• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

[2023 Six Nations] England Squad

Think Mercer is the one we need back.
His time in France has added some more agression to his game to add to his speed and handling.
Reminds me of Read or Dayglo in his skillset, combine him with Tom Curry and Ted Hill would be an interesting combination.
I'm not so sure that he's added aggression.
He's added game-time, and higher calibre team-mates, and a gameplan that actually suits him; and his play had improved with that.
Granted, I've not seen a huge amount, but enough that I think it's more... honing his craft, rather than adding anything he lacked previously.
 
Gabriel Oghre has said that apparently the life for rugby players in France is so much better than here.
That's weird, usually you hear the exact opposite when players move to France, saying how amateurish it is there - I remember Brian Mujati used to say how weird the work environment was there, with things like strength and conditioning/nutrition just being left up to the players themselves (hence players like Russell and Zebo packing on the pounds when they arrived)
But then I guess that was a while ago now
 
Wales are threatening to strike over pay so the match being played is uncertain at the moment.

I'd think it extremely likely that this is a negotiating ploy. The WRU would have to screw things up spectacularly for this to happen...

(WRU: "hold my beer"..?)
 
I'd think it extremely likely that this is a negotiating ploy. The WRU would have to screw things up spectacularly for this to happen...

(WRU: "hold my beer"..?)
More complicated than that. WRU is negotiating with the regions and need an agreement between all of them I believe. They are also looking at long term sustainability, so I don't think it's as simple as players striking means they'll cave. While the players will sign contracts they aren't actually involved directly in the negotiations I believe. I'm sure their clubs are speaking to them, but this could easily drag on if a minority don't agree.
 
That's weird, usually you hear the exact opposite when players move to France, saying how amateurish it is there - I remember Brian Mujati used to say how weird the work environment was there, with things like strength and conditioning/nutrition just being left up to the players themselves (hence players like Russell and Zebo packing on the pounds when they arrived)
But then I guess that was a while ago now
I think there's also been a big coming together across the piece to help Les Bleus prepare for the RWC.
 
More complicated than that. WRU is negotiating with the regions and need an agreement between all of them I believe. They are also looking at long term sustainability, so I don't think it's as simple as players striking means they'll cave. While the players will sign contracts they aren't actually involved directly in the negotiations I believe. I'm sure their clubs are speaking to them, but this could easily drag on if a minority don't agree.
Yeah, it's undeniably complex (and a whole lot of unrelated things coming together to whip up a huge storm) but "players considering the option of going on strike in the build up to Wales' Six Nations game with England" [BBC article] is nowhere near the same as the game being called off if players' (justified) demands are not met.

Promises will be made to expedite the negotiations in return for continued 6N appearances.

Obviously Welsh rugby is up cachu creek without a padlo, but I doubt England will turn up at the Principality to find no-one to play.
 
Players are saying they cant get Mortgages etc because they have no idea if they'll have contracts etc. Not a good place to be.
 
Players are saying they cant get Mortgages etc because they have no idea if they'll have contracts etc. Not a good place to be.
This seems to be the real issue. It's not the players striking because they think they aren't getting a fair deal, it's players striking because they aren't getting any deal.

I think it was mentioned elsewhere that the English players 20 years ago threatened to go on strike over image rights. This is far more serious as players aren't even sure if they'll have a contract in 4 months.
 
Think Mercer is the one we need back.
His time in France has added some more agression to his game to add to his speed and handling.
Reminds me of Read or Dayglo in his skillset, combine him with Tom Curry and Ted Hill would be an interesting combination.
Plus I just wonder if adding genuine alternatives to the likes of Dombrandt pushes his form, lack of competition doesn't help drive up the standards or help build depth.
 
This seems to be the real issue. It's not the players striking because they think they aren't getting a fair deal, it's players striking because they aren't getting any deal.

I think it was mentioned elsewhere that the English players 20 years ago threatened to go on strike over image rights. This is far more serious as players aren't even sure if they'll have a contract in 4 months.
Just to clarify I know nothing about the issues facing Wales my comments were not so much about them but a far more basic selfish ideology that them being a big part of Englands remaining WC preparations is not great for us for many reason and this is simply one more.
 
Plus I just wonder if adding genuine alternatives to the likes of Dombrandt pushes his form, lack of competition doesn't help drive up the standards or help build depth.
Totally.

Competition is a good thing, provided the coach doesn't then start chopping and changing too much.

Dombrandt's got a pretty clear run at the shirt now and will know this is his golden chance. If he doesn't take it, Mercer and T Willis will soon be on scene, possibly Barbeary and even CCS if he can find a quick way to be English!
 
Totally.

Competition is a good thing, provided the coach doesn't then start chopping and changing too much.

Dombrandt's got a pretty clear run at the shirt now and will know this is his golden chance. If he doesn't take it, Mercer and T Willis will soon be on scene, possibly Barbeary and even CCS if he can find a quick way to be English!
The main mistakes dombrandt had been making are when he's been running some pretty solid lines but the timing has been off or he's fumbled the pass. Those start going to have and I think he will be cutting through defences in a way Vunipola never did.
 
The main mistakes dombrandt had been making are when he's been running some pretty solid lines but the timing has been off or he's fumbled the pass. Those start going to have and I think he will be cutting through defences in a way Vunipola never did.
Yep, that's his USP but they have to start sticking. There have been other issues though like a fumbled kick off and missing that tackle on McVdM.

Everyone can have an off day. Maybe generally though he's anxious about his position and just trying a little too hard.
 
I think there's definitely an element of 'trying a little too hard'. As @Which Tyler said, if he'd taken a couple of those passes, I think we'd all have quite a different view of his performances.

My perception is that he's actually done fairly well on the whole but is getting some stick for not doing the things he's usually known for.
 
Kind of worried about their self-awareness if they didn't realise how bad it was. Also more criticism for EJ if he either hadn't identified the issue or hadn't actually told his players.

Honestly, pretty much everyone who watches England knows Mako will probably collapse at the scrum so not sure what he's surprised about.
 
Kind of worried about their self-awareness if they didn't realise how bad it was. Also more criticism for EJ if he either hadn't identified the issue or hadn't actually told his players.

Honestly, pretty much everyone who watches England knows Mako will probably collapse at the scrum so not sure what he's surprised about.
More reason to think EJ was a Trojan Horse.
He played good guy for a few months to lure us into a false sense, then did his bit to put us back.
Mind you it looks like the Aussies have got to go as far as us yo catch up
 
Top