• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

2014 Six Nations: Wales vs Italy (Round 1)

Samson Lee's continued omission is just stubbornness. Bevington on the bench is a really poor selection as well given his form this season.
tbf, Jenkins is injured so Gatland's hand is forced on Bevington... but I still think Phil John should have been in the original squad given how well the Scarlets scrum is doing...
 
I don't doubt that Rhodri Jones could be a future talent. The difference is that I am certain Samson Lee will be a future talent - heck he's already a talent right now.
 
Can't get my head around the omission of Samson Lee either. Personally I would have started him with Adam Jones on the bench to keep Jones fresh for the bigger games and to give Samson some experience against a strong Italian scrum. I think Rhodri Jones has potential, but I still doubt his scrummaging ability on the tight against a strong loosehead. Given the chance I think Samson Lee could really push Adam Jones leading into the RWC which would put us in a great position.

Bevington has really struggled with the new scrummaging laws, so I'm a little worried about how our scrum will go if both he and Rhodri Jones are on the field during the final stages of the game. With Gethin injured maybe there wasn't much option. Is Rhys Gill injured? As for Phil John, he's had a solid season and has really taken to the new scrummaging laws, but I don't think he's international class myself, although neither is Bevington atm!

Good to see Hibbard and Owens have recovered from injury.

On to the much debated 10 position. Priestland has looked better now that he's had a period of injury free rugby, so hopefully he can inject a little more creativity into the Welsh backline, getting more out of North, Cuthbert, Roberts etc. I would have probably stuck with the safer option of Biggar though, who's still playing well for the Ospreys despite their disappointing results in the HC.

It'll be interesting to see who Gatland picks in the backrow for the game against Ireland. He seems to pick Lydiate whenever he's fit, but if Tipuric has a strong game against Italy, then I'd still like to see the backrow of Warburton, Tipuric and Faletau; well if Warburton deserves to come back in that is. If Lydiate and Tips star against Italy, they should be retained imo.
 
Nothing wrong with Rhodri Jones, did a tidy job in November (don't forget).

Samson Lee discipline again has cost him.
 
Nothing wrong with Rhodri Jones, did a tidy job in November (don't forget).

Samson Lee discipline again has cost him.

I'm still unsure how much Rodri Jones was tested scrum time in the Autumn. Argentina was the biggest test, and he was up against a good prop in Ayerza so maybe I'm wrong.

Yeah Samson's discipline is still a problem I agree.
 
Lydiate has been released from the squad to go back to Wales as his first child is expected to be born this weekend. May miss the game. Just reported on the BBC website.
 
Woooo Paul James! Hibbard and Owens back is a huge boost, would like to cap Parry once before he goes west.
Coombs over Ball is a mistake, Ball is a genuine SR. Glad to see Tipuric starting. If Warburton is fit and Lydiate doesn't play could we see the pairing that played England reunite? Shingler and Tipuric doesn't fill me with confidence as far as the heavy tackling work goes, so if they did play together I hope AWJ and Chart are ready for a long day.

Priestland has improved, but not to a level higher than Biggar that merits the latter being dropped. Shame that the staff can't see past their biases (Richie Rees...). Bevington was already a bad scrummager, who else do we have? Don't say Phil John, I'll red the next person that does. Scott has been tearing it up for Turks, and isn't expected to replicate Roberts for the first time in years, so looking forward to seeing him have a run. North been in best club form I've seen from him, give him some space and let him go to work. Saints actually use him out wide and not at a second crash ball centre, who would have guessed he was a good wing?!
 
Personally I think this is the ideal game to try the so-called 'weaker' options, whilst retaining a majority of experienced and stronger players in other positions. No disrespect to Italy, but it's a far better game to try out options than away at Twickers etc.
 
I wonder what the Italian backline will be like, with the options available I could very well end up rating it worse than every single side in the Pacific Nations Cup let alone the Six Nations.
 
You never know. They have nothing to lose, so could put on a bit of a show (if they get the ball). Unsure if Mirco(sp?) Bergamasco is in the side, but money on a red card if he is, as his head's gone nowadays, and if Wales do open the floodgates, I can see him lashing out at someone.
 
If Italy play loose it could get ugly, though without bonus points it isn't as harmful to get blown out if you don't have ***le aspirations.
 
Bevington was already a bad scrummager, who else do we have? Don't say Phil John, I'll red the next person that does.

Phil John :p

On a more serious note, I'd have Gill as 3rd choice easily, but have a feeling he's injured? After that, Rob Evans probably, but he needs more experience at regional level. Showing some good signs in the scrum, but also has a bit of a discipline problem. He could be a wild card for the RWC though!
 
I must be the only guy in Wales to rate Phil John, and I'm not even Welsh. :p

Laugh all you want, he's Wales' number 1 number 1.
 
I must be the only guy in Wales to rate Phil John, and I'm not even Welsh. :p

Laugh all you want, he's Wales' number 1 number 1.

ISeeWhatYouDidThereWhiteSS.png


If Italy play loose it could get ugly, though without bonus points it isn't as harmful to get blown out if you don't have ***le aspirations.

dude. Wales are going to make sweet love to Italy. It'll be a very romantic night in Cardiff, I'm sure...
 
How could you not pick Lee, he is scared of no ****er.

BfAZ_aWCcAEpR4b.jpg
 
Jesus I thought rugby players were supposed to be educated. "Anythink", "wid". That's got to be a joke surely?
 
Top