Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="munstermuffin" data-source="post: 299047">&lt;div class=&#039;quotetop&#039;&gt;QUOTE (Monkeypigeon @ Jan 17 2010, 06:24 PM) <a href="http://index.php?act=findpost&amp;pid=432591" target="_blank">&lt;{POST_SNAPBACK}&gt;</a>&lt;/div&gt;Agree with that roughly although I think it hard to judge Carr as I dont see enough of him and well in Connacht he isnt playing at a standard required but yeah I think it about right except Earls is ahead of Shaggy. Also it great to see that such a thin line between them all.[/b]</blockquote>What you need to know about Carr is that he has 4 tries in 7 Magners league matches and 6 for 5 matches in the Challenge Cup. 10 tries in 12 matches for any team is brilliant. For Connacht it&#039;s a mini-miracle.I&#039;d have it as:1. Bowe,2. Earls/Shaggy,4. Carr/Trimble/Hurley,7. J. Murphy/DowlingCan&#039;t really separate Carr, Trimble and Hurley at the moment. Though I&#039;ve a bit of of bias towards Hurley and I&#039;ve seen him from the stands a couple of times and he has the work-rate of Dowling&nbsp; except he can finish + he;s a very strong runner when he has any spaceStill don&#039;t trust Trimble under a highball (Hurley&#039;s got better in that regard since he&#039;s gained confidence on the wing).EDIT:But speaking as a Connacht fan, if Ireland are to have a realistic chance of winning the 6 Nations, Cronin, Keatley, Mathews and Carr all need to be starting.[/b][/quote]Cheers for that like I&#039;ve seen Carr but not enough to praise or slam him.Agree with list except think Earls is ahead of Shaggy although maybe it hard to tell as we seen Keith excel in centre and not out on wing but he has given a good account out on wing in past.As for Hurley he really has flew up the pecking order and as shown yesterday he is safe under high ball but also smart using it. Trimble I know is playing well but I always have viewed him as a player that when it comes to big games he folds so dont like when he is selected.Also not sayin Carr bad or anything Feicarsinn but Carr has more tries because he plays alot more games than Earls and Shaggy and them[/QUOTE]

[QUOTE="munstermuffin, post: 299047"] <div class='quotetop'>QUOTE (Monkeypigeon @ Jan 17 2010, 06:24 PM) [url='index.php?act=findpost&pid=432591']<{POST_SNAPBACK}>[/url]</div> Agree with that roughly although I think it hard to judge Carr as I dont see enough of him and well in Connacht he isnt playing at a standard required but yeah I think it about right except Earls is ahead of Shaggy. Also it great to see that such a thin line between them all. [/b][/quote] What you need to know about Carr is that he has 4 tries in 7 Magners league matches and 6 for 5 matches in the Challenge Cup. 10 tries in 12 matches for any team is brilliant. For Connacht it's a mini-miracle. I'd have it as: 1. Bowe, 2. Earls/Shaggy, 4. Carr/Trimble/Hurley, 7. J. Murphy/Dowling Can't really separate Carr, Trimble and Hurley at the moment. Though I've a bit of of bias towards Hurley and I've seen him from the stands a couple of times and he has the work-rate of Dowling except he can finish + he;s a very strong runner when he has any space Still don't trust Trimble under a highball (Hurley's got better in that regard since he's gained confidence on the wing). EDIT: But speaking as a Connacht fan, if Ireland are to have a realistic chance of winning the 6 Nations, Cronin, Keatley, Mathews and Carr all need to be starting. [/b][/quote] Cheers for that like I've seen Carr but not enough to praise or slam him. Agree with list except think Earls is ahead of Shaggy although maybe it hard to tell as we seen Keith excel in centre and not out on wing but he has given a good account out on wing in past. As for Hurley he really has flew up the pecking order and as shown yesterday he is safe under high ball but also smart using it. Trimble I know is playing well but I always have viewed him as a player that when it comes to big games he folds so dont like when he is selected. Also not sayin Carr bad or anything Feicarsinn but Carr has more tries because he plays alot more games than Earls and Shaggy and them [/QUOTE]

Verification