• Help Support The Rugby Forum :

Heineken Cup: Quarter-finals XV

Jockstap

First XV
TRF Legend
Joined
Apr 18, 2009
Messages
1,590
http://planetrugby.com/story/0,25883,16016_6868585,00.html

All four Heineken Cup quarter-finals produced enthralling spectacles, making the selection of Planet Rugby's XV of the week all the more difficult.

What a weekend! The two all-French clashes in Spain saw attendance records broken as the Catalan and Basques fans brought an atmosphere that will long be remembered.

It could not have been closer in San Sebastian as last-year's finalists slogged it out. Toulouse had to dig very deep to hang on in extra time to set up a rematch of their semi-final clash with Leinster - this time in Dublin.

Judging by their performance in the Irish capital - and your votes on our recent poll - the Irish province are favourites to lift the trophy in Cardiff in May.

But don't discount Northampton, who are the only unbeaten team in Europe this season!

Leinster lead the way with five representatives in our line-up, Northampton and Toulouse have three each, Biarritz have two while Perpignan and Ulster both have a player amongst the backs:

15 Isa Nacewa (Leinster) - Our selection committee had a tough choice to make between Nacewa and Cédric Heymans. Both scored quite brilliant tries but the Toulouse full-back had a relatively quiet second half while Nacewa was faultless from start to finish.

14 Vincent Clerc (Toulouse) - Chris Ashton deserves a mention, especially for his part in creating Saints' winning score, but Clerc's step through the Biarritz defence to set up Toulouse's opening try was out of the top draw. For a little guy, he also put in some brave tackles.

13 David Marty (Perpignan) - Not too many stand out performers here. Jon Clarke was solid for Northampton and Tigers' Manu Tuilagi wasn't given much room to move. Brian O'Driscoll was a class act - as usual - but won't want to see the replays of Alesana Tuilagi going straight over the top of him!

12 Clément Poitrenaud (Toulouse) - We cringed when we saw Poitrenaud's name at twelve in the Toulouse team announcement, but the versatile French international showed the form that prompted Guy Novès to leave Yannick Jauzion on the bench as he made his opposite number - Charles Gimenez - look very ordinary.

11 Simon Danielli (Ulster) - Although Ulster's try came from their other wing Andrew Trimble (who was pretty good too) Danielli deserves some kudos for a number a incisive runs out wide and in midfield.

10 Jonathan Sexton (Leinster) - Another top class performance from the 25-year-old who was excellent in defence, kept his cool on the big occasion and made sure Leinster's dominance on the field was reflected on the scoreboard.

9 Lee Dickson (Northampton) - Dimitri Yachvili was brilliant for Biarritz but missed the conversion that would have won the game (albeit from the touchline) and then was charged down to hand victory to Toulouse. So we'll settle for Dickson, who scored the match-winning try for Saints.

8 Louis Picamoles (Toulouse) - Jamie Heaslip certainly gave Leicester the runaround, but when the rain came down and the going got tough in San Sebastian, Picamoles carried the ball like a monster.

7 Sean O'Brien (Leinster) - Once again O'Brien showed that he is one of Europe's top flankers and made the Tigers suffer at the breakdown. George Smith had one of his better games for Toulon.

6 Magnus Lund (Biarritz) - Unlike his fellow former England international Iain Balshaw - who had a shocker - the "Viking" was on top form. The rematch of last year's final turned into a real battle of attrition and Lund was still charging in the font lines after 100 minutes.

5 Leo Cullen (Leinster) - We picked Cullen as one to watch before the game and the veteran second rower didn't disappoint as he made life hell for his former club in the line-outs and was also immense in defence. A mention too for Toulon's Dean Schofield who was instrumental in creating a try for his skipper Joe van Niekerk.

4 Courtney Lawes (Northampton) - A man-of-the-match performance from the England lock who was brutal in the tight stuff and impressed with his all-round athleticism.

3 Sylvain Marconnet (Biarritz) - When Biarritz needed their pack to take control, France's most-capped prop stepped up to the plate. The Basque scrum dominant after half-time and effectively dragged their team back into contention.

2 Richardt Strauss (Leinster) - One of the hardest choices to make as William Servat and Guilhem Guirado were tireless grafters for Toulouse and Perpignan respectively. But the former Cheetahs' eye-catching off-loads and barnstorming runs couldn't be ignored.

1 Soane Tonga'uiha (Northampton) - Props aren't supposed to be regular try scorers, but it seems no one has told Saints' Tongan tank. Three minutes after kick-off and boom! He strikes again.
 
Agulla should be on there, he was the best player in the Leinster/Leicester match, bar Nacewa



Also: Another match where SOB was apparently God, but I only saw him two or three times :S
 
When people care.

Pienaar was better than Dickson in that match. And Trimble better than Danielli. Aguilla doesn't deserve a spot as he got depantsed.

Actually, maybe Danielli was better than Trimble. Just remembered that drop.
 
Agulla should be on there, he was the best player in the Leinster/Leicester match, bar Nacewa



Also: Another match where SOB was apparently God, but I only saw him two or three times :S

In fairness to SOB he hit massive amounts of rucks , turned over lovely ball and won some vital hard yards , nowhere near his best performance but excellent nonetheless ,

Agulla deserves to be there ..and I thought BOD was pretty solid on defence and turned over a good amount of ball considering he had about 40 stone of the Tualagi family to deal with
 
Forcibly stripped of one's trousers, usually in public.

http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=depantsed

Bum.jpg
 
<object width="640" height="510"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/0X3CkcLkSuo?fs=1&amp;hl=en_GB&amp;rel=0"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/0X3CkcLkSuo?fs=1&amp;hl=en_GB&amp;rel=0" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="640" height="510"></embed></object>

In better quality.
 
Yeah i felt weird googling "Agulla's bum". That'll forever haunt my google search history
 
Really I don't think any Ulster player deserves a spot though they were out of their depht. I think Danielli was ok Trimble was mixed with good moments and his usual crap. Aguilla I have to agree looked very dangerous and I think Ashton was best winger of 4 on Sunday.
 
Yeah i felt weird googling "Agulla's bum". That'll forever haunt my google search history
Especially when your Mum borrows your laptop to look up her favourite tennis player and types in "A....g.....OH DEAR GOD WHAT HAS HE BEEN GOOGLEING?!"
 
Really I don't think any Ulster player deserves a spot though they were out of their depht. I think Danielli was ok Trimble was mixed with good moments and his usual crap. Aguilla I have to agree looked very dangerous and I think Ashton was best winger of 4 on Sunday.

munstermuffin said:
Must say I was impressed by Ulster. Northampton were better team and deserved the win but Ulster couldve won it if they took chances but they put up a sublime battle.

?


Sometimes I genuinely don't know what the **** you're shiteing on about Munstermuffin.
 
I was impressed that they put up battle on day as I feared it couldve been a big defeat. But I still think Ulster are not up with top teams yet.
Also I was commenting on team of quarter finals.
 
Irregardless of whether Ulster as a constituent whole are at that level or not, the question is did anyone from Ulster perform to that level on that day. Two very different questions.

And I've got to disagree with Bullit, Dickson disappointed me and was slightly flat, the only thing Pienaar did wrong more or less all day was one wonky pass in the build up to Danielli's non-try. Neither of them had anything to do with Ulster's pack getting eroded, which was down to some spectecularly savage games from the likes of Tiny and Lawes, BJ Botha not being properly fit and not having all the players we'd have liked there. Mainly the former tbh, I'm not sure how much difference a fully fit Botha would have made there.

In fact, all the Ulster backs had good games, and some had very good games. Shame the pack didn't go as well, but I'm mainly over that...
 
Irregardless of whether Ulster as a constituent whole are at that level or not, the question is did anyone from Ulster perform to that level on that day. Two very different questions.

And I've got to disagree with Bullit, Dickson disappointed me and was slightly flat, the only thing Pienaar did wrong more or less all day was one wonky pass in the build up to Danielli's non-try. Neither of them had anything to do with Ulster's pack getting eroded, which was down to some spectecularly savage games from the likes of Tiny and Lawes, BJ Botha not being properly fit and not having all the players we'd have liked there. Mainly the former tbh, I'm not sure how much difference a fully fit Botha would have made there.

In fact, all the Ulster backs had good games, and some had very good games. Shame the pack didn't go as well, but I'm mainly over that...
That is a fair point but I still think Ulster (if a clinical team) would've done better. We have to remember they didn't score in final 47 mins of the game. That isn't good enough at this stage and shows a weak spot in performance.
I can agree with you Peat that I don't think Dickinson was standout 9 but did out-do Ruan on day mainly due to his pack were dominant.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest posts

Top