Top League XV opinions

[Yoichi]

after this yeah who do you think should be in the top league XV for 2013

 

[Yoichi]

my top league XV will go like

1.) Masataka Mikami
2.) Yusuke Aoki
3.) Kensuke Hatakeyama
4.) Isaac Ross
5.) Hitoshi Ono
6.) Todd Clever
7.) Luke Thompson
8.) Hate T-Pole
9.) Fourie du Preez
10.) Stephen Donald
11.) Rico Gear
12.) Tusi Pisi
13.) Jaque Fourie
14.) Shane Williams
15.) Ayumu Goromaru

i dont watch alot of top league but i think this is the top league XV

 

[Japanese_Hero]

not a bad selection Yoichi this is my opinion

1.) Masataka Mikami
2.) Yusuke Aoki
3.) Kensuke Hatakeyama
4.) Isaac Ross
5.) Luke Thompson
6.) Todd Clever
7.) Michael Broadhurst
8.) Hate T-Pole
9.) Fourie du Preez
10.) Stephen Donald
11.) Rico Gear
12.) Tusi Pisi
13.) Jaque Fourie
14.) JP Pietersen
15.) Ayumu Goromaru

i choose JP Pietersen over Williams is because i dont feel that shane williams is not playing as well as he could

 

[Yoichi]

wait ... JP Pietersen Plays in the top league ?

 

[Japanese_Hero]

wait ... JP Pietersen Plays in the top league ?

didn't you hear ? he signed a two year deal to play for Panasonic Wild Knights, he played 7 games and got 6 tries so far

http://www1.skysports.com/news/12040/8666518/

 

[Yoichi]

didn't you hear ? he signed a two year deal to play for Panasonic Wild Knights, he played 7 games and got 6 tries so far

http://www1.skysports.com/news/12040/8666518/

aww sweet!

 

[Onozawa365]

1.) Masataka Mikami
2.) Yusuke Aoki
3.) Kensuke Hatakeyama
4.) Isaac Ross
5.) Hitoshi Ono
6.) Luke Thompson
7.) Michael Broadhurst
8.) Rodney So'oialo
9.) Fourie du Preez
10.) Berrick Barnes
11.) Shane Williams
12.) Wynand Olivier
13.) Jaque Fourie
14.) JP Pietersen
15.) Rico Gear

 

[yt1993]

i think we are missing out players who did play in 2013 in the top league has been missed out heres my XV

1.) Masataka Mikami
2.) Yusuke Aoki
3.) Kensuke Hatakeyama
4.) Isaac Ross
5.) Hitoshi Ono
6.) Hate T-Pole
7.) Michael Broadhurst
8.) Rodney So'oialo
9.) Fourie du Preez
10.) Stephen Donald
11.) Nemani Nadolo
12.) Tusi Pisi
13.) Jaque Fourie
14.) JP Pietersen
15.) Ayumu Goromaru

Nadolo was the top try scorer and played in the top league at the beginning of 2013 until he moved to the crusaders i think he had to be in the top league XV

 

[yt1993]

1.) Masataka Mikami
2.) Yusuke Aoki
3.) Kensuke Hatakeyama
4.) Isaac Ross
5.) Hitoshi Ono
6.) Luke Thompson
7.) Michael Broadhurst
8.) Rodney So'oialo
9.) Fourie du Preez
10.) Berrick Barnes
11.) Shane Williams
12.) Wynand Olivier
13.) Jaque Fourie
14.) JP Pietersen
15.) Rico Gear

why no Stephen Donald ?

 

[ShunsukeWarrior]

1.) Masataka Mikami
2.) Yusuke Aoki
3.) Kensuke Hatakeyama
4.) Isaac Ross
5.) Luke Thompson
6.) Hate T-Pole
7.) Michael Broadhurst
8.) Rodney So'oialo
9.) Fourie du Preez
10.) Stephen Donald
11.) Nemani Nadolo
12.) Wynand Olivier
13.) Jaque Fourie
14.) JP Pietersen
15. Ayumu Goromaru

 

[Onozawa365]

why no Stephen Donald ?

i didn't see him play alot off games and when i did i thought he isn't as good as i expected him to be and i thought that Berrick Barnes played the better season so far then Stephen Donald

 

[yt1993]

i didn't see him play alot off games and when i did i thought he isn't as good as i expected him to be and i thought that Tusi Pisi played the better season so far then Stephen Donald

but the thing is that Tusi Pisi played most his matches as a center instead off a half-back but to be fair to both off us Tusi Pisi and Stephen Donald for fly-half is a tough call

 

[Yoshikazu9]

wareware wa toppurīgu xv ni tsuite hanashi*e iru?

moshi sōnara kore ga watashi nodesu

1.) Masataka Mikami
2.) Yusuke Aoki
3.) Kensuke Hatakeyama
4.) Isaac Ross
5.) Luke Thompson
6.) Hate T-Pole
7.) Michael Broadhurst
8.) Rodney So'oialo
9.) Fourie du Preez
10.) Stephen Donald
11.) Shane Williams
12.) Nemani Nadolo
13.) Jaque Fourie
14.) JP Pietersen
15.) Rico Gear

 

[Yoichi]

hai sōdesu. chīmu-nai no subete no kīpurēyā o shutoku shiyou to shi*e iru hōhō ni yori, tekisetsuna sentakushi

i do like the fact how you tried to get all the key wingers in like Nadolo, Pietersen, Williams and Gear all on in the one team think that be a strong team

 

[Japanese_Hero]

yeah i agree a good squad to get all the key wingers in the top league all on in the same side but i think its better if ones on and the other isn't but i think Nadolo plays 14 and pietersen plays center might be a good call aswell but i think its better to have Pisi in the team and leave one off the wingers out

 

[ShunsukeWarrior]

yeah i agree a good squad to get all the key wingers in the top league all on in the same side but i think its better if ones on and the other isn't but i think Nadolo plays 14 and pietersen plays center might be a good call aswell but i think its better to have Pisi in the team and leave one off the wingers out

yeah pisi has played well in the top league this season i think he cant be missed in the XV

 

[Yoichi]

so far ... we think that Fourie du Preez is definitely the scrum half, a bit off competition about the back row and competition in the wingers and fullbacks but we think that JP Pietersen should definitely be in the team. and we all agree that the japanese front row should be the Top Leagues XV front row Isaac ross is definitely one off the second row but competition between Hitoshi ono and Luke Thompson in the 5 jersey

 

[Onozawa365]

yeah pretty much

 

[yt1993]

how about the subs for the XV's mine would be

16.) Takashi Tanaka
17.) Yusuki Nagae
18.) Hiroshi Yamashi*a
19.) Shoji Ito
20.) Todd Clever
21.) Atsushi Hiwasa
22.) Peter Hewat
23.) Rico Gear

 

[Yoichi]

my subs are basically the same as yt1993

16.) Takashi Tanaka
17.) Yusuki Nagae
18.) Hiroshi Yamashi*a
19.) Shoji Ito
20.) Michael Broadhurst
21.) Atsushi Hiwasa
22.) Kosei Ono
23.) JP Pietersen