• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

England Six Nations Squad 2025

So the team for Ire. I'll guess at:

1. Genge mainly through lack of competition

2. LCD - going well

3. Stuart - improving

4. Itoje - established, but will captaincy inspire or drag on performance?

5. Martin. Don't think we've seen the best of him for a while.

6, 7, 8. Genuinely no idea. Will guess at CCS, T Curry and Earl. Could just as easily be Chessum, B Curry and Willis.

9. Mitchell if fit

10. M Smith. Pls not at 15

11. Freeman

Centres I guess he'll start Lawrence and Slade but they've never hugely gelled so suspect others will be tried during the course of the Championship.

14. Murley - in form and Sleightholme has injury question marks.

15. Steward. Ire won't be daft enough to play to his strengths and will look to exploit his weaknesses. Realistically though, who else?

Baxter, Dan, Heyes, Chessum, Willis, JvP, F Smith, Roebuck.


JvP has pulled out injured and won't be available for the Ireland match.

Not sure he will leave out so many CC players. Already Ford will likely be left out. Will he want to leave out anymore? And also have multiple ones as bench options behind non CC players.
 
What a load of old Pollocks.

"….England A game capped me, so unfortunately for the next 3 years I will be trying to push for that England squad".

Just further evidence that players are generally best kept away from the press 😀
Thats a very poor choice of words. I myself have divided loyalties between England and Scotland but once you have decided which one you are going to play for you need to show in words and actions that you are committed to them. Borthwick would be justified in not selecting him or at least having a serious conversation with him about it.
 
Thats a very poor choice of words. I myself have divided loyalties between England and Scotland but once you have decided which one you are going to play for you need to show in words and actions that you are committed to them. Borthwick would be justified in not selecting him or at least having a serious conversation with him about it.

The clue's in the name!
 
Thats a very poor choice of words. I myself have divided loyalties between England and Scotland but once you have decided which one you are going to play for you need to show in words and actions that you are committed to them. Borthwick would be justified in not selecting him or at least having a serious conversation with him about it.
If you listen to the interview it doesn't come across the same way. He was basically trying not to be rude to Jim H rather than him not being set on England. Despite having two Scottish parents he seems pretty set on England.
 
I see Ruck, Planet Rugby et al are shocked, shocked I say, that Gabby Logan's son might choose Scotland over England...
Logan you say?
I do t suppose he has a father does he?
 
Thats a very poor choice of words. I myself have divided loyalties between England and Scotland but once you have decided which one you are going to play for you need to show in words and actions that you are committed to them. Borthwick would be justified in not selecting him or at least having a serious conversation with him about it.
Justified in not selecting him over a choice of words on a podcast. Christ he's not said anything offensive.
 
OK, I really should know better, but I'll bite…..

If the tone had been more, we've not been far off and are hell bent on turning narrow losses into wins then fine. But saying if we get our act together we can beat anyone and implying a possible GS (or at least giving journos the ammunition to do so) will be perceived by many as outright arrogant or deluded. We haven't remotely been near a ***le let alone a GS in ages and only a tiny minority of the squad have the remotest idea what it takes from 2016. If you're going to make bold statements at least do some from a position of strength - for the most part we're a team that's figured out a way to lose, not win, against decent opposition. And that's before you think about where we stand in the rankings vs Ire and Fra or Sco's recent record against us.

Taking about Ireland specifically he then goes on to say that's the kind of match that gets the best out of him and the team. What, away 6N fixtures against decent opposition? During Itoje's career we've won 6N games once in Fra (2016) and once in Ire (2019, a very good performance). Record a bit better in Sco although we've lost the last 2 since winning in 2020….since when all 3 of those countries have stormed the HQ barricades at least once, twice in the case of Sco and in record style by Fra. I hope it turns round but at the moment the win v Ire is very much the exception to the rule, not solid roots.

All this is of precisely no consequence, but that's why it grated. And getting disproportionately annoyed by stuff like this also explains why I generally avoid interviews like the plague!!
I get your point but it's upto you how you chose to interpret words, ultimately I want a leader to back his team and feel they have the capacity to beat teams rather than admit defeat before the whilstles even gone. The most frustrating part of it all for me is England consistently being worse than the some of their parts in recent years amongst other things like strange selections and some level of poisoned regime, I don't think he did it in an overly cocky or arrogant way, hopefully the relatively poor AI (in terms of results) has served as a further humbling the team can come out the right side of.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Top