P
PommyDave
Guest
I've seen a few posts on here in the 'Your teams starting XI' thread who're suggesting England should start Cipriani ahead of Wilkinson.
Don't be foolish.
That is all.
Don't be foolish.
That is all.
I've seen a few posts on here in the 'Your teams starting XI' thread who're suggesting England should start Cipriani ahead of Wilkinson.
Don't be foolish.
That is all.
[/b]
lol, and why is it foolish to drop an over-rated nametag who's done nothing of consiquence since the 2003 final, even been regularly outshone by his understudy at Newcastle?
In 2007, it may as well been Andy Goode at 10, the pack did all the work and Wilkinson kicked it away instead of passing it out wide. Even Olly, 'useless-twat' Barkley provided more backs moves then him.
Retaining Wilkinson is a step in the wrong direction but is inevitable thanks to the meddaling to that other over-rated England Fly-Half arsehole, Rob Andrew.
[/b]
That really sums up the arguement for me. I'm not saying Cipriani is or isnt any good, I just think there are a lot of questions to be asked and answered. Same applies to Flood, Geraghty and Barkley. All look impressive at times, but they arent consistent, are prone to errors, and need more experience on the picth. Wilkinson makes fewer mistakes at the moment. The safe option, but for a team in transition, thats not a bad option to have.Can Cipriani pitch in to the 6N when he was anonymous against O'Gara in Thomond Park last week? [/b]
<div class='quotemain'>
lol, and why is it foolish to drop an over-rated nametag who's done nothing of consiquence since the 2003 final, even been regularly outshone by his understudy at Newcastle?
In 2007, it may as well been Andy Goode at 10, the pack did all the work and Wilkinson kicked it away instead of passing it out wide. Even Olly, 'useless-twat' Barkley provided more backs moves then him.
Retaining Wilkinson is a step in the wrong direction but is inevitable thanks to the meddaling to that other over-rated England Fly-Half arsehole, Rob Andrew.
[/b]
<div class='quotemain'> <div class='quotemain'>
lol, and why is it foolish to drop an over-rated nametag who's done nothing of consiquence since the 2003 final, even been regularly outshone by his understudy at Newcastle?
In 2007, it may as well been Andy Goode at 10, the pack did all the work and Wilkinson kicked it away instead of passing it out wide. Even Olly, 'useless-twat' Barkley provided more backs moves then him.
Retaining Wilkinson is a step in the wrong direction but is inevitable thanks to the meddaling to that other over-rated England Fly-Half arsehole, Rob Andrew.
[/b]
Problem is there may be no 6N England game in the next couple of seasons that is "wrapped up" before the final whistle. No disrespect - it's just the competition is getting tougher, and England look like they'll be unsettled for a while.I also think that the time to introduce Cipriani is when a game is wrapped up, to sample the atmosphere and to get used to his role in the England team. It will be a much better introduction to test rugby if he comes on when the other 14 players have copntrol. then he can concentrate on fitting in and finding his own game, so that he is ready for when he has to perform under real pressure.
[/b]
Problem is there may be no 6N England game in the next couple of seasons that is "wrapped up" before the final whistle. No disrespect - it's just the competition is getting tougher, and England look like they'll be unsettled for a while.<div class='quotemain'>I also think that the time to introduce Cipriani is when a game is wrapped up, to sample the atmosphere and to get used to his role in the England team. It will be a much better introduction to test rugby if he comes on when the other 14 players have copntrol. then he can concentrate on fitting in and finding his own game, so that he is ready for when he has to perform under real pressure.
[/b]
I'd start with Wilkinson against Wales with the view of giving Cipriani the last 15 or 20 minutes dependant upon how the game is panning out. If it's close and a kick may win it then I'd rather have Wilkinsons experience out there at the end but if the game is in the bag or England are chasing a try or two then that would be a good time to give Cipriani the freedom to try and create chances for the backs.
[/b]