. I don't even think France will improve dramatically especially under PSA it's just a waste
that's a fair comment. I'm torn betw. 1)they won't really improve substantially and 2)they will improve just because they'll increase the sum of the accumulated talent.
What funny is that they have the talent. They don't need any foreigners apart from one, Jake White. Give them a world class coach and let him selectwho he wants and they could win a world cup genuinely. From the people they have selected who would get in their team ? Maybe Armitage and Kockott ? And if Dusautoir and Nyanga are on form he might not start anyway.
I was thinking about that...trying to assess how France would do, of course with their real players, with a good coach at the RWC. I know it looks like an easy discourse to hold because we'll never know, but I feel we could really produce a good result at the WC, not saying we'd win it outright obviously but just, a good result quite certainly.
As for the guys we'd pick from the foreigners:
Atonio, Van der Merwe, S. Armitage, Tulou, Kockott, James, Connor, D. Smith, Spedding.
Armitage, Kockott and possibly David Smith. VdMerwe, Connor and Tulou are good too, but yeah it's not like they're much better or better at all...and I mean the logic for me is even if we could pick Kieran Read, Folau and Hooper, like, we've got talent right here, real talent, let alone we should only use them as they are French.
The occasional poach is okay, although even Kockott is a step too far..he's South African, he's not French. He had a career before the Top 14...