• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

Biarritz v Ospreys

Balshaw off now, hopefully Ospreys can claw it back



Tommy Bowe is unreal, that's twice now (that i've seen) that he's taken the ball from the Ospreys 22 and ended up deep into the Bia half


One point in it with 3 to go!
I remember saying before, during the group stages, that there was loads of matches where the winner won by 1 point, could be another one now (after last nights as well)
 
Last edited:
I'll be the first to say it.

**** off Clancy that was clearly offside.

EDIT: Whoops, studio has proven me wrong. Ospreys will be disappointed by their missed chances in the first quarter and Biggar's missed kicks in the last ten.
 
Last edited:
Ospreys should have won this. Intentions and game were their, too bad their conquest (lineout especially) was too poor.
 
Well, not really sure how the Ospreys lost this with the amount of chances they created, getting screwed over by the ref never helps...
 
90m try for the "American" winger!

Considering America is built on immigration, I find that comment hilariously silly.

EDIT: Personally, since 2007 when the Hairsprays rocked up to Vicarage Road thinking they already had it in the bag I've always reserved a wry smile and a faint satisfied chuckle whenever I hear about their latest Heineken Cup flop.

Here's to the Ospreys: Europes permenant underacheivers!
 
Balshaw was offside for his try. I wasn't convinced, but everyone else in the room was. And the winger with the annoying name made a deliberate knock-on straight before his try, and should have seen Yellow, not the tryline.

Biggar made the wrong choice in the final minute. Not offisde, but Biggar shouldn't have gone from the drop-goal.
 
Balshaw was offside for his try. I wasn't convinced, but everyone else in the room was. And the winger with the annoying name made a deliberate knock-on straight before his try, and should have seen Yellow, not the tryline.

Biggar made the wrong choice in the final minute. Not offisde, but Biggar shouldn't have gone from the drop-goal.

After seing the replay, Balshaw was not offside.
 
After seing the replay, Balshaw was not offside.
As I said, I wasn't so sure, but since everyone else I was watching it with thought it was, I thought I might as well throw it up as another offisd-ebased talking point.
 
Considering America is built on immigration, I find that comment hilariously silly.
I say the same for Flutey/Hines/anyone really,

Ngwenyas lived and played in France for the same amount of time he was in America
 
Not really. America gave the man his break into rugby, gave him an education, a home and a chance at getting a better life. Also, if America had a decent league then he wouldn't spend a moment longer in France as he'd be going back home to his country, America to play there.

It's not really as simple as "man moves from Zimbabwe to USA, plays rugby, signs for Biarritz."
 
haven't seen the match, but read and heard match reports, and I'm extremely gutted :( :(
from what i've read here and on reports, ref had a poor game (which in one aspect there's consistency seeing as last nights ref with Leinster/ Clemont was also extremely poor IMO).
a few "controversial" decisions and poor execution cost the ospreys dear, I'm so gutted and in some aspects i'm glad i missed the match (i think id be absolutely tamping and hitting the Bow (Leading to my transformation into Rambo, taking on anyone that comes near me lol ).
DE JA VU.... Sadly for another year we are europe's underachievers :( :( (BAD TIMES)
 
Extremely gutted, the Ospreys had a guilt edged chance here to make the Semi's. Our backline yesterday really was on fire, every single one of them were breaking the line at ease. I feel kinda sorry for Biggar, who had a mighty game in many areas, some of his half breaks were very important, but ultimately cost the O's the game with missed kicks. He shouldn't have gone for that final drop, hell Mike Phillips shouldn't have given it to him. The forwards had to get closer!

The Ospreys lineout was a shambles though, utter mess! That's very disapointing considering you have Wales' first choice second row, second choice hooker and lineout captain there! Bennett should have come off much earlier, pitty Hibbard was injured, as he would have come on if he wasn't. Scrum was under a little pressure, and they were stupid for giving a penalty away for early engagement.

Finally, just a word on the ref. Very, very poor. There was a blatant delibriate knock on before Ngwenya's try, by Ngwenya himself. Should have been penalty and yellow, since there were two O's players ready to score outside him. I really did think there was an offside at the end, but like Speedy the Studio showed that I was wrong.There was still a knock on though, so where was the advantage? Ryan Jones doesn't sound happy, as the ref apparently signalled to him that there was a penalty coming.

Was very disapointed with the Ospreys defense. It's an aspect of their game that is usually so strong, but they left way too many gaps yesterday. Ngwenya was class, Briaritz really took advantage of the pace he offers for both try's. The Ospreys are yet again the underachievers. Shows exactly where they need to work on. A decent looshead and a hooker who can throw in need to be found/trained.

Great game of rugby, thoroughly enjoyable, thoroughly gutted at the result.
 
Last edited:
At what point does it stop being an attempted intercept and turn into a deliberate knock on? I thought he went to get the intercept and then knocked it on by accident, not just swat it out of the air
 
At what point does it stop being an attempted intercept and turn into a deliberate knock on? I thought he went to get the intercept and then knocked it on by accident, not just swat it out of the air

When the gap between them is the size of Shane's foot and he slaps it at the floor instead of trying to catch it. It was cynical.
 
Ah right,
I didn't actually see it happen, but in the chat at the side of the stream half the people were saying it was an intercept, and half not
 
Ngweyna's try was fricking awsome...that's my poor contribute.
 
Yeh, there was no attempt from Ngwenya to catch the ball, he literally slapped it to the floor. It was poor from the ref, however it was still the Ospreys scrum which got turned over , presenting Ngwenya with the chance. Phillips underestimated his speed, gave him the outside and Ngwenya took it with ease. It was a poor attempt at a tackle from Shane, he'll be dissapointed with that. Great finish.
 
Top