- Joined
- Sep 17, 2009
- Messages
- 16,160
- Country Flag
- Club or Nation
Re 15. Agree we need to develop talent there. But is Hugo Keenan in longterm plans for Leinster and I know Shane Daly is for Munster both are marginally younger than Stockdale but as a 15 have much higher ceiling in that position.I agree re 15 but can at least see the logic with Stockdale long term, with Lowe, Larmour and Conway playing their best stuff on the wing developing his potential at 15 could be valuable.
Murray, Sexton and POM are all at stages of their career that they either need to start or not be involved, the first two are starting but POM has very little value from the bench short or long term.
Henshaw ahead of Aki would be a more positive choice too in my opinion.
I hope Kelleher is unavailable (Haven't read anything) because if we're not trying to develop that talent with our current options there is a serious issue.
Stockdale is a superb wing. And if 1 of the others moved off wing I'd move Conway first then Larmour before Stockdale.
Murray starting makes sense. Is proven at this level. Ok form is iffy. But also JGP has proven to impact games off bench and change tempo. (Yes he has done it from start too) This allows an injection in to game at some stage in what is now a 23 man game.
POM I think is there solely on lineout reasons. Versatility I get but isn't in great form and well VDF I have seen play 6 before I'm sure and well CJ can play 6 equally Tadgh Beirne is a proven 6.
I think Aki 100% deserves spot and has opened the gap with Henshaw a bit. More on the back of his performances being superb than Henshaw being poor.
Kelleher was left out and just not selected which surprised me as he is agile and seemed to suit this pack.