• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

The comparison thread

RWC 11 or Sidhe Rugby Challenge ?

  • RWC 2011 HB

    Votes: 80 10.3%

  • Sidhe Rugby Challenge

    Votes: 418 53.8%

  • Both

    Votes: 279 35.9%
  • Total voters
    777
Nice trailer but no game play all cut scenes. Looks good from that perspective, just really hope that the game play lives up to the polished presentation.
 
Demo

So is there or is there not going to be a public demo released for RWC11? And if so when? Cant wait for it if its true, will play that game over and over untill i can get the real deal in my hands!
 
munster.jpg
Munster are Licensed in RC
I was and still am totally getting both, but now i know which one I'm looking forward to more

pity its the old jersey,
The new jersey is much nicer

The features and content of Rugby Challenge include:

  • Play in Single Match Mode, Competition Mode, and multi year Career Mode as well as extensive help and Tutorial Mode options available for players new to the sport
  • 93 teams and 31 stadia featured including official team and competition licenses for the All Blacks, the Qantas Wallabies, the USA Eagles, Tri Nations, Bledisloe Cup, Super Rugby teams, Aviva Premiership Rugby, TOP 14 Orange, RaboDirect PRO12, ITM Cup, and Ranfurly Shield
  • Enjoy the game with groups of friends locally, or compete in online multiplayer with support up to 4v4 via PlayStation®Network, Xbox LIVE®, or Steam
  • Create or customise players, teams, and competitions using the extensive customisation tools to shape the game to your own preferences and keep the game fresh season after season
  • Dynamic presentation delivers a true on-field rugby experience with enhanced replay angles, lifelike cut-scenes, rich sound, and real-time commentary from seasoned rugby commentators Grant Nisbett and Justin Marshall
Like seriously, im still pretty loyal to HB, but rugby challenge is really starting to tick the right boxes, the only thing that could let them down now is if the gameplay sucked, and it couldnt suck that bad could it?
 
Last edited:
finbar_omahony said:
View attachment 1045
Munster are Licenced in RC
I was and still am totally getting both, but now i know which one I'm looking forward to more

pitty its the old jersey,
The new jersey is much nicer

The features and content of Rugby Challenge include:

  • Play in Single Match Mode, Competition Mode, and multi year Career Mode as well as extensive help and Tutorial Mode options available for players new to the sport
  • 93 teams and 31 stadia featured including official team and competition licenses for the All Blacks, the Qantas Wallabies, the USA Eagles, Tri Nations, Bledisloe Cup, Super Rugby teams, Aviva Premiership Rugby, TOP 14 Orange, RaboDirect PRO12, ITM Cup, and Ranfurly Shield
  • Enjoy the game with groups of friends locally, or compete in online multiplayer with support up to 4v4 via PlayStation®Network, Xbox LIVE®, or Steam
  • Create or customise players, teams, and competitions using the extensive customisation tools to shape the game to your own preferences and keep the game fresh season after season
  • Dynamic presentation delivers a true on-field rugby experience with enhanced replay angles, lifelike cut-scenes, rich sound, and real-time commentary from seasoned rugby commentators Grant Nisbett and Justin Marshall
Like seriously, im still pretty loyal to HB, but rugby challenge is really starting to tick the right boxes, the only thing that could let them down now is if the gameplay sucked, and it couldnt suck that bad could it?
Click to expand...

No I think it will be more than acceptable and hoping that it will be awesome. the presentation and graphics are very good and in some cases much better than alot of other sport ***les.
 
While the Q@A sessions are ok, the more i read them the more disillusioned i get
80% of the time the answer is no regardless of the questions being asked, which are mostly, does it have this, does it have that, can you do this, can you do that, will you be able to do this, will you be able to do that
all no
and if all the changes have been made to the back-end and how the games play, no amount of chat is going to be able to explain how it works properly
at this point a trailer or video is what is needed
 
finbar_omahony said:
While the Q@A sessions are ok, the more i read them the more disillusioned i get
80% of the time the answer is no regardless of the questions being asked, which are mostly, does it have this, does it have that, can you do this, can you do that, will you be able to do this, will you be able to do that
all no
and if all the changes have been made to the back-end and how the games play, no amount of chat is going to be able to explain how it works properly
at this point a trailer or video is what is needed
Click to expand...

Asking On twitter and gameplay sounds like it's just around the corner. Maybe even this week if were lucky enough. Don't worry were nearly there
 
Ok...so how the hell did sidhe get munster and hb Ireland? Thought that wasn't achievable with the union setup?

Now I'm getting to thinking did hb drop the clubs from the game because rc had hoovered them all up?

They have all Europe and tri nations clubs bar saffers as far as I can see.

We are very much in a place now with one club game and one international one.

Would be interested to know if rc forced hb into dropping the clubs as there was no point building all the clubs with unlicensed players.
 
jovialjonny said:
Ok...so how the hell did sidhe get munster and hb Ireland? Thought that wasn't achievable with the union setup?

Now I'm getting to thinking did hb drop the clubs from the game because rc had hoovered them all up?

They have all Europe and tri nations clubs bar saffers as far as I can see.

We are very much in a place now with one club game and one international one.

Would be interested to know if rc forced hb into dropping the clubs as there was no point building all the clubs with unlicensed players.
Click to expand...

you should take a good look at that pic, and of the sidhe trailer,
Munster the club has been licenced but i dont think the players have, as they dont look anything like the real players
but hey, im not that pushed just being able to play as munster is enough for me
having the correct (if out of date) jersey is a bonus
having the players would be the cherry,



i think we can live without the cherry
 
Sidhe said before that they had licensed images of aviva prem players.

I wasnt entirely clear but it sounded like they couldn't then show them in the england national team but some smart editing tools might get you round it if that's the case.
 
finbar_omahony said:
you should take a good look at that pic, and of the sidhe trailer,
Munster the club has been licenced but i dont think the players have, as they dont look anything like the real players
but hey, im not that pushed just being able to play as munster is enough for me
having the correct (if out of date) jersey is a bonus
having the players would be the cherry,



i think we can live without the cherry
Click to expand...

I did have a look and it looks like John Hayes on the right and sam tuitithead on the left in the red scrumcap.

I don't mind too much re likenesses,good to have the right names if poss.
 

Similar threads

Wally
  • Poll
The Comparison Thread Pt. 2
2
Replies
29
Views
5K
peks89
P
G
funny clip from the game - 8th man runs straight into the poles
Replies
0
Views
5K
Gallopaway
G
A
  • Sticky
The Online Thread
12 13 14
Replies
265
Views
52K
Ruff
Ruff
TRF_Cymro
The Glitch / Problem Thread
5 6 7
Replies
134
Views
28K
jaffka
J
Hulk Hogan
Got the game Yesterday
Replies
2
Views
5K
Hulk Hogan
Hulk Hogan

Latest posts

Top