• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

Johann Muller: Out Of Africa [Into Ulster]

When Ulster wanted some Saffas to go play up North they really seemed to go for over-the-hill or overrated players. Get a South African consultant so that you can target the quality. I think plenty of our guys would enjoy a stint in Ireland. Also, the Magners league and Heiniken Cup is way better than what I am expecting from the new S15 format. Johann Muller, LOL.

I'm not sure what you're trying to say here. Is Johann Muller over the hill? He looked decent in the game i saw him play last week. Why are you expecting S15 to be of such a low standard next year?
 
30 years of age and 22 Springbok caps. Doesn't really sound like a dud or over the hill. Myabe that's just me though, in all honesty I didn't get to see that much Super 14 this year. BJ botha is hardly overrated surely?
 
and pedrie wannenburg from what iv seen is a fantastic player his game against the ospreys was great
 
Can't say that Muller was ever really inspiring in a Bok jersey. Maybe his experience could benefit Ulster but he is by no means a great player.

Not talking about BJ, though he has struggled to perform for the Boks recently. Pienaar is massively overrated IMO and frankly I am glad to see the back of him. Then again, players like Schalk Brits seem by all accounts to perform (although I haven't actually watched) in the NH where I couldn't stand him in a WP jersey (he can run with a ball but was greedy and constantly getting himslef isolated) so who Knows, Pienaar might set the ML alight. Wannenburg is pretty solid but aging, though his size and age wouldn't work against him as much in Europe as it would here.

Mainly, i think the playing conditions are so diferent that players who might not be highly rated at home might well perform up North. Maybe a change of scenery and a little confidence/better player management helps as well. All in all, I think you have missed a few golden opportunities (Wian du Preez is pretty young and promising, though). I was, however, sad to see Ernst Joubert move North as I don't rate either Spies or Kankowski for the Bok no 8 jersey.
 
PS, could the Ospreys please offer Ricky Januarie a long term contract? And thanks for taking Luke Watson! But send Wian and Ernst Joubert back home and to the WP; we can do with some quality depth in the front row and backrow.
 
Top