munster have two top class natural 12's there and if I was McGahan I would bite the bullet and pick one to partner Earls who is more suited to playing 13, and in my opinion Mafi would be the ideal choice. Also if Munster were to sign Flutey next year this would also create a similar dilemma to the one now so I do think he would be a bad signing. In my eyes I would also see Earls as a candidate to replace O'Driscoll at 13 in the future so playing him there would certainly have benefits for the national team. With Doug Howlett on the go next season too signing a top class winger should be at the top of Munster's to do list!
M
munstermuffin
Guest
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (mulldog @ Feb 23 2010, 06:18 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}></div>
Word is Munster have Riki Flutey on their radar - http://www.planetrugby.com/story/0,25883,3...5961924,00.html
I think that Mafi and Earls is the way forward too even with De Villiers in the fold at the minute. I was at the Ulster V Munster game at Ravenhill a while back which Ulster won. Mafi and De Villiers were in the centre together and didn't like the look of them to be honest. I do still think Munster have two top class natural 12's there and if I was McGahan I would bite the bullet and pick one to partner Earls who is more suited to playing 13, and in my opinion Mafi would be the ideal choice. Also if Munster were to sign Flutey next year this would also create a similar dilemma to the one now so I do think he would be a bad signing. In my eyes I would also see Earls as a candidate to replace O'Driscoll at 13 in the future so playing him there would certainly have benefits for the national team. With Doug Howlett on the go next season too signing a top class winger should be at the top of Munster's to do list!
[/b][/quote]
Mulldog Earls has been 13 for last 4 games in H'Cup,
We signed class winger in Johne Murphy,
Howlett will be giving us 1 more year too
Word is Munster have Riki Flutey on their radar - http://www.planetrugby.com/story/0,25883,3...5961924,00.html
I think that Mafi and Earls is the way forward too even with De Villiers in the fold at the minute. I was at the Ulster V Munster game at Ravenhill a while back which Ulster won. Mafi and De Villiers were in the centre together and didn't like the look of them to be honest. I do still think Munster have two top class natural 12's there and if I was McGahan I would bite the bullet and pick one to partner Earls who is more suited to playing 13, and in my opinion Mafi would be the ideal choice. Also if Munster were to sign Flutey next year this would also create a similar dilemma to the one now so I do think he would be a bad signing. In my eyes I would also see Earls as a candidate to replace O'Driscoll at 13 in the future so playing him there would certainly have benefits for the national team. With Doug Howlett on the go next season too signing a top class winger should be at the top of Munster's to do list!
[/b][/quote]
Mulldog Earls has been 13 for last 4 games in H'Cup,
We signed class winger in Johne Murphy,
Howlett will be giving us 1 more year too
Similar threads
