- Joined
- Dec 3, 2012
- Messages
- 2,984
- Reaction score
- 1,426
So plumtree and moar out, Ryan in. I feel bad for fiji. Also it's interesting that there is no replacement for moar. And that McLeod has retained his place when defence has been woeful at best.
www.stuff.co.nz
They were Foster’s scapegoats…So plumtree and moar out, Ryan in. I feel bad for fiji. Also it's interesting that there is no replacement for moar. And that McLeod has retained his place when defence has been woeful at best.
Can only hope...They were Foster’s scapegoats…
I hope South Africa crushes New Zealand in these back to back August RC games, so that the NZRU have the balls to sack Foster and bring in what could be the ultimately All Blacks dream team: Robertson, Ryan, MacDonald and Joe Schmidt.
dont get me wrong...would rather not have either as im still of the feeling playing international rugby should be a privilege, an honorI’m not 100% on the whole situation but my understanding is that Reece cops a lot less flack because he fully owned up to his actions, faced significant consequences, seeked help and has since made steps to better himself.
Frizell on the other hand received a 2 match ban and AFAIK didn’t face any legal consequences. I by no means love that Reece is still involved in the ABs set up but I do think that he’s a lot more palatable than Frizell.
I agree they are scapegoats, though not necessarily just fosters scapegoats, I would say they are the nzru scapegoats. They had to make some changes to show they were doing something. But it's certainly not clear they made the right ones, or all the right ones. Their process probably involved deciding what the minimum change was to keep the public at bay. Getting rid of two assistants and not replacing one was the best they could afford. Foster couldn't have taken over any of the other roles, so attack coach was the easy decision . Plumtree reviews poorly last year so if they got rid of him it would look like they knew what they were doing, plus they probably couldn't find a decent defence coach to replace McLeodThey were Foster’s scapegoats…
I hope South Africa crushes New Zealand in these back to back August RC games, so that the NZRU have the balls to sack Foster and bring in what could be the ultimately All Blacks dream team: Robertson, Ryan, MacDonald and Joe Schmidt.
South Africa is not good enough to do that....not even close.They were Foster’s scapegoats…
I hope South Africa crushes New Zealand in these back to back August RC games, so that the NZRU have the balls to sack Foster and bring in what could be the ultimately All Blacks dream team: Robertson, Ryan, MacDonald and Joe Schmidt.
Huh, I wonder if Macdonald said no out of loyalty to razor.im embarrassed we seem to have been so blatant is just trying stop PGS playing for Fiji
I believe Schmidt only selected the squad, he's not travelling to South Africa so would be hard placed to help with the 23
I have seen reports Leon Macdonald and jason Ryan have been tapped up for the AB's assistants...extrapolating that out quite a lot...Fozzie to step down on return from SA and Schmidt, Macdonald and Ryan going forward?
Ironically given fans want foster out because they don't trust him to take us to the World Cup, Foster has taken this mentality that only the World Cup matters.
But it goes both ways - upholding the aura within the team helps us win, but the sense of an aura from outside the team helps our opposition lose too. The aura simply isn't there anymore for most opposition - the springboks never really felt it, Ireland, france, and england probably won't be affected by it. Maybe not argentina either now they've beaten us. Wales and scotland probably feel the aura still but we'd beat them anyway (probably).
Maybe it's not just Foster whose job should be under threat. There's barely a position that the incumbent for South Africa isn't in the conversation for being the best in the world and the depth in the tight five is unparalleled.South Africa is not good enough to do that....not even close.
I don't know where to start, to be honest, there's so much to say about this NZRU trainwreck that started after the Lions series and got even worse after the travesty that was Ian Foster's appointment back in December 2019...I will however try to summarize my thoughts in connection thereof:I agree they are scapegoats, though not necessarily just fosters scapegoats, I would say they are the nzru scapegoats. They had to make some changes to show they were doing something. But it's certainly not clear they made the right ones, or all the right ones. Their process probably involved deciding what the minimum change was to keep the public at bay. Getting rid of two assistants and not replacing one was the best they could afford. Foster couldn't have taken over any of the other roles, so attack coach was the easy decision . Plumtree reviews poorly last year so if they got rid of him it would look like they knew what they were doing, plus they probably couldn't find a decent defence coach to replace McLeod
Interested to hear what are the things you are seeing that point to foster being a bigger problem than his assistants. I'm grateful this forum exists where people provide reasonable and humble comments as opposed to the blood thirsty frenzy from people that have no idea on stuff comments and elsewhere.
I mean I have my reasons for thinking fosters head coaching hasn't been the best but I'm interested to hear yours. I also have plenty of reasons for suggesting the assistants have been poor, that the opposition has been good, that the players aren't as good as what they used to be, that there's not such great evidence to suggest that robertson would be the degree of savior people think he will be.
Also I think its really not worth one's while to care so much about the World Cup that they are willing to support the opposition in the hope that the coach gets dropped so we have more chance of winning the World Cup. At the absolute best we will go from 15 to 30 per cent chance of winning. Even the 2015 all blacks didn't go into the World Cup with more than 50 per cent odds of winning. So it seems like self sabotage to put all your eggs in the World Cup basket when your team will most likely lose anyway. Better to enjoy games outside the World Cup too.
...if you're going to post nothing but pure sense then thats really going to kill the conversation....agree with all thisI don't know where to start, to be honest, there's so much to say about this NZRU trainwreck that started after the Lions series and got even worse after the travesty that was Ian Foster's appointment back in December 2019...I will however try to summarize my thoughts in connection thereof:
- Plumtree and Mooar were Foster's scapegoats because he chose them and not NZRU. Remember when they were lauded by Foster as being part of an ideal coaching setup that ticks all the boxes? Ironically, although one of the reasons for which Razor's application as All Blacks HC was rejected was that his proposed coaching setup was supposedly weaker than Foster's...now both Plumtree and Mooar have been sacked, while Jason Ryan has been appointed as the All Blacks forwards coach;
- The first major mistake that Foster made was appointing Sam Cane as Captain, without a minute of rugby being played in NZ that season. Sam Cane was a great All-Black, but at the time of his nomination and surely after, he wasn't probably near the Top 3 opensides in NZ. The problem with his appointment was/is that the team had to carry him in the starting lineup, forcing other players to be played out of position (i.e. Ardie Savea, Papali'i) and destabilizing the whole back row;
- He persisted with players way past their prime and has not developed any talent NZ oozes with. Just to give you an example, although both Whitelock and Retallick are aging, I don't see any younger lock to have been granted a significant amount of game time ever since he took the job;
- His head coaching record in SR is abysmal and when it comes to the All Blacks, it could have been even worse had not been for Italy, US, Tonga or Fiji. In comparison, Razor's coaching abilities proved to be phenomenal, as he won with the Crusaders 6 SR championships in a row, with either aging or departing All Blacks...how many SR trophies did Todd Blackadder win with one of the finest players the All Backs have ever seen?
- Where are now the members of the old boys club that heavily advertised for Foster (re)appointment? One of the most stupid mistakes the NZRU has ever done was reappointing Foster prior to the 2021 Northern Tour, but Sir Steve Hansen told the public it was a no brainer...;
- I don't buy the argument that the All Blacks players are not that good...in my humble opinion, the team is poorly selected and coached;
- The bottom line is that, strictly playing wise, they need to select the best players for each position and not go the out-of-position route anymore.
Sorry if my message came too long, but it saddens me to see the All Blacks in such a poor state.
thats been exactly NZ primary game plan for several years, let "them" have the ball...soak it up (see why a tackler like cane was picked at 7 rather than a jackle)...force a turnover and strike from anywhere on the field...it use to work but everyone is very wise to it now...and we dont have the same weapons as we did in 2015 for example...and we dont seem to have a clue how to play a different wayIt felt like at times for NZ but also Australia that they would try and soak up the attack and fire every ruck before counter attack and surge past the oppositions defence. However, the likes of England and Ireland have really abbrasive and physical defences that don't gift many opportunities.
Well, I'll see if I can limit my reply.I don't know where to start, to be honest, there's so much to say about this NZRU trainwreck that started after the Lions series and got even worse after the travesty that was Ian Foster's appointment back in December 2019...I will however try to summarize my thoughts in connection thereof:
- Plumtree and Mooar were Foster's scapegoats because he chose them and not NZRU. Remember when they were lauded by Foster as being part of an ideal coaching setup that ticks all the boxes? Ironically, although one of the reasons for which Razor's application as All Blacks HC was rejected was that his proposed coaching setup was supposedly weaker than Foster's...now both Plumtree and Mooar have been sacked, while Jason Ryan has been appointed as the All Blacks forwards coach;
- The first major mistake that Foster made was appointing Sam Cane as Captain, without a minute of rugby being played in NZ that season. Sam Cane was a great All-Black, but at the time of his nomination and surely after, he wasn't probably near the Top 3 opensides in NZ. The problem with his appointment was/is that the team had to carry him in the starting lineup, forcing other players to be played out of position (i.e. Ardie Savea, Papali'i) and destabilizing the whole back row;
- He persisted with players way past their prime and has not developed any talent NZ oozes with. Just to give you an example, although both Whitelock and Retallick are aging, I don't see any younger lock to have been granted a significant amount of game time ever since he took the job;
- His head coaching record in SR is abysmal and when it comes to the All Blacks, it could have been even worse had not been for Italy, US, Tonga or Fiji. In comparison, Razor's coaching abilities proved to be phenomenal, as he won with the Crusaders 6 SR championships in a row, with either aging or departing All Blacks...how many SR trophies did Todd Blackadder win with one of the finest players the All Backs have ever seen?
- Where are now the members of the old boys club that heavily advertised for Foster (re)appointment? One of the most stupid mistakes the NZRU has ever done was reappointing Foster prior to the 2021 Northern Tour, but Sir Steve Hansen told the public it was a no brainer...;
- I don't buy the argument that the All Blacks players are not that good...in my humble opinion, the team is poorly selected and coached;
- The bottom line is that, strictly playing wise, they need to select the best players for each position and not go the out-of-position route anymore.
Sorry if my message came too long, but it saddens me to see the All Blacks in such a poor state.
It's not that bad an insult; the sevens in all those teams are pretty good.Stuart Barnes at his provocative best in the Telegraph likening Cane to Chris Robshaw in the Stuart Lancaster era and saying that he was schooled by Van der Flier and wouldn’t be good enough to get in the Aussie team. Or the Boks. Or the English. Or the Welsh. Or the French. Or the Scottish. Or even the Italians!
Robertson would have given his blessings because he'd be a dick not to. And he owes Ryan for his reputation. There have been many games that the crusaders attack looked pretty dire apart from their maul and or their maul defense and scrum kept them in the game. Especially when moar was attack coach; that's why it always shocked me when I heard moar was coaching in the all blacks.I think Foster has adopted the "WC is the only thing that matters" mantra because it is the only thing that will be able to rescue his legacy. It's quite different to Eddie's obsession of being on the cusp but not over the line.
I think you're dead on about the jersey and its downstream effects on aura, accountability and success. Win ratio is more important than trinkets and jewellery. Any team can have a bad day or be outplayed by a team in a divinely inspired flow state in knockout rugby. I'm still annoyed about the double loss to the Wallabies last year. Success over time is dominance.
World Cup wins are nice but double-edged. After that, laziness can bloom with all the accolades and the obvious deficiencies are papered over with the "still reigning champs" ********. It's why that AB run was so special - they actually got much better after 2011 and stayed hungry up until the point all those greats retired. The rot set in afterwards.
Side note - do you think that Ryan took that post with Robinson's blessing so as to have some boots on the ground to provide intel? Seems like a good way to prep for a transition when he gets the top job inevitably.