• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

Heineken Cup: Team of 2010/11

Jockstap

First XV
TRF Legend
Joined
Apr 18, 2009
Messages
1,590
http://planetrugby.com/story/0,25883,16016_6949767,00.html

Now that the dust has settled across Europe, Planet Rugby thought it was only right to dish out some praise to the star men of the Heineken Cup.

What a final it was at the Millennium Stadium over the weekend as the two top teams remaining in the 2010/11 competition put on a real show.

Yes, I will pull out the cliche that it was a game of two halves but that it was, with Leinster prevailing thanks to a marvellous 28 points from their maturing fly-half Jonathan Sexton - apparently he also pulls off a mean Istanbul-like team-talk.

Northampton will of course be wondering what might have been in the aftermath, but credit where it is due, they have enjoyed a remarkable season and few would disagree that they will be back at the business end of things this time next year.

And so we come to our Team of the Tournament. It was difficult to find space for players from those sides not hailing from Dublin or the East Midlands of England. However, tried PR did and it would be great to hear your own selections...

Planet Rugby's Team of the Tournament

15 Isa Nacewa (Leinster) - A toss-up between Ben Foden and this lively, hard-hitting full-back went the way of the Leinster hero. A top European season from the former Blue.

14 Matt Banahan (Bath) - He came a close second to Paul Diggin in the try-scoring tally and fully deserves his place on the right wing. Chris Ashton was much better in the Six Nations.

13 Brian O'Driscoll (Leinster) - Florian Fritz and Jon Clarke were battling hard for this spot but the experienced O'Driscoll gets the nod for being in key in sealing the Cup.

12 James Downey (Northampton) - We have been hearing on the wires a great deal of Ireland fans wanting this guy in their national side. We have to echo that sentiment.

11 Paul Diggin (Northampton) - If there was a way to get Ben Foden and Isa Nacewa in the same team we would. But instead we go with the numbers and that sees 2010/11's top try-scorer Diggin claim our number 11 jersey. A mention too for Maxime Medard.

10 Jonathan Sexton (Leinster) - 28 points in the Heineken Cup final and 138 in all, Sexton's game-management pushes him into our playmaking position with relative ease.

9 Lee Dickson (Northampton) - Only when Dickson was injured did we realise how important he is to Saints. This busy number should be in England's World Cup squad.

8 Louis Picamoles (Toulouse) - This was our toughest call as Roger Wilson, Jamie Heaslip and Joe van Niekerk pushed hard. But his endless carries sees him at the base.

7 Phil Dowson (Northampton) - A try in the final was the icing on the cake for what has been a strong campaign for Dowson. He's such a good link-man between forwards and backs.

6 Sean O'Brien (Leinster) - Such a powerful runner and tackler, we think that barring BOD, O'Brien would be the first name on Ireland's team sheet. 6,7 or 8, he is always a warrior.

5 Leo Cullen (Leinster) - It is tough to find a lock in Europe with as much European know-how as the ex-Tiger. Calm, assured and technically superb, he had to make the cut.

4 Johann Muller (Ulster) - His second-row partner Dan Tuohy deserves a mention as their combination was key to Ulster making the quarter-finals. What a signing he has been.

3 Brian Mujati (Northampton) - Adam Jones made our weekly XV twice this year, but the Opta stats say it all with Brian Mujati getting almost twice what an average tighthead got in terms of scrummaging points in 2010/11. Much-improved since moving from the Stormers.

2 Richardt Strauss (Leinster) - It was a strong Heineken Cup term for the former Cheetah, who does enough to pip William Servat and Dylan Hartley to our hooking jersey.

1 Soane Tonga'uiha (Northampton) - What a campaign for this Saint. Cian Healy had a good term but in truth, no one comes close to the strength and speed of Tonga'uiha.
 
Accurate enough but I would have Horgan 14. Ashton 11. Pienaar 9. lawes 4. Nyanga 7.
 
Banahan? lol
Don't agree with their bit about BOD - he didn't seal the deal with the cup, that was Sexton and O'Brien that won them the silverware, not BOD


Apart from those two, I'd pretty much agree
 
Some absolutely demented decisions in that team. Banahan at 14 is laughable. As is Dickson at 9. Not starting Lawes is a joke and after Heaslip's performances in the knock out stages how can anyone deny him the 8 jersey?
 
Most notable for me:

Foden for Natcewa, Meddard for Diggin, Pick-a-winger for Banahan.

BOD is also receiving far too many plaudits for just being BOD (anyone who read the Brian Moore article should have felt slightly nauseous afterwards). In all honesty I think he came off a distant second best in the one-on-one matchups against Fritz, Tuilagi and Clarke.
 
Foden and Nacewa is a very close call. Nacewa was the better player up to the final and then Foden had one of the best performances of the season in the final, overall though Nacewa was better in the tournament. I think everyone is being unfair on BOD, he may not have been the best 13 in the tournament, but he wasn't s*** like everyone is making him out to be. He was very good in the group stages and against Toulouse, alright against Leicester and rubbish against The Saints, overall not a bad tournament.
 
Most notable for me:

Foden for Natcewa, Meddard for Diggin, Pick-a-winger for Banahan.

BOD is also receiving far too many plaudits for just being BOD (anyone who read the Brian Moore article should have felt slightly nauseous afterwards). In all honesty I think he came off a distant second best in the one-on-one matchups against Fritz, Tuilagi and Clarke.

Agreed on BOD comment 100%
Lawes been left out is very strange to me as I thought he was possibly a contender for player of Tournament.
Foden and Nacewa is a tight one but it was always going to be Nacewa since he was player of Tournament in many eyes.
Banahan is a very strange call when you consider Ashton, Horgan and a few more candidates.
Dickinson at 9 is a very strange call too but in fairness I can't think of many standout 9's only Pieenar
 
gotta go with foden hes being the most impressive player ive seen this season
 
Howlett maybe, instead of Banahan?
Can't remember if he really shone in the HEC, or weather it was Magners/Amlin that I was really impressed with, but he's certainly been good this season
 
Howlett was a waste of time this year. I was thinking perhaps Trimble TBF.
 
Howlett was a waste of time this year. I was thinking perhaps Trimble TBF.

He had an excellent league campaign, 13 tries this season.

Would have had Yachvilli at nine myself, but sin é. Also, I had a look at the wiki page for the 2011 Heineken Cup try scorers. Nice nickname Johnny.
 
I was thinking Horacio Agulla or Alessana Tuilagi...

Here would be my XV

15. Nacewa
14. Ashton
13. BOD
12. Downey
11. Agulla
10. Sexton
9. Pienaar
8. Heaslip
7. Dowson
6. O'Brien
5. Cullen
4. Lawes
3. Mujati
2. Strauss
1. Tonga'uiha
 
15. Nacewa
14. Ashton
13. BOD
12. Allen/Downey
11. Tuilagi
10. Sexton
9. Pienaar
8. Picamoles
7. Dowson
6. O'Brien
5. Tchale-Watchou
4. Lawes
3. Mujati
2. Strauss
1. Tonga'uiha
 
In all honesty I think he came off a distant second best in the one-on-one matchups against Fritz, Tuilagi and Clarke.
How to you figure that? Tuilagi was pretty average against Leinster. Clarke was anonymous even when Saints were on top. I cant for the life of me remember the Toulouse match but thats some statement.
 
How to you figure that? Tuilagi was pretty average against Leinster. Clarke was anonymous even when Saints were on top. I cant for the life of me remember the Toulouse match but thats some statement.

Really?

rose+tinted+specs.jpg


It's no coincidence that the point of focus moved from BOD to Sexton when Leinster started playing significantly better.
 
Sorry, i'll repeat the question. You said he was a distant second behond some pretty anonymous performances I'm curious how you came up with that. You really think Clarke was far ahead of O'Driscoll? or Tuilagi for that matter? If so, how do you work it out?
 
Simple. I watched the games. And didn't base my entire opinion on cliché riddled Leinster-centric bias.
 
15. Nacewa (close call with Foden at heart of everything good for Leinster made their style possible)
14. Horgan (how many kick-offs did he win? Ospreys weren't good enough for Bowe. Aston dropped a ball on the 5m line with no one around. Banahan for f*** sake are you taking the mickey?
13. O'Driscoll (if you say no it's blasphemy. N ot great by his standards better then everyone else. Tuilagi? Clarke? please.)
12. Downey (finally added offloading to his game in the semi. Key to Northampton)
11. Medard (no one else really great feet.
10. Sexton (who else?)
9. Pienaar (brilliant in a great run for Ulster.)
8. Heaslip (heroic displays ecspecially against Clermont)
7. Dusautoir (4 tries probably best tackler in tournament.
6. O'Brien (no arguement)
5. Hines (brings the hard edge to Leinsters pack. Big loss)
4. Lawes (tackled anything that moved)
3. Ross (look at Leinsters scrum last year then look at this years. Did a very difficult thing changing tactics in 2nd half. Mujati very close but Ross' impact was massive.)
2. Strauss (Sensational can't wait to see him play for Ireland.)
1. Tong'uiha (man mountain)

9 Leinster, 3 Northampton, 2 Tolouse, 1 Ulster. Leinster selections not biased reflect the fact that they're in a league of their own. Northhampton closing in but where's everyone else?
 
Simple. I watched the games. And didn't base my entire opinion on cliché riddled Leinster-centric bias.
Fair enough, we all watched the games. I watched the final twice today :). But if you didnt base it on cliche riddled leinster centric bias, what did your opinion on? Was Clarke better offensively? Defensively? Tuilagi made an impression where?

Without some kind of basis for your statement I have to assume you are a subscriber to Stephen Jones of the times.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Top