Menu
Forums
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
Latest activity
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles and first posts only
Search titles only
By:
New posts
Search forums
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Help Support The Rugby Forum :
Forums
Other Stuff
Rugby Video Games & Apps
Rugby World Cup 2011 Game
Squads And Player Ratings
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Reply to thread
Message
<blockquote data-quote="Hermezzz" data-source="post: 416297" data-attributes="member: 39751"><p>Based on 'my' Pumas line-up:</p><p></p><p>15. Lucas González Amorosino: <strong>83</strong> (incredible runner and great finisher, not so good when defending, can also play winger)</p><p>14. Gonzalo Camacho: <strong>80</strong> (really strong for a winger, little bit like Sackey, can also play outside centre)</p><p>13. Marcelo Bosch: <strong>83</strong> (good line breaks, good tackles and always very aware, can also play fly-half and fullback)</p><p>12. Santiago Fernández: <strong>77</strong> (maybe a bit boring with the ball in hand, but reliable centre, strong tackler, can also play fly-half)</p><p>11. MartÃn Bustos Moyano: <strong>79</strong> (best kicker around at the moment, not slow at all)</p><p>10. Juan MartÃn Hernández: <strong>87</strong> (last time I saw him play: RWC 2007, can also play fullback and inside centre)</p><p>9. Alfredo Lalanne: <strong>80</strong> (tough choice, but he's my favourite scrummie)</p><p></p><p>8. Juan MartÃn Fernández Lobbe: <strong>88</strong> (not as fast as I'd like, but still awesome eightman)</p><p>7. Julio FarÃas Cabello: <strong>81</strong> (slow and tall enough to play lock, really good tackler)</p><p>6. Genaro Fessia: <strong>80</strong> (great at turnovers and very strong for a flanker)</p><p>5. Patricio Albacete: <strong>87</strong> (tall, heavy and strong, what else do you need for a world class lock?)</p><p>4. Mariano Galarza: <strong>83</strong> (ditto, only five years younger and two inches taller)</p><p>3. Juan Figallo: <strong>79</strong> (a bit small for tighthead, but still, excellent prop)</p><p>2. AgustÃn Creevy: <strong>87</strong> (best ball carrier this country ever had, former eightman and very fast on the loose)</p><p>1. Marcos Ayerza: <strong>84</strong> (Leicester fans, help me with this one, great scrummager and hard to stop when carrying the ball, anything else?)</p><p></p><p>16. Eusebio Guiñazú: <strong>77</strong> (he's fat, slow and can play tighthead, loosehead and hooker... nice)</p><p>17. Rodrigo Roncero: <strong>83</strong> (always getting into fights, conceding penalties or arguing with the ref, but always a nightmare at the scrum and tackling hard) </p><p>18. Manuel Carizza: <strong>77</strong> (not a bad lock, but way too slow and never shows up too much)</p><p>19. Juan Manuel Leguizamón: <strong>84</strong> (very fast for a flanker, great tackling and has an eye for scoring, but also commits plenty of penalties, so he wouldn't be my first choice to complete the back row)</p><p>20. AgustÃn Figuerola: <strong>79</strong> (likes to get involved in the attack, but not a complete scrum-half like Lalanne)</p><p>21. Nicolás Sánchez: <strong>83</strong> (great playmaker and line breaker, can also play inside centre, only one cap)</p><p>22. Horacio Agulla: <strong>82</strong> (fast and strong runner, can also play fullback but I think he lacks some field vision)</p><p>[23. MartÃn Scelzo: <strong>80</strong> (big and strong tighthead, but grows tired quickly]</p><p></p><p>I reckon this would be a really good Pumas team (we could fight the 3rd spot again, I guess), but since we have the worst coach in Argentinean rugby history (<u>Santiago Phelan</u>, the Antichrist), I guess overall team rating would be 75-80 (in our best days). Sorry for making it such a long post, it was supposed to be only numbers, right?</p><p></p><p>And this would be my top ten:</p><p></p><p>1. NZ: 94</p><p>2. AUS: 91</p><p>3. RSA: 90</p><p>4. FRA - 88 (even if they're the most inconsistent team on the planet)</p><p>5. ENG - 86</p><p>6. IRE - 85</p><p>7. WAL - 83</p><p>8. ARG - 82 (I can't moan enough about our coach, if we had a decent one we would easily be an 85, maybe more)</p><p>9. SCO - 81</p><p>10. ITA - 78</p></blockquote><p></p>
[QUOTE="Hermezzz, post: 416297, member: 39751"] Based on 'my' Pumas line-up: 15. Lucas González Amorosino: [B]83[/B] (incredible runner and great finisher, not so good when defending, can also play winger) 14. Gonzalo Camacho: [B]80[/B] (really strong for a winger, little bit like Sackey, can also play outside centre) 13. Marcelo Bosch: [B]83[/B] (good line breaks, good tackles and always very aware, can also play fly-half and fullback) 12. Santiago Fernández: [B]77[/B] (maybe a bit boring with the ball in hand, but reliable centre, strong tackler, can also play fly-half) 11. MartÃn Bustos Moyano: [B]79[/B] (best kicker around at the moment, not slow at all) 10. Juan MartÃn Hernández: [B]87[/B] (last time I saw him play: RWC 2007, can also play fullback and inside centre) 9. Alfredo Lalanne: [B]80[/B] (tough choice, but he's my favourite scrummie) 8. Juan MartÃn Fernández Lobbe: [B]88[/B] (not as fast as I'd like, but still awesome eightman) 7. Julio FarÃas Cabello: [B]81[/B] (slow and tall enough to play lock, really good tackler) 6. Genaro Fessia: [B]80[/B] (great at turnovers and very strong for a flanker) 5. Patricio Albacete: [B]87[/B] (tall, heavy and strong, what else do you need for a world class lock?) 4. Mariano Galarza: [B]83[/B] (ditto, only five years younger and two inches taller) 3. Juan Figallo: [B]79[/B] (a bit small for tighthead, but still, excellent prop) 2. AgustÃn Creevy: [B]87[/B] (best ball carrier this country ever had, former eightman and very fast on the loose) 1. Marcos Ayerza: [B]84[/B] (Leicester fans, help me with this one, great scrummager and hard to stop when carrying the ball, anything else?) 16. Eusebio Guiñazú: [B]77[/B] (he's fat, slow and can play tighthead, loosehead and hooker... nice) 17. Rodrigo Roncero: [B]83[/B] (always getting into fights, conceding penalties or arguing with the ref, but always a nightmare at the scrum and tackling hard) 18. Manuel Carizza: [B]77[/B] (not a bad lock, but way too slow and never shows up too much) 19. Juan Manuel Leguizamón: [B]84[/B] (very fast for a flanker, great tackling and has an eye for scoring, but also commits plenty of penalties, so he wouldn't be my first choice to complete the back row) 20. AgustÃn Figuerola: [B]79[/B] (likes to get involved in the attack, but not a complete scrum-half like Lalanne) 21. Nicolás Sánchez: [B]83[/B] (great playmaker and line breaker, can also play inside centre, only one cap) 22. Horacio Agulla: [B]82[/B] (fast and strong runner, can also play fullback but I think he lacks some field vision) [23. MartÃn Scelzo: [B]80[/B] (big and strong tighthead, but grows tired quickly] I reckon this would be a really good Pumas team (we could fight the 3rd spot again, I guess), but since we have the worst coach in Argentinean rugby history ([U]Santiago Phelan[/U], the Antichrist), I guess overall team rating would be 75-80 (in our best days). Sorry for making it such a long post, it was supposed to be only numbers, right? And this would be my top ten: 1. NZ: 94 2. AUS: 91 3. RSA: 90 4. FRA - 88 (even if they're the most inconsistent team on the planet) 5. ENG - 86 6. IRE - 85 7. WAL - 83 8. ARG - 82 (I can't moan enough about our coach, if we had a decent one we would easily be an 85, maybe more) 9. SCO - 81 10. ITA - 78 [/QUOTE]
Verification
Post reply
Forums
Other Stuff
Rugby Video Games & Apps
Rugby World Cup 2011 Game
Squads And Player Ratings
Top
