[2025 Women's Six Nations] Round 1 - 23/03/25

[Which Tyler]

Stupid stupid stupid.
Hadn't realised it was Evans watching live.

ETA: Sending to the bunker? Does that mean it's a 20 minute red, not 32?
If so, then that's a travesty (and is a travesty that bunker review can't give a full red)

 

[AlRums]

Interesting an almost replay of DuPont's taking off, leading to a Scottish yellow.

 

[AlRums]

Stupid stupid stupid.
Hadn't realised it was Evans watching live.

ETA: Sending to the bunker? Does that mean it's a 20 minute red, not 32?
If so, then that's a travesty (and is a travesty that bunker review can't give a full red)

Yet the bunker can't undo the yellow, so two yellows are still a red. Bunker shouldn't even be involved.

Unless she is upgraded to red in the bunker therefore triggering a 20 min red which makes a mockery of the laws.

 

[AlRums]

Interesting an almost replay of DuPont's taking off, leading to a Scottish yellow.

I'm not disputing the yellow btw, just commenting on the double standards.

 

[Which Tyler]

Yet the bunker can't undo the yellow, so two yellows are still a red. Bunker shouldn't even be involved.

Unless she is upgraded to red in the bunker therefore triggering a 20 min red which makes a mockery of the laws.

That was my fear, but A] I don't know if 20min reds are a thing in the W6N (hope not, I hate them), and B] I material as it stays yellow, so permanent anyway.

I have a feeling the other review will be red - depending on other angles (I can't tell if the other Welsh lady in there was pushing her off balance)

 

[AlRums]

I'm still not sure after the garbled reasoning of the ref if that's full red or 20 min.

Red 8 judged as yellow in bunker, fair enough, 2 yellows = red

 

[AlRums]

That was my fear, but A] I don't know if 20min reds are a thing in the W6N (hope not, I hate them), and B] I material as it stays yellow, so permanured anyway.

I have a feeling the other review will be red - depending on other angles (I can't tell if the other Welsh lady in there was pushing her off balance)

Calls the Dupont decision even more into question with the upgrade to red.

Well that's 14 v 14 for at least the next 10 mins or so.

 

[Which Tyler]

There we go - 2nd bunker (knee) is upgraded to a fake-red

 

[Which Tyler]

I'm still not sure after the garbled reasoning of the ref if that's full red or 20 min.

Red 8 judged as yellow in bunker, fair enough, 2 yellows = red

On the one hand, she's lucky it wasn't upgraded to red for that - no mitigation I could see, but it does mean that the red is permanent, not faked, so...
Wonder for the bunker was aware of that potential, so decided based on that, rather than the actions of Evans herself

 

[AlRums]

There we go - 2nd bunker (knee) is upgraded to a fake-red

Don't dispute yellow, red a bit over the top.
Maybe the fpro just wanted to even up the teams

 

[AlRums]

Great break, leading to a good try

 

[AlRums]

Helen Nelson's having a great game

 

[AlRums]

Are they saying Wales get to replace for the red?

That's ******* ridiculous.

It's seems that the red card, proper, no longer exists.

 

[Which Tyler]

Are they saying Wales get to replace for the red?

That's ******* ridiculous.

It's seems that the red card, proper, no longer exists.

TF????

 

[AlRums]

Scotland player off at 51 mins, comes back at 73

 

[Which Tyler]

Excellent game of rugby that.
Well played Scotland, fully deserved winners

 

[AlRums]

Excellent game of rugby that.
Well played Scotland, fully deserved winners

I agree, good win should have had the forth try though.

The only thing I've got from Six Nations so far this year is there is no red card anymore.