The new roster star players opinions!

[iINDOMINUSxx]

im going to do an updated roster and im not sure who should be the stars i had an idea of who should be the star players so this is what i was thinking (Note* im comparing it with the players with stars from the TRF Rugby 10 mod)

Ma'a Nonu keeps his star
Dan Carter keeps his star
Richie McCaw keeps his star
not sure is Juan Hernandez should keep his or give it to Morne Steyn
Ben Foden star should go to Halfpenny
Chris Paterson star should go to Kurtley Beale or Israel Dagg
Shane Williams star should go to James O'Connor
Tommy Bowe star should go to George North
Jerry Collins star should go to Sam Warburton
Will Genia keeps his star
Quade Cooper keeps his star
Vincent Clerc Keeps his star
Bryan Habana keeps his star
not sure if Fourie Du Preez should keep his star or give it to aaron smith
not sure if Jaque Fourie should keep his star of give it to Brian O'Driscoll
Fancois Steyn Keeps his star
Andries Bekker star should go to dusautoir
Shalk Burger keeps his star
Harinordoquy star i dont really know but i think it should go to robshaw
Ngwenya star should go to Julian Savea

and the rest i have no clue about if there is more but i'd like to see what you guys think please leave your opinions in this thread

 

[Kapa O Pango]

Your missing:
*Matt Giteau
*Sergio Parisse
*Bryan Habana
*J Wilkinson
*Gavin Henson
*Ronan O'Gara

^ Some of these guys need changing.

 

[iINDOMINUSxx]

Your missing:
*Matt Giteau
*Sergio Parisse
*Bryan Habana
*J Wilkinson
*Gavin Henson
*Ronan O'Gara

^ Some of these guys need changing.

lol yeah i couldn't remember but i did habana i said he should still be a star and in my opinion id say henson star should go to one of the welsh centers id say jamie roberts and giteau i dont know parisse i think will still be a star i dont even know if wilkinson still plays but if he does then i think he'll still be a star and rowan o'gara star goes to sexton or farrell

 

[Kapa O Pango]

lol yeah i couldn't remember but i did habana i said he should still be a star and in my opinion id say henson star should go to one of the welsh centers id say jamie roberts and giteau i dont know parisse i think will still be a star i dont even know if wilkinson still plays but if he does then i think he'll still be a star and rowan o'gara star goes to sexton or farrell

Maybe David Pocock should have Parisse? Just a suggestion.

 

[pinguinosmc]

Gavin henson > Ashton
o'gara > Jamie Roberts

 

[iINDOMINUSxx]

Maybe David Pocock should have Parisse? Just a suggestion.

mm.. maybe or Pocock should get harinordoquy's star maybe cause parisse is a good captain in my opinion + a good player most of italy's tries came from parisse or parisse was part of the attack i think he deserves his star

Gavin henson > Ashton
o'gara > Jamie Roberts

well my problem is that ashton hasn't been playing good and i rather give rowan o'gara star to a kicker so i some one can get a kicking style cause rowan o'gara has one although i dont know if henson has one but i think henson star should be given to jamie roberts

 

[Freddie Howard]

Conrad smith should definitely have a star!!

 

[Kapa O Pango]

mm.. maybe or Pocock should get harinordoquy's star maybe cause parisse is a good captain in my opinion + a good player most of italy's tries came from parisse or parisse was part of the attack i think he deserves his star

Yeah, when you think about it, Parisse does derverse his star. Probably one of Itatly most star #1 players.


Harinordoquy's could eitheir go to David Pocock or maybe Kirean Read?

 

[j'nuh]

Picamoles should get one!

 

[iINDOMINUSxx]

Conrad smith should definitely have a star!!

well he is good but im not sure if he's should have a star

 

[iINDOMINUSxx]

Yeah, when you think about it, Parisse does derverse his star. Probably one of Itatly most star #1 players.


Harinordoquy's could eitheir go to David Pocock or maybe Kirean Read?

that is a tough one but i think pocock should get it

 

[geostar]

Are you going to change the face portraits also?

 

[Kapa O Pango]

I was thinking about: These are only suggestions. * = stays the same

Fourie du Preez > Mike Phillps?
Matt Giteau > Morne Steyn?
JM Hernandez > Morgan Parra or Owen Farrell?
Vincent Clerc*
Jerry Collins > Sam Wurburton, Sean O'Brien or Chris Robshaw?
Schalk Burger*
Imanol Harinordoquy > David Pocock?
Bryan Habana*
Sergio Parisse*
Richie McCaw*
Tommy Bowe > George North?
Ben Foden > Leigh Halfpenny?
Francois Steyn*
Shane Williams > James O'Conner?
J Wilkinson (Not sure yet)
Dan Carter*
Will Genia*
Quade Cooper*
Gavin Henson > Jamie Roberts?
Ronan O'Gara > Jonathan Sexton?
Ma'a Nonu*
Chris Paterson > Kurtley Beal, Israel Dagg or Israel Folau?
Takudzwa Ngwenya > Julian Savea?
Andries Bekker > Thierry Dusautoir?
Jaque Fourie > Manu Tuilagi?

 

[iINDOMINUSxx]

thats a good choice and geostar i was thinking about removing it so when we update roster the portraits arn't really a problem anymore

 

[iINDOMINUSxx]

or JM Hernandez star goes to Morne Steyn and Giteau's star goes to conrad smith just what freddie said

 

[Freddie Howard]

I think these players deserv stars:
Richie Mcaw
Dan Carter
Thierry Dusautoir
Adam Jones
George North
Lee Half_Penny
Liam Gill
Will Genia
Kieran Reid
Bryan Habana
Maxime Medard


And i dont think David Pocock should have one and Quade cooper should also not have one.
Cooper cant make Australia so why would he get a star

 

[Freddie Howard]

Also Aaron Smith is not the best half back in New Zealand so therefore should not get a star. If a halfback was gonna get it it would be Genia or Weepu or maybe Mike Phillips?

 

[iINDOMINUSxx]

but the thing is about cooper is that he's been injured for a long time i wouldn't select him either but for stars to me quade might not be an australian star but he might be a super 15 star and i was thinking that mike phillips was going to get du preez star and why should liam gill have on i haven't even heard of him before i see why you think adam jones should have a star being the best tighthead prop but i cant find a prop who was a star but i dont think maxime medard sould get one he ain't the best but he is good but except from that i agree with your star player opinions

 

[Freddie Howard]

I just think there are better Five Eights than Quade Cooper and also the fact that he is not a loyal man after the thins he said about Robbie deans and the things he said about he Australian rugby union. And he also makes heaps of mistakes and had a terrible World Cup. If u were going to give stars to a first five you would give it to. Carter. Maybe Owen Farrell or even Aaron Cruden is better than cooper. And about Liam Gill. He is a really good young guy from Australia and the reds and he is a loose forward maybe not a star for him though

 

[iINDOMINUSxx]

right ok just because he's not loyal doesn't mean he deserves a star and if i give to someone else mind you owen farrell looks like he'll be the same and he isn't good england rugby team doesn't like farrell and cruden doesn't start