Menu
Forums
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles and first posts only
Search titles only
By:
New posts
Search forums
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Help Support The Rugby Forum :
Forums
Other Stuff
Rugby Video Games & Apps
Rugby Challenge Series
2018-19 Squads and Stats Update!
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="unrated" data-source="post: 902823" data-attributes="member: 45773"><p>Maybe a discussion on the forum would be in order in attempting to determine the best possible team and player ratings.</p><p>For example one can go look at the Super rugby Pecking order thread to get a general idea of where teams in Super rugby are ranked by the community. </p><p></p><p>So to use Super rugby as a case study</p><p>The best super rugby team should probably be around 81-84 Overall</p><p>The worst could range from 60-70</p><p></p><p><strong>Here is an example</strong></p><p></p><p>Hurricanes 83</p><p>Crusaders 83</p><p>Lions 80</p><p>Chiefs 80</p><p>Highlanders 77</p><p>Bulls 77</p><p>Sharks 77</p><p>Stormers 75</p><p>Blues 74</p><p>Tahs 74</p><p>Rebels72</p><p>Brumbies 72</p><p>Reds 70</p><p>Sunwolves 65</p><p></p><p>Then you adjust the players ratings in the team so that they result in the team being rated closely to the desired target (Which is subject to change)</p><p>But then to ensure extra detail the well know players gets the ratings based on their perceived playing ability but also where you would rank them in the team. </p><p></p><p>So for this i will use <strong>the Sharks as an example:</strong></p><p>players ranked form best to worst (IMO)</p><p>1.Jean-Luc du Preez</p><p>2.Dan du Preez</p><p>3.Beast Mtawarira</p><p>4.André Esterhuizen</p><p>5.Curwin Bosch</p><p>6.Makazole Mapimpi</p><p>7.Lukhanyo Am</p><p>8. Rob du Preez</p><p>9 Ruan Botha</p><p>10. Sbu Nkosi</p><p></p><p>After you have individually ranked the players in the team the number one player would have the best ranking in the team and then following in a descending order.</p><p>Now while a guy like Nkosi who is only ranked 10 on my list would have an overall weaker rating than the guys above him you would still be able to personalise the stats for each player so that it resembles their real life qualities.</p><p>Nkosi can be the 10th ranked player but still have electric pace and great defending as thats his qualities but when working in the bigger picture (Trying to match the teams overall rating with the desired amount)you can decrease stats from other areas to balance it out.</p><p></p><p>Also it would be great to keep in mind what [USER=72041]@noah_jo[/USER] said in terms of rating players</p><p>It would be good if you could follow these rating guidelines -</p><p><strong>90+ </strong>for arguably the best in the world </p><p><strong>85-90</strong> for good internationals. </p><p><strong>75-85</strong> for good top tier players.</p><p><strong>70-75</strong> for decent top tier/reserve players</p><p></p><p></p><p>So if the Sharks number one to 5 ranked players is ranked as either good internationals or "arguably" best in the world then you must rate them as such but try and balance the rest of the players as to fit in with the desired overall rating for the team.</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="unrated, post: 902823, member: 45773"] Maybe a discussion on the forum would be in order in attempting to determine the best possible team and player ratings. For example one can go look at the Super rugby Pecking order thread to get a general idea of where teams in Super rugby are ranked by the community. So to use Super rugby as a case study The best super rugby team should probably be around 81-84 Overall The worst could range from 60-70 [B]Here is an example[/B] Hurricanes 83 Crusaders 83 Lions 80 Chiefs 80 Highlanders 77 Bulls 77 Sharks 77 Stormers 75 Blues 74 Tahs 74 Rebels72 Brumbies 72 Reds 70 Sunwolves 65 Then you adjust the players ratings in the team so that they result in the team being rated closely to the desired target (Which is subject to change) But then to ensure extra detail the well know players gets the ratings based on their perceived playing ability but also where you would rank them in the team. So for this i will use [B]the Sharks as an example:[/B] players ranked form best to worst (IMO) 1.Jean-Luc du Preez 2.Dan du Preez 3.Beast Mtawarira 4.André Esterhuizen 5.Curwin Bosch 6.Makazole Mapimpi 7.Lukhanyo Am 8. Rob du Preez 9 Ruan Botha 10. Sbu Nkosi After you have individually ranked the players in the team the number one player would have the best ranking in the team and then following in a descending order. Now while a guy like Nkosi who is only ranked 10 on my list would have an overall weaker rating than the guys above him you would still be able to personalise the stats for each player so that it resembles their real life qualities. Nkosi can be the 10th ranked player but still have electric pace and great defending as thats his qualities but when working in the bigger picture (Trying to match the teams overall rating with the desired amount)you can decrease stats from other areas to balance it out. Also it would be great to keep in mind what [USER=72041]@noah_jo[/USER] said in terms of rating players It would be good if you could follow these rating guidelines - [B]90+ [/B]for arguably the best in the world [B]85-90[/B] for good internationals. [B]75-85[/B] for good top tier players. [B]70-75[/B] for decent top tier/reserve players So if the Sharks number one to 5 ranked players is ranked as either good internationals or "arguably" best in the world then you must rate them as such but try and balance the rest of the players as to fit in with the desired overall rating for the team. [/QUOTE]
Verification
Post reply
Forums
Other Stuff
Rugby Video Games & Apps
Rugby Challenge Series
2018-19 Squads and Stats Update!
Top