With that said, here are some players I'd like to see for the training squad:
Props: Beast Mtawarira, Jannie Du Plessis, Coenie Oosthuizen, Frans Malherbe these 4 are the incumbents and rightfully so yes, Caylib Oosthuizen, Marcel van der Merwe and Morne Mellett. No Lourens Adriaanse? I thought he did pretty well with the Bokke. I've also been very impressed with the Lions' props this year though getting a Bok call-up playing for the Lions will take a bit of a miracle I suppose though it shouldn't.
Hookers: Bismarck Du Plessis, Adriaan Strauss, Callie Visagiemy personal preference would be Ntubeni of the local guys but TBH it doesn't matter as BdP and Strauss have the position sewn up. Brits, Burden and Kyle Cooper are also on a level (if not above) both Visagie and Ntubeni
Locks: Flip van Der Merwe, Stephan Lewies, Paul Willemse, Willem Alberts, Eben Etzebeth with PSdT not being avaiable anytime soon Lewies is a good call and I think Willemse is playing better rugby every time I see him (can't say a 130kg body won't be useful in test rugby as well) but I'd hate to see Alberts moved off the flanks where he has better opportunity to do what he does best- bruise the opp
Flankers: Heinrich Brussouw, Jacques Du Plessis, Francois Louw, Lappies Labuschagne, Jaco Kriel No. 8: Duane Vermeulen, Philip van der Walt, Warren Whiteley
Labuschagne and vd Walt havn't played any rugby this year!? Louw and Vermeulen are shoe-ins yes. Whitely would certainly deserve a call up but would he suits test rugby nevermind bok rugby? Might work, we could certainly do with some... flair/pace in the backrow but would we lose too much of what has worked for us last year? FLouw and Vermeulen might not have pace but they have surprisingly had a number of try assists between them after breaking the line (odd as it is to see these 115kg odd bodies fly and offload). Kriel I feel has not built on strong showings from last year but Brussow has been the man behind the Cheetahs' revival of their season IMO. It would be criminal to leave the man with a 100% record against the All Blacks out now that he seems back to his best I agree. I agree with you with leaving Kolisi out. Of the Stormers flankers Schalk Burger and Carr have been better. Doo you know (as a Bulls supprter) how far Arno Botha is from being fit? THAT is our flanker right there. If he comes in then I wouldn't mind putting Alberts at lock or not having Louw or Brussow start.
Scrumhalves: Cobus Reinach, Francois Hougaard, Piet van Zyl, Faf De Klerk it's depressing to me that these are the best calls from inside SA.
Flyhalf: Jacques-Louis Potgieter, Frans Steyn, Johan Goosen, Marnitz Boshof LOL, imagine Frans has done well at 10, could you imagine the size of matchday XV we could put out if we focussed on weight strating with Frans at 10!. I hope Goosen goes well. I feel it is between him and Pollard for going forward (though Pollard is with the Juniors ATM)
Centre: Jan Serfontein, JJ Engelbrecht, JDV, JDJ, Damien De Allende, Paul Jordaan I suppose we have to cut somebody and then there is still Jaque Fourie seemingly in the back of HM's mind and Frans Steyn to consider as I don't think HM will consider him at 10. Man, it's gonna be a tough choice to sort out these options. Balance will be key. It's kinda sad JdV is captain as that will weigh too much not to have him be the point the decision is based around and I don't like him at 13.
Wings: Lwazi Mvovo, JP Pietersen, Bjorn Basson, Cheslin Kolbe, Rayno Benjamin, Raymond Rhule I've never been a fan of Basson but I think now is the time to rest Habana (I hear he is on and off in any case with injury) and see what we have in Mvovo/Benjamin or Rhule. Kolbe is just too puny.. I mean he is half of what Aplon is. Pity Aplon is injured.
Fullback: Jaco Taute, Hennie Daniller, Willie Le Roux. Willie le Roux has to start to cement his place and get some caps under the belt IMO at 15 in test rugby. I hate that the Cheetahs play him at 14 as he needs to work on his defense at 15.