Who must get George Smith's star

[Intercept King JDV]

I'm re-configuring the star players and I'm stuck on this one, who must get George Smith's star ability, Rocky Elsom or David Pocock?

Please vote for who you think.Voting ends this Friday (14 Jan '11).

 

[Feicarsinn]

Aw, no Jamie Heaslip?


If not, then Rocky for old times sake.

 

[Davidson77]

And what happend with Spencer's Star? I want it back!

 

[Gavin]

David Pocock has had more of an impact on the opposition than Elsom has since he returned from playing for Leinster.

 

[Feicarsinn]

David Pocock has had more of an impact on the opposition than Elsom has since he returned from playing for Leinster.

I'm going to punch you in the Ovary!

 

[Draggs]

Pocock.
Will Parisse get Bekker's star?

Also, I'd propose for Drew Mitchell to get Tuqiri's (Ngwenya is quick, and not much else. Mitchell has scored 9 international tries this year) and for Kurtley Beale to get Latham's (powerful boot, Paterson is old).

 

[Hulk Hogan]

David Pocock for Smiths.
Mitchell for Ngwenya.
No one in aus for Lathams.

 

[ikaletahirep]

i agree with draggs.

 

[Draggs]

David Pocock for Smiths.
Mitchell for Ngwenya.
No one in aus for Lathams.

Yeah, Beale might be a stretch right now. I was trying to factor in the boot that comes with Latham's star. Byrne would have been my choice two years ago.

 

[Hulk Hogan]

Yeah, Beale might be a stretch right now. I was trying to factor in the boot that comes with Latham's star. Byrne would have been my choice two years ago.

Yeah that's understandable, just Beale isn't star material yet and James O'Connor I doubt will ever be, they're both on off players, did some hero kicks, then were flat out landing a con or penalty after their initial impressive kicks.
I would even suggest Digby Ioane gets Tuquiri's star but, Ioane is injured to often these days, so it's kind of hard to tell if he's still as good as he was, he in my opinion was everybit star material as Nonu.

 

[Manumare]

in my rosters i left smith's and j rokocoko stars but i gave the rest to other players. hernandez has pichot's, morne steyn has o'gara's, quade cooper has spencer's, heaslip has dallaglio's, j de villiers has lewsey's, stephen jones has latham's, heymans has robinson's, bastareaud has henson's, muliaina has tuqiri's and trinh duc has larkham's. i did nothing with nyanga's cause it injures players so i keep him on the bench

 

[Intercept King JDV]

Thanks for everybody that voted and for the feedback, David Pocock will get George Smith's star then by the looks of it.I'm going to have to cut this short and stop this poll now today because I'm going to be away for about 10 days as from tomorrow.

Thanks again for all who voted, the full list of star player changes will be up for feedback/comments after I get back.