• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

3rd test - Australia v British & Irish Lions

Aki didnt do anything wrong for the 3rd try, he's the outside man outnumbered, his job is to make the attacker step in and have his inside man muller him...

The inside man had pushed up out of position and wasnt there, I think Porter ended up trying to cover Curry's position.

Aki isolates himself for that try, the outside defenders are all numbered up, meaning there's no real need for him to completely offload the ball carrier. There's a looping Australia attacker which Aki could number up against, but he's so far behind that by the point he would come into play, Australia would already be well beyond the gainline so that defensive alignment would be obsolete. His inside defenders are also equally at fault, but at the point screenshotted, Aki should be in a position to react and make the tackle, but he's so, so slow that Sua'ali'i just breezes past him with ease.

1753791207684.png
 
Aki isolates himself for that try, the outside defenders are all numbered up, meaning there's no real need for him to completely offload the ball carrier. There's a looping Australia attacker which Aki could number up against, but he's so far behind that by the point he would come into play, Australia would already be well beyond the gainline so that defensive alignment would be obsolete. His inside defenders are also equally at fault, but at the point screenshotted, Aki should be in a position to react and make the tackle, but he's so, so slow that Sua'ali'i just breezes past him with ease.

View attachment 24200

This screen shot is too late though, famage has already been done by Curry shooting alone, and ball watching instead of scanning.

Infact if I remember correctly Sheehan pushes up, Curry goes with and marks a crash ball candidate, at that point Sheehan is basically touching Curry. Curry then sees the ball go behind the Aus play and decides to push on him instead of folding and cover Akis inside shoulder.

The line break is created through Curry's channel, whether Aki can turn in quick enough is pretty irrelevant, you have to trust your inside man in high level defences, a defender is never criticised for not turning in, because turning in as the outside defender is exactly what attacks try to acheive.

Curry gave away a number of line breaks because of this tendency,l to push and chase ball. Its not necessarily bad if its planned with those inside and out, but when its not its disruptive.

But look, noone has a perfect game, Curry isnt playing badly in the tests, he's just playing like he has all tour, at about 80% of what he's capable of.

In fact, he made 2 big tackles in the 1st test, doing this exact same thing, except on both occasions the pass had been made, and his contribution became neutral because he didnt stop anything or anyone
 
The line break is created through Curry's channel, whether Aki can turn in quick enough is pretty irrelevant, you have to trust your inside man in high level defences, a defender is never criticised for not turning in, because turning in as the outside defender is exactly what attacks try to acheive.

I'd agree with that if Aki turning in would leave to an overlap or his outside defenders being outnumbered, but that's not the case in this example. Absolutely, there's already been a defensive mistake which has caused this, but Aki is in the position of not having a specific (i.e. manned-up) defensive duty. He's not covering any Australian attacker, he's there to protect the space, and he doesn't do that. Aki being able to turn quickly enough is very relevant, especially considering the speed and running ability of his opposite number.
 
If Morgan had played the lions would've won 30000000 - 0

#JusticeForJac
#IBelieveJacMorgan
#ManletsUnite
I heard the lads have all made Jac captain as they have so much respect for him.

Genge and Chessum both have Welsh girlfriends and I’ve heard that they’ve both sat in the corner like little cucks as Jac “big boy” Morgan has his way with them and pleasures them in ways only a Welshman could.

Don’t quote me on this, just some stuff I’ve heard from trusted sources.
 
Pinning that try on Aki alone is hilarious too to be fair.

Chessum and JGP miss bad tackles on Jorgenson, Keenan should have got a better shot in too to slow him down. Sheehan and Curry get disconnected from their midfielders and, Harry's right that Curry then doesn't trust his inside man. It does leave Aki as the last line of defense and he doesn't do great at all but his choice was to defend to not create an overlap and trust his inside men, could definitely argue he should have read the situation better but it was a decision made after bad individual moments and a systems break beforehand.

It really shows that Handsome Josh needs to start.
 
Last edited:
You need God, like handsome Josh has.
Our Father, who art in the second row,

Alun Wyn be thy name.

Thy ruck will come, thy scrum will be done,

In Cardiff, as it is in Llanelli.

Give us this day our daily pint,

And forgive us our high tackles,

As we forgive those who drop the ball five metres out and smell like Genge

And lead us not into retirement,

But deliver us from French referees.

For thine is the armband, the glare, and the thinning hair

Forever dominant in the loose…

AWJ-men
 
Pinning that try on Aki alone is hilarious too to be fair.

I don't know if that comment is aimed at me, but if it is, I will point out that in both of my previous two posts, I stated directly that the inside defenders were also fault, and haven't pinned it on Aki alone.

but his choice was to defend to not create an overlap and trust his inside men

The only way there would have been an overlap would have been if Sua'ali'i got on the outside of Aki, as the outside defenders were already numbered up. Curry in particular has voided the inside space which should have offered Aki the protection from the inside step. I think there are two mental errors there- first of all Curry's in creating that space in the first place, but also Aki in not recognising that the inside space where Curry should be is likely to not be protected very well, and that Sua'ali'i is now the danger, not the threat of the overlap which (unless there's an alternate angle which shows otherwise), the Lions have numbered correctly.

Both those errors are quick midweek fixes when reviewing the tape. What isn't a quick fix is the lack of mobility Aki showed there in allowing Sua'ali'i to get on his inside. That's far easier to exploit for an opposition attack than waiting for the defensive line to make a mental error.
 
I don't know if that comment is aimed at me, but if it is, I will point out that in both of my previous two posts, I stated directly that the inside defenders were also fault, and haven't pinned it on Aki alone.



The only way there would have been an overlap would have been if Sua'ali'i got on the outside of Aki, as the outside defenders were already numbered up. Curry in particular has voided the inside space which should have offered Aki the protection from the inside step. I think there are two mental errors there- first of all Curry's in creating that space in the first place, but also Aki in not recognising that the inside space where Curry should be is likely to not be protected very well, and that Sua'ali'i is now the danger, not the threat of the overlap which (unless there's an alternate angle which shows otherwise), the Lions have numbered correctly.

Both those errors are quick midweek fixes when reviewing the tape. What isn't a quick fix is the lack of mobility Aki showed there in allowing Sua'ali'i to get on his inside. That's far easier to exploit for an opposition attack than waiting for the defensive line to make a mental error.
That's exactly what I was pointing out no? You've got the best athlete on the pitch against you in an isolated position, ROG actually called it about two passes out. You can stand him up and give the overlap or show him the inside and trust your team. Struggle to see what Tuipuluto does differently, Aki is an elite defender.

I'd start Tuipuluto if he's fit fwiw, I just don't think that's the play to put Aki down to justify it. In fact, Tuipuluto is a pretty good player, no real need to put Aki down at all.
 

Latest posts

Sponsored
UnlistMe
Back
Top